
Adam Lambert had the judges raving with his over-the-top rendition of "Black or White." (Credit: Fox)
By Perrie Samotin
psamotin@am-ny.com
Season eight of American Idol officially kicked off last night with the top 13 singing tracks by the King of Pop himself, Michael Jackson. A tad unfair, maybe, to have them sing songs that most of us identify so closely with the original artist, but whatever. While some contestants sounded like they were drunk and singing in a private room at iBop Karaoke, others — mainly Lil Rounds, Danny Gokey and Adam Lambert — killed.
We'll skip the bizarre hilarity of the runway-inspired judge's entrance and cut right to the chase.
Lil Rounds kicked things off with the popular, if a bit safe, "The Way You Make me feel." Her singing was soulful and the judges thought it was a solid way to kick things off. Simon hated her fashion-forward look, but whatever, he only seems to likes girls that wear trollop-y getups, so that was expected.
Scott McIntyre, who's been blind since birth, follows Rounds with a snooze-fest version of "Keep the Faith." He's playing the piano, which is nice, but his voice is grating. Sorry, but he's not a pop star. If this were "Billy Joel Idol," maybe he'd have a shot. We can't really complain though, because at least he's not singing Bruce Hornsby's "Mandolin Rain" again (arguably the lamest song ever written). The judges were meh, praising his skills but admitting they were hoping for more.
Next up was Michael McDonald Danny Gokey, who needs to invest in some chicer glasses so as not to look like he wandered out of a late-nineties coffee house. After injecting "P.Y.T" with his usual brand of rasp (and displaying spastic, kicky moves), the judges loved him. In fact, Paula freaks out, tears up and starts making the grandiose predictions that are fast becoming her Season 8 signature.
The next few: Oil-rigger Michael Sarver, teenager Jasmine Murray and outdated, acoustic guitar-playing Kris Allan are whatever. Sarver takes the cheesy route and croons "You Are Not Alone," but his voice is pretty good. America will like him because he's blue collar and there's no country singer to otherwise take their vote. The other two are annoying and aren't going to win, so you don't need to know what they sang.
Husky-voiced, crimson-haired "rocker" Allison Iraheta, who is apparently 16, tells us she used to sing on a "stage" at a local Latino department store and gets down with a gritty version of "Give in to Me." She's way cooler than some of the other contestants (ScottJasmineKris) and the judges commented on her confidence and likened her to a dark horse.
Anoop Desai, the surprise 13th contestant, completely bashed his chances of moving along in the competition by choosing "Beat It," a stupid song when it's not sung by MJ. Brow furrowed and arms pumping, he acted the part, telling us to beat it. Looks like he'll be taking his own advice tonight. It's quite sad, actually, because he kicked ass on other songs.
We have no idea what Puerto Rico's own Jorge Nunez warbled his way through. All we know is that we think we heard him sing it on the Lido Deck of a Carnival Cruise we took in 2002.
Megan Joy Corkery — who looks like she escaped from her post at Williamsburg's Sound Fix Records — channeled her inner Duffy and shimmy-shook her way through "Rockin' Robin." Her voice is weird and retro, and the judges were split.
OMG, Adam Lambert is so theater! We could totally see him strutting across his high school stage belting out some teen angsty "Spring Awakening" style jam. He's definitely an entertainer, though. His manic, over-the-top performance of "Black or White" was memorable and resulted in the judges dying over how amazing he was. Paula, of course, cried and started a sentence with "never in the history of this show..."
Matt Giraud so wants to be Justin Timberlake. He played the piano and sang "Human Nature" pretty well, although his falsetto could use a little tuning up. The judges dig him, as will lots of female viewers, we think.
Last up was tiny Alexis Grace who sang the hard-edged "Dirty Diana." We thought it sort of sucked and disappointed and didn't compare to her performance during the semi-finals, but the judges thought it to be OK, though not as good as she may have thought it was, said Simon.
Who's out? If it were up to us, it's be Scott and Jasmine.Two contestants are said to be out tonight, with a "surprise" addition to the show. Rumors point to it being in the form of a face-off between the lowest vote-getters. Tune in tomorrow for the latest.