The CW Source

BRUCAS! ALL THE WAY.

Okay, People are trying to say Peyton is admirable and "strong", HELLO!

have u seen teh show? shes a complete cry baby and likes to hide in the shadows. She OBViOUSLY loves Lucas, or wants him, but she doesn't tell Lucas, instead when Brooke trys to get Lucas back, she tells him to be "careful"... and i don't know about you but when she decies to sleep in Lucas's bed, is it becuase she's scared or ebcuase she wants to see him??? HMM!

and shes a complete homewrecker, wtf is she doing telling Brooke she still has feelinsg for Lucas when she supposedly, wasn't going to try anything? YES SHE GOT SHOT, IN THE DAMN LEG, NOT A FATAL WOUND. i don't mind her telling Lucas how she feels, but do u have to make-out with him?? TWICE??
WTH!

FUCK OFF LEYTON.

BRUCAS ALL THE WAYYY!

on brooke's side 100% if peyton wasn't gonna try anything with lucas why tell brooke that she loves him then. She could have kept it to herself instead of taking brooke through the painful memory of what happened before that wasn't fair it was pointless for peyton to tell brooke that unless she did wanna make something of her feelings for lucas!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sorry i'ma total brooke fan she rocks

Brooke 110%. She is the best chracter on the show and such a good friend to peyton. But all peyton does is whine and think about herself. Nd Brucas is waay better then LP ever will be. No matter whose endgame. BL will always be the best couple on oth IMO.

bruckas=truelove brukas all the way

I love lucas and brook togather peyton is ok but needs to get a life and find someone elts.Brooke and lucas are ment to be so mark let them date and get married peyton even said in season 5 that she was in love with the idea of her and lucas so i say go brooke and lucas

HAHA you know guys, i watched some old clips from the first three seasons and thought that brucas were SOOO SWEET TOGETHER! but now lucas lookes like crap, that hair and his weird face expressions, and the fact that he is a totally different person when he is with peyton makes him sooo unatractive. I think he and peyton looks like brother and sister, they have no chemistry when they act and they are a boring couple to wathc because they can NEVER just be happy about anything but now i dont mind if they are together i just laugh my ass of every time i see the two of them. Brooke should be with someone way cuter than lucas, and someone who doesent change peronality like he does, i think if the show gives brooke a new cute boyfriend ( like steven;) then people will watch to see them not leyton, leyton bores me and they cant even kiss but whenever brooke is in a relationship she spunks it up! i still want brucas back in the end, but for now i dont care. peyton and lucas makes asses out of themselfs and its just so wrong seeing them together but they are a missmatch, you guys can have leyton now because i now realise that you loose ! you want peyton to be the funny one, the one people like to watch but now that she is with lucas noone wants to watch her! HAHAHA its just so funny...leyton it cracks me up i call them pucas cuss they make me puke but whatever...they can have their brother sister relationship and brooke can get a new boy who will tell her that he loves her then not just change...and by the way...im gonna keep voting for brooke because she was right all along!

i think peyton belongs with lucas not brook because thay are such a cute couple

OMG brucas.
watch the first seasons.
lucas is IN LOVE WITH BROOKE
2cd season, IN LOVE.
its not supposed to be peyton and lucaS
WHO LOOK LIKE BROTHER AND SISTER.
its all about brucas

I LOVE YOU BROOKE!

Who would want a boyfriend stealer, why is brooke, peyton's friend again after she has stealed her boyfriend over and over again. Peyton is such a ***** because she keeps lying to brooke for example in season 2 brooke said she wants to start a relationship with lucas but is afraid to get her heart broken again. Peyton told brooke that she doesn't have to worry because for one thing, peyton will not sleep with lucas again. What a BIG FAT LIAR.

I think that brooke sleeping with nathan was the stupidest idea. it was stupid how all of a sudden there is a sex flim of brooke and nathan. VERY VERY VERY stupid. Whats with peyton, its not like nathan was with her. Peyton is a boyfriend stealer. How could she take her best friend's boyfriend. what kind of friend is she. What a ***** anyways brooke rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

One Tree Hill would not be nearly as appealing without the relationship of ... Lucas and Peyton! In my opinion they are a better match than Lucas and Brooke. If you look closely you will see their love is and has always been a part of the show even when Lucas was "in love" with Brooke. Lucas has always cared about Peyton and anyone who says differently is lying to themselves. This couple sends a strong message of love and hope and persistence. Brooke and Lucas had a connection, but I don't think it is one that could have withstood time. As we have seen this past season all the characters seem to have found their right place. Lucas and Peyton, Nathan and Haley, & Brooke and Chase (although I don't think he will stick around). I won't say bad things about Brooke even though I could. All I will say is that I think when she "fell in love" with Lucas in the first season she was only infatuated with the idea of a guy that didn't use her, as she was WELL aquainted with. Brooke loved the idea of Lucas but I don't think she ever felt the same way Peyton feels about him. I think that is why Brooke broke up with Lucas in the beginning of season 4. Now I don't believe I have said anything that could be contradicted or argued over, but be my guest.

hey brooke shouldnt have slept with nathan wether he and peyton broke up or not he shouldnt have done it in the first place and seccond of all brooke shouldnt have started to go out with lucas when peyton had started to develop feelings for him and its not peytons fault that she kissed lucas coz he was getting bored of whiney and clingy brooke, brooke should have know better than to go out with lucas wen her best freind has feelings for him. and brooke is soooo annoying with her clinging ness and winging she sooooo a spoilt brat plus peytons problems are more important than hers anyway and lucas is a good bloke for helping peyton anyway so stuff all that in ure pipe an smoke it!!! and dont let the door hit u on the ass on ure way out !!

dont be all bitchy bout peyton , peyton is ace broke is a spoiled brat and needs to be put in her place lucas and peyton are great together and peyton may have had sum tough times and that doesnt make her a liar plus lucas cam onto peyton and peyton didnt want anythin to escalate so dont be all nasy bout peyton!

