South Florida Sun-Sentinel
For more Sun-Sentinel music coverage, click here.

« They're Coming to Take Me Away Ha-Haaa! | Main | Do something, already: Britney Spears at Mansion »

Of great gigs and big pigs: Roger Waters at Sound Advice

Pink Floyd songs generally come in two moods: anger and melancholy. Roger Waters used to sing most of the angry songs, hissing at “certain teachers” on Happiest Days of Our Lives, while David Gilmour was the melancholic one, “swimming in a fishbowl” on Wish You Were Here.

Yet there was Waters on Friday night at Sound Advice Amphitheatre, west of West Palm Beach, singing Gilmour's Wish You Were Here as wistfully as his hard-edged voice would allow.

Waters, 62, didn’t assume too many of Gilmour’s vocal duties on the first U.S. date of "Dark Side of the Moon Live.” Touring singer and guitarist David Kilminster was the de-facto replacement -- and a capable one -- for Waters’ former bandmate. But the absence of Gilmour, or any ex-colleague of Waters, was not so glaring in this welcome revival of classic Pink Floyd.

Friday's showpiece was Dark Side of the Moon. That 1973 album, a masterpiece of total immersion, represented a peak in the Waters-Gilmour partnership. It’s also become one of the best-selling records of all time, handed down like an heirloom and, unfairly or not, celebrated more for its technical brilliance than its themes of alienation.

The Waters-led band played Dark Side in its entirety, in order, on Friday night, and bookended it with other material. The arranging, playing and singing were impeccable throughout a 26-song set. Dark Side was by no means the only source of highlights during a sold-out performance for nearly 20,000 people.

The change in tone of Mother, from 1979’s The Wall, still came as jolt, as Waters’ voice rose from an insistent plea (“Mother, do you think she’s dangerous to me?”) to a demanding scream (“Mother, will she tear your little boy apart?”). Shine On You Crazy Diamond, an endearing tribute to Pink Floyd’s founding guitarist, the late Syd Barrett, swayed between gentle verses and a booming chorus.

Some concertgoers in Europe have said that Waters is occasionally using pre-recorded vocals to buttress his singing. But if that was the case on Friday, the pairing of Waters’ voice with any taped tracks was too seamless to be detected from the seats

But then, Pink Floyd was the epitome of rock as a form of perfectionism. Dark Side of the Moon is still one of the most exquisite-sounding albums ever made, and while it’s not bereft of emotion or meaning, its overall effect is trance-inducing. Dark Side is ultimately an escape vehicle, an immaculate sonic cocoon — however much it addresses greed (Money), modern-day paranoia (Brain Damage) and existential dread (Time).

But those three songs were timely on Friday, since the chaotic world they describe hasn’t gotten any calmer since 1973. Waters made his topical references more explicit during the dreamy-sounding Us and Them, flashing images of war planes and oil machinery on the video screen.

The Great Gig in the Sky had no claim on current events. It was simply a stand-alone, showstopping performance, with its spacey gospel aria sung majestically by backing vocalist Carole Kenyon.

Along with first-rate sound, the concert boasted tremendous visual pop. The old, push-button tabletop radio that served as a motif was nothing but pixels, but the screen showing it was so stunningly high-def, the radio looked real enough to touch. There were deep-space vistas — a nod to those “Laser Floyd” planetarium shows? — and acid trails and grainy reels of people and places.

As it happened, the most eye-catching prop of the night was also the lowest-tech: a giant, graffiti-covered pig floated over the crowd during a song called Sheep. If Waters’ anti-war, anti-Bush sentiments weren’t obvious to anyone one before that moment, seeing the the name of the sitting president printed across the big pig’s posterior removed all doubt.

POSTED IN: Reviews (20)

Discuss this entry

Comments

I can't believe no one else has anything to say about this epic concert. But well said, Piccoli.
Having seen Roger Waters before I feared the promised Dark Side Of The Moon set would fall short of the real thing, but it was pretty evident to me as soon as I heard Mother that I wasn't in for an evening of dissapointments.
Thanks for mentioning Sheep. Animal is one of those albums that doesn't leave you unchanged.
I do feel, however, is necessary to start a petition to keep the beer guys on the law at Sound Advice from blowing those annoying whistles in the middle of a brilliant performance. "I got beer! I got cold ones!" in the middle of The Great Gig in the Sky while Kenyon is about to give me a heart attack with her stand-alone performance makes me want to throw the beer cart off the hill...

Just saw Waters in Oakland, California last night and posted a review on my Blog at http://isorski.blogspot.com/. Enjoy!

Post a comment

To help keep spam off our site, please enter the letter "s" in the field below:

About the Author

SEAN PICCOLI joined the Sun-Sentinel as pop music writer in 1996. He previously worked in Washington, D.C., covering news, politics, entertainment and culture ...

More

Subscribe by email

We'll send you every post.
Just enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Or subscribe through an RSS reader.

Powered by Movable Type 3.36
Hosted by LivingDot

Add to Technorati Favorites

Music Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory