South Florida Sun-Sentinel


« World Rabies Day: Where to get low-cost shots and info. | Main | Are tiny grain mites infesting your pet's food? »

Pets still in the driver's seat in California and Florida.

Paris Hilton can breathe a little easier...

California's Governator over the weekend vetoed a law that would have prohibited driving while holding a dog (or any animal) in your lap or in your arms. Violators could have been fined as much as $150.
This from the same Arnold Schwarzenegger who just banned texting while driving.

The legislation had been dubbed "the Paris Hilton Law," given the celebutant's practice of motoring around town with her four-legged accessories.

parishilton540%5B1%5D.jpg

However, it is illegal in California to allow a dog to ride unsecured in the back of a pickup truck.
Unlike Florida.

Florida's motor vehicle laws don't address securing animals in cars or trucks. But Walton County, in the northern part of the state, did pass legislation this summer
requiring animals to either be tethered or in a carrier when in the back of open-bed vehicles. As I recall, Broward County considered a similar ordinance years ago, but never passed it.

What do you think? Does Florida, or county governments, need to deal with how drivers carry their pets? Have you seen potentially dangerous situations involving motorists and animals?

Here's the California story from the Sacremento Bee.


Schwarzenegger vetoes bill forbidding drivers to hold pets

By Jim Sanders and Kevin Yamamura
from the Sacramento Bee, Sept. 28, 2008

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger vetoed legislation Saturday that would have banned motorists from holding a live animal in their laps or arms.

The Republican governor gave no specific explanation other than to blame his veto of Assembly Bill 2233 on the recent budget dispute.

As he has with six dozen other bills this signing period, Schwarzenegger attached a uniform four-sentence message explaining he is signing bills only of the "highest priority" during the condensed signing period caused by the 85-day budget delay.

Talk show host Rush Limbaugh and other conservatives ridiculed the lap-dog measure as excessive government and dubbed it the "Paris Hilton Bill" in honor of the celebrity dog lover.

Violators would have faced a base fine of $35, which could have risen to $150 with state and county fees.

Assemblyman Bill Maze, the bill's author, said he proposed AB 2233 after seeing a Tulare County woman driving with three dogs on her lap.
"One had its feet on the steering wheel and the other two were leaning over her left arm," said Maze, R-Visalia.

A traffic collision at 40 mph can hurtle a 25-pound dog through a vehicle with the force of a 1,000-pound object, according to a legislative analysis of the bill.

"You've got a live animal that has a mind of its own," Maze said. "It can get tangled in the steering wheel or pinned between your knees. It can create a real hazard for yourself and everyone else."

But Sacramentan Kurt Reiswig, 70, opposed the measure as a "nanny government" attempt to regulate personal behavior that should be left to common sense. Lawmakers simply can't ban every driver distraction – from eating to changing a radio station – that can divert attention from the road, he said.

"Next thing, they'll say we've got to have seat belts for the dog," Reiswig said.

Schwarzenegger signed 114 bills and vetoed 95 on Saturday. Among the bills he signed was Assembly Bill 2168 by Assemblyman Dave Jones, D-Sacramento, which allows chefs to buy produce from farmers markets to cook restaurant meals as long as they obtain a memo detailing the food's origin. The governor has 557 bills left to consider by Tuesday, according to spokeswoman Rachel Cameron.

The governor vetoed the lap-dog bill despite signing other restrictions in the past two years that ban drivers from text messaging and using phones without a hands-free device. State law currently allows drivers to be cited if their vision is obstructed or a distraction causes them to violate a rule of the road – but not simply for holding an animal.

Pets must be secured in the back of a pickup but can roam freely inside a vehicle.
California Highway Patrol statistics show that four people were killed and 346 others injured in collisions from 2001 to 2007 due to driver inattention caused by an animal. No breakdown exists of how many were in their owner's lap.

Critics contend that government should not dictate who sits in their lap – period.
Quieting a whining or scared pet on your lap, while driving, can be safer than to be distracted by an animal's barking, fidgeting or misbehavior in a back seat, opponents said.

Several Sacramento-area residents interviewed near a local dog park said AB 2233 would have been a positive step.
Darrin Richards, 41, said his mixed-breed dog rides in the back seat.

"If we can't drive with our cell phone, we shouldn't be able to drive with a dog in our lap, either," Richards said.

Nationwide Mutual Insurance found in a 2006 survey that 8 percent of drivers had held a pet while behind the wheel.


POSTED IN: None

Discuss this entry

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.trb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/96720

UGC PetsShare your photos!

Give your furry loved ones the attention they deserve and send us cute pictures of your pets.

> Get started

About This Blog

This blog is all about living with pets. A place to help understand, care for and have fun with your animals.

Share your stories about your pets’ funny but heartwarming quirks. Show off your videos and photos.

And we’re not only about dogs and cats. Whether you're living with rabbits, birds, reptiles, fish and anything else that constitutes a non-human companion, Sit, Stay, Speak! is here for you.


ANGIE BRENNAN, a Sun-Sentinel page designer, lives with four dogs and one boyfriend. And has a lifetime of animal stories to share.
More
DIANE LADE, a reporter on the Sun-Sentinel's Help Team, has lived with cats, dogs, reptiles, fish, an iguana, and an armadillo.
More
CYNDI METZGER, editor of the Sun-Sentinel's Outlook section, is smitten with Bella, her poodle who regularly ignores requests to sit, stay and get off the ivory-colored sofa.
More
JOHN TANASYCHUK, a Sun-Sentinel lifestyle writer, has lived with cats as long as he can remember. He and his partner currently share their home with three.
More

Subscribe by email

Get every blog entry sent to you!
Simply enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Or subscribe through an RSS reader.

Powered by Movable Type 3.36
Hosted by LivingDot

Add Sit, Stay, Speak! Where South Florida talks pets | Sun-Sentinel Blogs to Technorati Favorites