Brooke is amazing, she's the best, she deserves lucas more than peyton, peyton is so boring and she's a liar, she lies to have lucas, brooke is brave and she's a good friend, lucas is so happy with her, and brooke deserves to be happy with an amazing guy, lucas can be this guy, the lucas season 2 and 3 was this guy, i hope the lucas season 5 will be again

Brooke! Peyton is a pathetic character. Always in need for help and she plays the victim. Even though theres no lucas thing. I still love brooke she's pretty, smart, creative, clever, funny,forgiving sincere and most of all independent. she can stand for herself. TEAM BROOKE

well said the person below me. i agree with everything u said except that i understand the part when she kiss lucas when she was dieing.but other than that i agree completely.the both have them have too much problems. They were better off as friends.the writer try to make the chemistry work by givin them the muffin or the cookie fight but that couldn't out do what brucas have because thier chemistry are unbelivable.♥♥brucas♥♥

You know, Lucas and Peyton's fans basically said that Peyton deserves him more, why? Because most of the time, when Lucas and Brooke fight, in the end it always has to be Lucas who would sacrifice/give up/say sorry. And when it's Peyton and Lucas, they're equal. Whilst with Brooke, it's they're not equal.

Or so they said. Really.

Brooke and Lucas, they're natural. When they were together, they made each other HAPPY. It was almost all fun, and nothing else mattered, as long as they were happy TOGETHER. The fact that Lucas who usually would have to say sorry whenever they fight, well that's not how they do it. They're equal in a way that they help each other to stand, and they're happy doing it. Sure, they have their ups and downs, but one can't simply deny that their chemistry was unbelievable.

Brooke will always be Brooke, always cheery and happy most of the time, because you see, she's a constant. Lucas, well, he's Lucas. And we all know Lucas got lots of problems, but that's okay, because Brooke was always there for him. She's happy, she makes him happy, and then he's happy, and they're both happy at the end of the day. And when Brooke is sad, Lucas is the only man that can really really make her smile back. And he understands her. He knows she's really trying hard to be a better person and a better girlfriend.

But no, Peyton wasn't really thinking straight when she slowly started to snatch him back. She wasn't thinking about her best friend.. (forever?) at all. She didn't think about how her best friend would have felt if she does what she was doing, and basically she really just wasn't thinking of how much Brooke loved her, and wouldn't do all these kind of things to her (No, don't you start talking about the Nathan and Brooke thing, YOU KNOW Peyton and Nathan were already broken up!), and hell, this is how she pays back all the friendship and helps Brooke gave her? And what a good moment too! When she was most vulnerable, almost dying you say. And Lucas has always been a good person. He knew that Peyton needed him, and Peyton is/was his really close friend, if not his best friend after Haley. And so yeah. But really. Peyton and Lucas, they are both very sad person. And thats just not good.

But whatever really. I actually liked ONE TREE HILL for the series itself, not because of the pairing. And even IF I liked the series for the pairing, the pairing would be Nathan AND Haley thank you very much.

Since I've stopped watching this series, well I could safely say that I DID like Brooke and Lucas more than I've ever liked Peyton and Lucas. To me Peyton and Lucas, they complete each other in a sense that they both need help. And they're the best friends type really, it's just wrong. While with Brooke, it was completely different, and without doubt, wayy better chemistry. Alas, in the end it really is up to the director. Lol. So while we're quarreling like monkeys here, the director had probably long made up his mind on who's going to be with who, if you get what I mean.. XD!

hey, i just wanted to say i watched a video on youtube about lucas brooke and peyton. first of all, what the hell is up with lucas hair??? he was so hot in the first season and now he looks like gunther from friends with longer hair. and now that he is making out with a girl that looks like his sister its not much beetter, brooke made him look good, when he is with peyton it makes me wanna puke.

OK no I think peyton should get Lucas okay first off Brooke slept with Chris Keller and was non-exclusive dating Lucas too okay and Peyton didn't do anything of that maybe it was wrong she kissed him when they were at the motel and they didn't tell Brooke cause that was really wrong but I still think that Peyton she get him and stay with him!

to megan FYI do u ever seen hilarie without makeup she looks way older that sophia.you should see sophia without make up she gorgeous just the same.and brooke does have serious problems maybe not as peyton. the writers may have not hurt her physically but they hurt her emotionally alot and getting hurt emotional is way worst than getting hurt physically.to the leyton fan you have ur fun now.because if brooke gave him to peyton she can take back. so i'm all for brucas."pretty girl"hehe

brucas!

