What are we trying to accomplish with education in Broward County? Do we want our children to be able to get jobs here and to communicate with their fellow man, in Spanish if need be? Or do we want to continue with this English-only emphasis and expect our kids to just point to an American flag when someone tries asking them something in Spanish?
My son enrolled in Spanish I at Seminole Middle School in Plantation, where just like most schools in this melting pot, there is a substantial Hispanic population. Spanish ONE.
Spanish UNO.
Parents, if you saw that your child was taking Spanish I, would you assume that there was a Spanish ZERO where students learned Spanish for an entire year?
My son is the only student in his 7th grade Spanish I class who hasn't already had an entire year of the language.
Concerned about his grade, he asked me to help him get placed in a more basic Spanish class. Sure, that's reasonable, no problem. They must have made a mistake, I thought.
I called the 7th grade guidance counselor. He had no sympathy at all and instead lept to the idea that maybe my son should be removed from all his advanced classes. He suggested I meet with all 8 of my son's teachers to see if he's having trouble in all the classes!
Hello? Are you and I speaking the same language, Mr. Guidance Counselor?
I told the gentlemen my son is not having difficulties in all of his classes, nor does it indicate a learning disability that he hasn't picked up a new language in three weeks.
The man said there is no easier Spanish class, and if you don't take 6th grade Spanish at that school, you essentially have no choice but to enter the new language in 7th grade far behind.
The class qualifies for high school credit, so the man kept telling me, "this is a high school class.''
Hello? Does high school Spanish I start on some higher plane and assume the participants are well versed in Spanish?
Somehow, I think not.
And what if you move to the school in 7th grade? You're just screwed?
Um, well, the guy replied, we've nver really encountered this situation. And you could take sign language, he offered.
SIGN LANGUAGE. Yes, at that moment I thought some sign language might actually help me convey my thoughts.
However, I wondered, is sign language the skill that local employers are seeking when they advertise "language skills preferred''? If a Spanish speaking customer walks in, what is the hand sign my Creed could use for "I only know one language?'
Turns out that unless you are in the top of the academics at my son's middle school, you are not even eligible for Spanish class.
Am I alone in thinking that if our children are going to stay in South Florida as adults, they will need Spanish speaking skills?
Spanish should be required and should start in middle school. At the very least it should be an elective open to all kids, not just the academic elite.
> Please comment