Of dog attacks and dangerous breeds
Dog bite attacks -- like the one on Friday, in which a 10-year-old Davie boy was severely bitten by two Rottweilers when he jumped into a neighbor’s backyard to retrieve a ball -- always jump-start the never-ending debate: Are certain breeds vicious? Expect to see folks from two camps at city commission and council meetings soon: those who insist “dangerous” types of dogs should be banished from their neighborhoods; and others who insist there are no bad breeds, only bad owners.
While owner Victor Cantelmo was cited for not having his pets licensed or vaccinated, the police have released his Rottweilers from quarantine, ruling the incident an accident. The dogs were in Cantelmo’s yard, behind 6-foot fence with a gate fastened with a security cord and a warning sign posted. Broward County animal officials will decide the animals’ fate.
Now State Rep. Perry Thurston, D-Plantation, says he will push for state rules that would give municipalities more leeway in banning specific breeds.
What do you think? Should some breeds be outlawed in residential neighborhoods? If so, which ones and how would they be selected? Should there be more restrictions on owners, as far as licensing, warning signs or fencing?
Rottweilers and pit bulls were cited in a 2000 Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association paper as the dogs most likely to fatally attack humans. But a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention study of fatal canine attacks on humans over 20 years concluded there was no foolproof way to identify at-risk breeds – and that any dog has the potential to be vicious. In 2001, a four-pound Pomeranian attacked and killed an infant in Los Angeles.
The Davie case does have some of what attorney Kenneth Phillips, of Dog Bite Law, identifies as dog attack danger signs: There was more than one dog in their own yard with no master present, and both were males (male dogs are more than twice as likely to bite than females).
CDC statistics show that the majority of dog bite victims are children, and the face is the dog’s most common target. Good parent behavior, along with responsible pet owner behavior, is important. The CDC advises teaching your children never to approach unfamiliar dogs and that all play with dogs should be supervised.









ANGIE BRENNAN, a Sun-Sentinel page designer,
lives with four dogs and one boyfriend. And has a lifetime of animal stories to share.
DIANE LADE, a reporter on the Sun-Sentinel's Help Team, has lived with cats, dogs, reptiles, fish, an iguana, and an armadillo.
CYNDI METZGER, editor of the Sun-Sentinel's Outlook section, is smitten with Bella, her poodle who regularly ignores requests to sit, stay and get off the ivory-colored sofa.
JOHN TANASYCHUK, a Sun-Sentinel lifestyle writer, has lived with cats as long as he can remember. He and his partner currently share their home with three.