Okay, 1st of all. I love the show not the Brucas and Leyton thing. In fact, I like Naley. I don't really like Brucas OR Leyton. Peyton and Lucas liked each other at first, but Peyton got scared of a relationship becuz of all the deaths she faced she is afraid to get close to someone. And Brooke was supportive of that but she shouldn't have gone out with Lucas then especially when Peyton still had feelings for him. And then Brooke actually started liking him, which just made it more complicated. And Lucas kissed Peyton, she kissed him back becuz she LIKED him and wasn't thinking. And she didn't want to tell Brooke becuz she was afraid that it would hurt her. And she ended it with Lucas becuz Brooke is really important to her. However, if I was Brooke I would still be mad at especially Lucas. Oh, well. They forgave each other. But Peyton always had the feelings for Lucas she jst hid them. And Lucas started liking Brooke again becuz he was watching her become more independent and strong. And Peyton was busy with Jake. But Peyton got shot, and kissed Lucas becuz she thought she was gonna die. But I still thoguht that was wrong becuz Brooke almost died crying becuz she lost Peyton. Brooke is a great friend. Peyton is not as great a friend basically because of the Lucas conflict. Hey, she tried! And she always liked Lucas and was jealous of Brooke for it. Come on, cut her some slack. She lost all her parents and her dad is never home, her BFF is mad at her, she found put her ex-BF slept with her drunk BFF and shes losing it and Psycho Derek decided to come up on the scene. She became strong in the end and told Lucas how she felt and relaized she was the one for him all the time. Mostly becuz they both have the single mother growing up thing. And as Haley said, "Tortured Artist meets Tortured Athlete" And Peyton is a good person to be so strong and amazing after all she went through. I agree Chad and Sophia have better chemistry together but thats because Burton is not as old as Sophia, at least she doesn't look as old. And Brooke is a good friend, she always forgave Peyton and even saved her damn butt! And Peyton is too, she always welcomed Brooke into her house when she was almost homeless and helped her with her Colthes over Bros. fashion designs. Leyton are good together becuz they love each other and Brucas are also good together but Brooke needs someone a little more outgoing and "Chase-like" for her style. Lucas and Peyton are both the emotional and dark-pasted ppl. They belong together. But that doesn't really matter. The show is great. The actors are very great. So just watch the amazing music and the character complicatiuons rather than fued about it on this site and get a life!

I don't get why all the blames are all going to Peyton. For starters, it takes two to cheat!

yes, and lucas made a mistake to. but that was only the first time. who started it up the second time? thats right peyton.

If you take a look at Brooke and Peyton's character traits and how the producers are portraying them, it's pretty hard to not be intrigued by Peyton. I mean, she's so talented and sensitive-very admirable!

No, not really. She is a crybaby who likes to steel boyfriends.

It's obvious that she has difficuties showing her emotions and love to others.

ehm okey? I dont really see that she has a problem showing people how she feels. I mean she did tell Lucas that she loved him and then kissed him in the school library(while he was still dating brooke) and then she said she loved him and wanted to be with again in her room. and she also toled Jakeshe loved him. I dont know but saying I love you to is not a problem that peyton has.

her dad is always away that she practically grew up by herself.

Oh, and Brooke didnt? Her parents isnt in ONE single episode so far. and now they moved and shes living alone, and even when they were living in tree hill.they just threw cash at brooke and sent her on her way( and thats a quote)

Now, watching the beginning episodes of the fist season, let's get real. Who's side were you really on? Brooke reminds you of who, the "biatch" in school.

Hm, saving your friend from getting raped, fixing up the tutor girl with the most popular boy in school, talking to the nerd (Mouth) and getting together with a poor guy. No, it doesent sound so bitchy to me.

Chemistry? Of course you'd think Brooke and Lucas would have more because the actors playing them were dating and then got married.

Chad and Sophia STARTED dating after they shot the first brooke and lucas love scenes and even then they had an amazing chemistry and they still do. even though they are divorced.

She uses only her talents and brains for her success, unlike the case for Brooke, who doesn't seem to be able to detached herself from using her sexuality. Take a look at her designs for crying out loud!

Oh, Peyton can draw pictures of people having sex because that is just using your talents. but brooke cant design a revealing dress because thats using sexuality? and by the way, theres nothing wrong with the hoes over bros clothing line. comon if what brooke designs are sluty then peyton is a big slut for wearing the leopard top at the party where she almoast got raped.

Peyton deserves Lucas! She may have kissed Lucas, but Brooke slept with Nathan.

Peyton and Nathan were BROKEN UP. So dont even try comparing that to what peyton did.

When they slept together there weren't anything emotionally wrong with Brooke, while in case for Peyton, yeah there was.

No, but Brooke was drunk. and peyton was not. if anything she was happy because she had just found out that her father was alive.

The first season she had strong feelings for Lucas, but Brooke came between them,

no, peyton hated lucas. and brooke liked him. it was when brooke started dating him that peyton wanted him. watch the episodes please.

and remember the events that was happening during that first "cheating" kiss. She thought her father died!

no she didnt. she had just found out he was still alive.

Then the second, she's been shot, and thought she was about to die!

so? does that give her any right kissing anyone elses boyfriend? NO. Brooke shouldnt have slept with nathan but atleast she didnt screw him while he was still with peyton.

Peyton all the way.

No, Brooke all they way.

I don't get why all the blames are all going to Peyton. For starters, it takes two to cheat!

If you take a look at Brooke and Peyton's character traits and how the producers are portraying them, it's pretty hard to not be intrigued by Peyton. I mean, she's so talented and sensitive-very admirable! Her tragedies and misfortunes makes us symphatize with her character. It's obvious that she has difficuties showing her emotions and love to others. Who wouldn't? Her mom, who she thought was her real mother, died when she was a very young age, and her dad is always away that she practically grew up by herself.

Now, watching the beginning episodes of the fist season, let's get real. Who's side were you really on? Brooke reminds you of who, the "biatch" in school. The girls who loves to put down others even though they have so much already to make themselves feel more better of who they are, without regards that those "others" are experiencing family crisis such as their's or even worser.

