My daughter, Lily, the 5-year-old, keeps coming home with comments, pictures, and songs about holidays we don't celebrate.
I've been pulling Hanukkah art out of her backpack. Last week it was a lovely crayon-colored dreidel. She had a song to go with it.
Her teacher must be really into holidays.
All month, Lily has been commenting and asking questions about Hanukkah. As a family that celebrates Christmas, I consider Hanukkah a holiday of another religion, and one that I figured Lily was too young to be exposed to without confusion at this age.
I'm not closed-minded at all. My dad's half of the family is Jewish. It's my heritage.
But a child's mind is quite narrow and easily boggled, and I choose to focus on the religion and holidays that I want our family to celebrate.
Anyway, isn't it a sacred right of parents to teach our very young children about the family's beliefs, without someone else offering competing information at this age?
I don't think the teacher talks about the holidays in a religious context. But it's kind of hard to avoid when they come home and ask why we don't celebrate Hanukkah.
This morning, while eating a bagel, Lily asked, "Do we celebrate Kwanzaa?''
Kwanzaa had just been created when I was her age, growing up in Rockwell City, Iowa.
"No,'' I said.
"Why don't we?'' she wanted to know.
I started to think ... Maybe I should re-consider my gut reaction. Some of the ideas the other holidays are based on are concepts I want to encourage: self-determination, faith, creativity, family unity, and religious freedom.
Maybe I could study up on these other holidays, glean the best ideas from them, and offer a hodge-podge at our house, as part of Christmas.
Or maybe not.
I tell my 12-year-old about other religions and cultures. I want him to know these things, to be exposed to them, to be respectful of others' beliefs.
But the constitutional freedoms we fight for in this country don't belong to kindergartners.
They've got no freedom of speech, that's for sure. And I don't think they should have freedom of religion.
> Please comment