Operation Cast Lead was launched in Gaza 18 days ago to curtail rocket launches into the southern portion of the state of Israel, and the death toll is approaching 1,000. Issues of proportionality, media access and humanitarian relief have surfaced, and leaders from both sides of the issue are taking a stance.
William Bernstein, president and CEO of the Jewish Federation of South Palm Beach County, said he believes the issue of proportionality to be absurd.
“Hamas has launched 11,000 rockets over the years and put millions of Israelis’ safety at risk, and that seems fairly out of proportion. The Jewish people and the Jewish state have no animosity toward the people of Gaza, but we do have serious concerns about the philosophy of their radical terrorist leadership,” he said.
Altaf Ali, executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relation’s Miami chapter, said everyone has a right to defend against aggression, but the number of civilian causalities is unacceptable.
“It is a disproportionate response against people unable to defend themselves, and I believe the response was handled poorly,” he said. He continued by saying that true Muslims believe Hamas’ tactics to be deplorable, but that concerns over a backlash may be justified.
“It is absolutely true that violence begets violence, and I think that is a valid concern,” he said.
Another sticking point has been media access, or lack thereof, and Bernstein said the criticism seems unfounded.
“I’m not sure what the lack of access refers to because I see images coming out of the region daily. If there is a block of any kind, I am sure it is because of safety issues and the inherent difficulty of this type of combat,” he said.
A Jan. 9 letter from Kiyo Akasaka, Under-Secretary-General for Communications and Public Information, to Israel’s Ambassador to the UN Gabriela Shalev reads as follows: “The chief of communications and public information for the United Nations called Thursday on the Israeli Government to ensure immediate access for international media into Gaza, stressing the need for full and independent coverage of events unfolding in the territory which has been the target of an Israeli offensive launched nearly two weeks ago.”
Ali said that more media coverage and transparency is the answer and the cornerstone of any democracy.
“If access is denied, one has to wonder why that would be the case. The press play a vital watchdog function, and it is in everyone’s best interest to have as much information as possible,” he said.
POSTED IN: None
> Discuss this entry