Chemistry? Of course you'd think Brooke and Lucas would have more because the actors playing them were dating and then got married. Don't let that fool you though. It seems that Chad can have a chemistry with any hot stuff. He did cheat!

Isolating who the actors playing the characters are my vote will definitely fall for Peyton. She's a greater character than Brooke. She uses only her talents and brains for her success, unlike the case for Brooke, who doesn't seem to be able to detached herself from using her sexuality. Take a look at her designs for crying out loud!

Peyton deserves Lucas! She may have kissed Lucas, but Brooke slept with Nathan. When they slept together there weren't anything emotionally wrong with Brooke, while in case for Peyton, yeah there was. The first season she had strong feelings for Lucas, but Brooke came between them, and remember the events that was happening during that first "cheating" kiss. She thought her father died! Then the second, she's been shot, and thought she was about to die!

Peyton all the way.

Okay most people are brucas fans......but me personally.....LEYTON!!! I mean if Lucas didn't like Peyton he would of almost had sex with her in the motel...and everyone says that Peyton went after Luke twice but the second time she thought she was gunna die. I mean if u were trapped in a library almost dead with the guy u love wouldn't u tell him how u feel?

If Lucas still loves Brooke wouldn't he of asked her to be with him the night of the banquet for Whitey, before Peyton told him she was in love with him?

And yes Peyton knew she was hurting Brooke in the motel scene, but so did Lucas and he didn't stop it either until the necklace thing.

The night after the sex tape was revealed Brooke did tell Nathan that she could've stopped him...but she didn't.

Oh in season 3 when Peyton told Brooke she still had feelings for Luke, she also said she was just going to bury it again. And the night of the party that Brooke threw for Lucas to get over Keith's death, Lucas even told Peyton he loved her too, but he also loved Brooke.

Lucas and Peyton are made for each other. If it wasn't for Brooke in the 1st season they would've been together.

I think its time for Brooke to be happy for Peyton and let Lucas go.

Look its obvious who the writers really want to see together and that is brooke and lucas. they would never have put brooke back with lucas again in season two if it wasent for the fact that they had amazong chemistry and that they liked seeing them. now the only reason brooke and lucas broke up is because sophia and chad got divorced. and if that had not happened they wouldnt have had to put peyton with lucas. i mean its so draged out! they were forced to make this storyline because its just slow watching the same thing happen all over again. anyway thats it i hope brucas gets bagck togetehr again. they are ment to be.

Brucas should be together peyton doesnt love him like brooke does peyton and jake are perfect for eachother.....lucas and brooke were also perfect togther!
im on team brucas forever!
"People who are meant to be together always find their way in the end"-BROOKE!
brucas----x

ever sense ive been watching one tree hill ive been a total BROOKE FAN 1ST OF ALL PEYTON AND LUCAS HURT BROOKE TWICE BROOKE DIDNT MEAN FOR WHAT HAPPENED WITH THE TAPE SHE WAS DRUNK AND EVEN THOUGH PEYTON GOT SHOT SHE STILL SHOULDNT HAVE KISSED LUCAS AGAIN LUCAS AND BROOKE ARE GREAT TOGTHER AND I HOPE THEY FIND THERE WAY BACK TO EACH OTHER.PLUS I CANT EVEN BELIEVE BROOKE FORGAVE PEYTON IN THE PAST EPISODE OMG WHATEVER I SOO BELIEVE THEY WILL FIND THERE WAY BACK TO EACH OTHER

okeeeeeee dokeee basically and HONESTLY im sorry for all of yout aht are stupid enough for thinking that peyton is something of a good person and that she waits for her friends boyfriends instead of just going after them.
FYI
YOU SHOULDNT GO AFTER YOU FREINDS BOYFREINDS AT ALL,
EVER, EVER EVER EVER EVVVVVVVVEEEEEEEEERRRRR!! and peyton has crossed that very fine line more than once, brooke has forgived peyton for being a 2 faced backstabbin bitch but i certainly would slap her in the face call her a bunch of stuff i woould never say otherwise and walk away leaving her just standing there,
honeslty how could a "true" best friend do that and yeah i know all of you leytoners are gonna be like brooks a sakank brooks a whore blha blah blahhhhhh she slept with nathen and yeah that was reeeeeeeely shady but like serioulsy first of all shew was hammered wich shouldnt even be an excuse but she was and second of all it was one night and serioulsy peyton and lucas had an on-going relashionshop that they both knowingly knew aboutt!!! it really should have been like kksomething that brooke obs shouldnt have done i TOTALLY AGREE she shouldnt ahve but brooke and lucas have chemistry and wheenver lucas and peyton kiss i feel like im watching a sister and brother make out its really awkward... so basically leytoners have your year.. we had season 3 you guys have seasn 4! have fun bc your time is ticking away...

NO to Leyton
Yes to Breyton
Yes to Brucas
Yes to Naley
OTH FOREVER!!

I'm on Brookes side!
Lets go back to season one Brooke liked Lucas when he liked Peyton, Peyton had her chance how can you be on her side. I think Peyton and Lucas we'll be together this season (4) but you heard Lucas, His the guy for Brooke, he can't just take that back. I'm going to keep watching even though there not together this season because I still have hope for them. And even if they don't get together all us Brooke and Lucas fans will know they were and always will be ment to be x
One Tree Hill Rocks!

Well I guess I wouldn't be very happy if suddenly my best friend would come to me to tell me she was in Love with my boyfriend! I guess no one would!Would be a shock to me considering if I knew that they had a story already! Would change everything! I'm Brooke's side! And Peyton didn't go after Lucas?? Of course she did! In season 3 and 4 before they get together we can see that! She's always around him!

i totally and 100 percent agree with the last comment
i love peyton as an individual
but im going to have to say no to leyton..they dont have chemistry like brucas do

i can not wait until 5th season.to see if marks gon put the brucas back together he has to

Look, Peyton and Lucas are a couple now but bottom line is that Hilary and Chad can never EVER shoot a scene as real as chad and sophia. I have cried laughed and yelled watching brucas moments and when I see Leyton "so called moments" I just dont feel that its real. i THINK that leyton will continue to be a couple on the show but I think that even leytoners must agree that they just dont have that chemistry that brooke and lucas does. the only thing that makes leyton moments work is the music in the backround and if you take it awaay the scene is not as cute. Brooke and Lucas moments on the other hand are so filled with love and passion that you cant help but to smile. And Lucas rellay loved Brooke in season two and three, and you just cant stop loving someone its so obvious that the ONLY REASON brooke and lucas are not together is that chad and sophia are not an item anymore andthats week. I understand it must be hard for them but the bottom line is that they shouldnt let their personal life get in the way of their work, and the fact that Mark choosed to make it easy for them and put lucas with peyton is just week. I nolonger feel exited watching one tree hill.dont get me wrong its a great show and all but and Ill keep watching it hoping for a change but when I watch it all I do is sit there hoping that LUcas and Brooke will find their way back. I actually started watcing the oc more because there I actually feel that the acters with true chemistry are items on the show.
Anyway I shure do hope that Brooke and Lucas will shoot more love scenes because the leyton scenes are just so un cute.

Yes, I do watch the episodes, I even watch them a few times after they air.

Second, I don't know why people get so affended. Did you know I write Lucas and Peyton stories AND Brooke and Lucas stories? Because personally I don't mind Brooke and Lucas, and that's the reason I am here. Because I don't get the sense to these arguments. I mean, really? What's so bad about Lucas and Peyton? They are happy with each other.(I can come up with a bunch more reasons, but I am going to get on with the point.)

What's so bad about Lucas and Brooke? Personally I think Lucas and Brooke are very sweet together, infact, I can say from the top of my head almost all their scenes in season 3.

I am just saying, I live with a family the watches One Tree Hill, and everyone of them are Brooke and Lucas fans. Every single one, not one Lucas and Peyton fan.

I don't know why there are so many people that can't get along because you don't agree on the same couple, infact, I don't know why people have to start these threads. There have been so many fights over who should be with Lucas, which team are you on, ect...

Like I said before, why can't you just watch the show because you love it. Again like I said before to all you Brooke and Lucas fans AND Lucas and Peyton fans, none of these couples where together in the first episode, so why can't you just watch One Tree Hill now for the reason you watched it back then?

And you know what, on the fact that this is a Brooke vs. Peyton issue and not a Brucas vs. Leyton issue. I am on both their teams. Brooke and Peyton make great friends, I just can't wait to see when another thread like this doesn't exist anymore.

I hae also saw people writing that Brooke was drunk? Well first off she shouldn't have been, am I right? Second of all I never heard anything that Brooke had heard Peyton say that Nathan could so call sleep with anyone he wanted, and did I hear Nathan tell her? I don't think so. As far as Brooke knew, Peyton and Nathan were still together.

She was drunk, she shouldnt have been? why not? Peyton has gotten drunk as much as brooke has. but thats not the point the pointis that you probably slept through out the episode because heres what happened

Peyton " Were broken up"

Nathan " for real och like well get together tomorrow again?"

Peyton " for real, now GO SLEEP WITH WHATEVER SKANK YOU WANT"

there you go. whatever skank you want.

and then you said"as far as brooke knew nathan and peyton were still together...oh dear.

Brooke "IM so drunk"

Nathan " Peyton broke up with me"

there you go again.

I believe the first and only time that Peyton and Lucas got together was AFTER Lucas had broken up with Brooke, or do you not all remember him saying he needs some time?

when leyton kissed in the library he was with brooke. when they almoast slept together he was still with brooke (AND LET ME AD AT THE SAME POINT THAT THEY WERE RIPPIN EACHOTHERS CLOTHES OFF BROOKE WAS WATCHING THE PHONE WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO CALL AND SAY THAT PEYTONS DAD WAS OKEAY"
and when they kissed in the halway he was with brooke.

and so you ask why do we watch the show. you obviesley dont watch it since all you posted was incorect.

Okay I have really heard enough! I have heard people saying Peyton and Nathan were broken up, and Brooke and Lucas weren't. Excuse me? I believe Brooke slept with Nathan, awhere's Peyton had just kissed Lucas.

I believe the first and only time that Peyton and Lucas got together was AFTER Lucas had broken up with Brooke, or do you not all remember him saying he needs some time?

I hae also saw people writing that Brooke was drunk? Well first off she shouldn't have been, am I right? Second of all I never heard anything that Brooke had heard Peyton say that Nathan could so call sleep with anyone he wanted, and did I hear Nathan tell her? I don't think so. As far as Brooke knew, Peyton and Nathan were still together.

I have said what all I needed to say, it's really unbelievable that there are Brucas and Leyton. I mean Peyton came up with that name for Nathan and Haley, does that mean now we all have to label the couples? Plus why can't some people just watch the show, not for favorite couples, but because you love what it is about? I personally don't care what couple it is, I am personally a Lucas and Peyton fan, but you know what? I watched the season all through the Brooke and Lucas moments. Unlike all of you, I watch the show because it is something, not which side are you on.

You should really think about why you are watching this show. Alot of you Brooke and Lucas fans are not watching the show anymore. Why? Because as I last checked, Brooke and Lucas didn't start the show out together, so why did you watch it back then? Seriously, like I said before, why do you watch this show?

im mainly on team breyton but judging from this season and watching it, even though the show makes brooke look bad for some reason?
I have to say even thought Brooke can come off as harsh sometimes but she is the right one

1. what lucas and peyton did was MUCH WORSE thana brooke and nathan
brooke and lucas were clearly together.
Peyton and nathan were not
Brooke was drunk..she was not in control of her mind
Peyton was always aware of what she did. she KNEW SHE WAS DOING WRONG AND SHE DID IT

and heres one that most people dont notice
peyton kissed lucas while he was with brooke. not ONCE but twice. people say that brooke should have forgiven peyton because she was in that situation with nathan once (for one totally different situation because of the reasons listen above)
and for two.. BROOKE DID FORGIVE PEYTON ONCE REMEMBER!
when they betrayed her the first time. BROOKE PUT IT BEHIND HER.
im sorry but anyone who had their BEST Friend and boyfriend betray them TWICEE! would not be able to take it

and also, brooke and peyton have very different personalities. peyton is a lot more sensitve and shows her emotional side..brooke likes to appear strong but that doesnt mean that brooke's heart didnt break

and i know that peyton loves lucas a lot..which is very sweet

but brooke was totally in love with him.she just didnt show it as much..she was totally right when she said she doesnt need to prove herself by declaring her love for lucas.

the ONLY thing i see in peytons defense in this thing is that brooke never told her about her and nathan hooking up she held it inside

but clearly, peyton made A LOT MORE mistakes.

over all though, i lvoe peyton alot too and i want them to get back together

as for lucas, he has a real ending with brooke
peyton was lucas's second choice in matters of love

Are you Peyton Lovers deaf or just stupid? Peyton and Nathan were broken up and she did say he could sleep with whoever the hell he wanted or something like that.

I'm not using drink as an excuse but they were DRUNK, they had alcohol blinding their judgement. Peyton was aware of what she was doing when she and Lucas went around behind Brooke's back.

And for those who are calling Brooke a slut or a whore or whatever. Grow up. People who call her that are Leyton Fan's or Peyton lovers. I'm actually quite fond of Peyton, even though I'm on Brooke's side and you don't see me yabbering on about how much of a slut she is.

They both did something wrong in the past, they should just make up and be friends.

Brooke is selfish? Do you even watch the damn show!

I'm not for Leyton at all. Brucas all the way.

Brooke : Lucas is the one for me

Lucas : (brooke) she´s the one for me
Rachel : Why ?

Also mmhh a dream compared to getting shot in the leg yesh it is pratically the same situation!! She was bleeding to death the only reason most people live getting shot in the leg is because they make it to the hospital in time while Peyton was locked in the school because Jimmy was still in the school with gun therefore she was bleeding to death so she ulitmately thought she was going to die and kissed Lucas it was soo not another excuse!!

it was 2 ANOTHER EXCUSE because kissing him then showed sha had planned to do it sometime in the future, and she saw a golden oppertunity imean was he supposed to push away a bleading girl?.NO SHE KNEW HE WAAS TO NICE TO TELLHER OFF,and she took advantage of that.

And Brooke is far from perfect as a best friend okay i love the girl she is funny and quirky but seriously she goes after Lucas in season 1 even though she knew Peyton liked Lucas i mean that was kindof a cheap thing to do. Thats all i had to say to be honest i just needed to get off my chest cause some of the comments were frustrating me!!

nonono! brooke went after lucas after asking peyton if she wantedhim, she even gave her a fare game date, and peyton said "he is already fare game. i dont like him" you see, brooke liked him the first time SHE EVER LAYED EYES ON HIM in the gym, and at that point peyton didnt like him so brooke actually liked him first. i rest my case.

Okay mmh leyton lovers can't argue with class?? Ha thats a first i was reading through of them and that is so not true i man Brucas/ Peyton haters are calling Peyton a whore at least she loved Lucas when she went behinde brooke's back. Brooke and Nathan just lusted each other it wasn't love it wasn't meaningful sure Nathan and Peyton broke up but if Brooke was such a good friend to Peyton then she wouldn't have slept with her just newly ex!!

Also as for people saying it is just Brooke's fault what about Lucas cheating on Brooke with her bestfriend i never read once any one saying it was his fault!!

Also mmhh a dream compared to getting shot in the leg yesh it is pratically the same situation!! She was bleeding to death the only reason most people live getting shot in the leg is because they make it to the hospital in time while Peyton was locked in the school because Jimmy was still in the school with gun therefore she was bleeding to death so she ulitmately thought she was going to die and kissed Lucas it was soo not another excuse!!

And Brooke is far from perfect as a best friend okay i love the girl she is funny and quirky but seriously she goes after Lucas in season 1 even though she knew Peyton liked Lucas i mean that was kindof a cheap thing to do. Thats all i had to say to be honest i just needed to get off my chest cause some of the comments were frustrating me!!

P.S i really think Brooke and Peyton should just come over their difference and get back to Hoes Over Bros!!

it doesent matter what all of yall think brooke davis and lucas scott is endgame!

"i don't understand why everyone gets so aggravated over this whole thing. it's television. it's fiction. it's cheesey. and you don't have to pick sides. just appreciate each character and let the show take its course."

EXACTLY!! although, i have to say, it's kind of amusing to watch these people get so intense and hateful... all for something that doesn't even exist. when i'm bored at work i usually just read the various posts here.... it makes my day! haha it's absolutely hilarious.

i feel that each of them has their good points and the bad ones too.
peyton is definitely more mature and a lot less frivolous.
brooke on the other hand is more carefree and a lot funnier.
although i like peyton and luke together, i have to admit that brooke and lucas did have great chemistry.
peyton and luke seem more alike and so it feels like their relationship makes more sense than brooke/lucas.
so basically, i like both characters/couples. i don't understand why everyone gets so aggravated over this whole thing. it's television. it's fiction. it's cheesey. and you don't have to pick sides. just appreciate each character and let the show take its course. it's one thing to have a favorite couple/character and it's an entirely different thing to make that character so real to yourself that you insult people and get into ridiculous diatribes over it.

i hate peyton so much..shes a slut...
and brooke and lucas are meant 2 be no mater what. and in the end of season 4 brooke and lucas will be together...just wait and see

So, right now on the show, Peyton loves Lucas, Lucas loves Peyton and Brooke is completely OK with them together (she even pushed Lucas to go to Peyton)...
Hmmm, so I think everyone is on the same side now : the LucasxPeyton's side :D

The catfights in the last episode were crazyyy!! alot of you are saying how wrong it was that Peyton attacked and punched Brooke... well ok punching her was a little over the top and I think she was mostly caught up in the heat of the moment... as for tackling her, I don't think that was that bad. Brooke had just egged her house and was throwing breakable things around her...
however, I think that at the end of the show where Brooke had just seen "WHORE" written on her dress and thought that Peyton must still care, it is setting up for a reconcile between Peyton and Brooke. and I can't wait for them to be friends again.
I'm hoping that maybe Brooke will somehow end up at Peyton's house and help save her for physco Derick... or at least that Brooke will be there for Peyton after she gets attacked again
I just hope Peyton is ok and that creepy-ass kid gets his ass kicked!

Well i think that peyton really shouldnt be mad she did the same thing to brooke.Anyway peyton shouldnt even be w/ lucas he belongs w/brooke.

BRUCAS FOREVER

All you peytonlovers were making such a huge deal when brooke said that peytons mum slept around even more than peyton did . And what about peyton calling brooke a whore several times and punching her and attacking her !? That was nothing compared how peyton is treating brooke now . You have no idea how good this feel writing this right now :)

dude brooke is such a hypocrite... she treated peyton so badly for the same mistakes she made herself.

Brooke didnt make the same mistake. okay, she slept with nathan once when him and peyton were broken up.
peyton on the other hand had a ongoing affair with lucas when he was still dating brooke. so brooke didnt slep with anybodys boyfriend. and she was drunk i dont remember peyton being drunk when she made out with lucas all those times.

LOOK I can see why peyton is mad but she doesent have a right to PUNCH and ATTACK brooke thats just sick... brooke didntattack ore punch peyton when she stole lucas TWICE!

i want peyton and brooke to be friends again but you guys have to see that peyton and lucas are not ment to be together. if it wasent for psykostalkerderek then they would never be together lucas is just with peyton cause he feels responsilbe for her. I was starting to get over brucas but then i saw some brucas scenes from the third season when brooke gave him the letters and all of that and you have to udnerstand that SCENES LIKE THAT DONT JUST HAPPEN they have SUCH CHEMISTRY! hilarie and chad can never capture those emotions for eachother because they just dont click like chad and sophia do and when chad and sophia act they really make you believe that there is a brooke and lucas and that they love eachoter. all of the times they havde shared can not just be forgotten. i think mark should let peyton and lucas be friends but not more. he loves brooke and he will always love her i just know it.

woow , loooks like leytoners and brookehaters can´t argue with dignity . And for all of you that are calling brooke a whore are totaly wrong , and I´ll explain why . A whore is one who sleeps with guys so they will get paid . That´s a whore , now you don´t see brooke getting paid for sex now do you . So please cut the crap for gods sake . At least we brucasers have some class when we´re arguing :)

well said.

guys, i dont think peyton had any right to punch brooke. first of all nathan and peyton were broken up. and when brooke slaped peyton it was not cause of peyton wanting lucas she slaped her for twisting her words so i think peyton punching brooke was a jackass thing to do. and oh ATTACKING HER??? hello shes crazy that girl...

when peyton and lucas were in the hotel she didint think about stoping luke stoped it. cant say i balame him;)
and actually peyton and nathan were broken up when brooke slept with him, its still not cool but its not the same thing as having an ONGOING AFFAIR with lucas when brooke was still dating him. so...brooke is not a whore.

Peyton and Nathan where brokem up Brooke and LUcas were still dating

Peyton didnt love nathan brooke knew that. Brooke loved lucas, peyton knew that.

Lucas and Peyton where not drunk Brooke was drunk enough to have a foggy memory.

look i dont hate peyton i just want you to see that it was not the sa´me thing. im a brookefan but i didnt like it at all when she made fun of peytons mothers death and now when fake derek is at peytons im totally freaked out i want peyton to be happy i just feel for brooke to.

"back in season one at the hotel they came close, but they stopped"

Oh no , Lucas stopped the whole thing , Peyton didn´t think about brooke for a second .

"and how do you know that it was a one-time thing and that they were drunk?2

OMG , you can´t be serious . Brooke showed no intress in nathan what so ever so it was a one time thing . orelse we would have seen that it was something going on with the two of them in season 1 , actullay this is just a thing that mark throwed in for the whole drama thing . It sais in the spoilers that both were drunk .

"Why was it ok for Brooke to be pissed at Peyton for cheatign with Lucas when she had already cheated with Nathan and gone much farther with him?"

We never said that peyton has no roght to be pissed , just that she´s overreacting a little with punching brooke and attacking her . And brooke had the right to be pissed because they went behind her back . It just seems like people are only mad at brooke and not even a bit at nathan . afterall he was in it too . And besides brooke has grown and she doesn´t do that kinda stuff anymore , But peyton on the other hand is the same .

"And brooke was also genuine and sincere in her love for luke . But still peyton went behind brookes back . The N/B sex was just a one time thing , Peyton and Lucas went behind brookes back for a while . Now you can´t possibly say that doesn´t hurt more ? And may i add one thing , Both nathan and brooke were drunk , real drunk .. huh unlike peyotn and lucas . "

the point is that Peyton really loved Lucas and that's why she cheated with him, but Brooke didn't care about Nathan at all, so she was willing to throw away her long term friendship over just sex. And maybe most importantly, PEYTON NEVER SLEPT WITH LUCAS. yeah, back in season one at the hotel they came close, but they stopped. Brooke on the other hand didn't seem to hesitate. and how do you know that it was a one-time thing and that they were drunk?
So can anyone answer this question - Why was it ok for Brooke to be pissed at Peyton for cheatign with Lucas when she had already cheated with Nathan and gone much farther with him?
Hell yeah Peyton has a right to be pissed.

The smell of her hair
The look in her eyes
The sound of her laugh
The shape of her smile
The size of her personality
The beauty of her words
Some of the things you love her for
You want her back
But she’s scared
Scared to be hurt again
Scared of you with her best friend
Scared to open her heart again
You promise
Promise you wont hurt her again
Promise you wont go to her best friend
Promise you’ll never let her go again
She believes you, but you lie
Her best friend love you
And you love her to
You didn’t mean to hurt her
But you do
But you did her a favor
Because you don’t disserve her
She forgives you
Even though part of her still loves you
And her best friend they’ll never be the same again
Brooke will find and disserves someone better

HAHAHAHAHA... do you not understand that calling brooke a whore is similar to a literary technique called "exaggeration for effect".... stop taking things literally and try to read between the lines you fool.

woow , nice humilliating people on the internet . So you mean that she can´t take it serious when you write such words as whore slut etc . Then she really can´t take anything serious what you guys write ( leytoners ) Because all I see you posting is really slut and whore . Please come up with reasons instead , We´re getting sick of all the freaking crap . And some of you were saying that is was not right for brooke to say that peytons mum slept around more than peyton did . Well Look who´s calling who a whore in the promo . Your sweet and beloved peyton . So now you must be reallt mad , Beacuse you almost freaked .

"A whore is one who sleeps with guys so they will get paid"

HAHAHAHAHA... do you not understand that calling brooke a whore is similar to a literary technique called "exaggeration for effect".... stop taking things literally and try to read between the lines you fool.

dude brooke is such a hypocrite... she treated peyton so badly for the same mistakes she made herself.

EXACTLY!! i was never a huge fan of brooke but i never really hated her either... but i think after the whole sex tape deal i'm beginning to really dislike her.

woow , loooks like leytoners and brookehaters can´t argue with dignity . And for all of you that are calling brooke a whore are totaly wrong , and I´ll explain why . A whore is one who sleeps with guys so they will get paid . That´s a whore , now you don´t see brooke getting paid for sex now do you . So please cut the crap for gods sake . At least we brucasers have some class when we´re arguing :)

dude... BROOKE LIKE 100 AND 10 PERCENT
there is no way id take that stupid emo loser who listens to gay rock and has a 24 hours sex show over brooke...?

dude brooke is such a hypocrite... she treated peyton so badly for the same mistakes she made herself. i can't believe the nerve she had to actually SLAP peyton after having slept with nathan. it's just unbelievbale.
and plus she's stealing calculus tests to graduate high school.
brooke is just so pathetic, i think i throw up a little in my mouth every time i even think about that character.

nathan and peyton were not together and peyton didnt even like him anymore because she felt okay about him and haley right away. she like lucas. brooke would not have slept with him if he and peyton were still together and if she knew peyton had feelings for him so you shut the hell upp for good

It´s still not the same , peyton went behind brookes back with lucas . And then she kissed him . And there was even no feelings involved between N/B , like there was between L/P , plus both nathan and brooke were drunk . And it sais in the spoilers that N/P had just broken up when N/B slept together , So they weren´t a couple at the time , Know it doesn´t help much :/ But as I was saying it´s still not the same it was a one time thing , But the peyton and lucas thing went on for a while .

i hate how brooke made peyton feel bad when she was with Lucas when she did the same with nathan....im on peyton side forever but i wish that their friendship would heal already i love watching them as best friend than enemy... but it doesn't look like it will heal anytime soon this season...so sad

PEYTONNN!

luke and peyton are just a little too cute together. i love them.

lucas doesent really look good anymore he is not hot now that he wants to become writer and so im thinkin he and peyton are okay together, since she doesent deserve better. it would suck if they were together and he was looking and acting like in the first two seasons but now hes not attractive anymore and i must say i love the brooke chase relationship! im with brooke!

Brooke's. Always and Forever. Period.
Lucas, you suck mayor ass. But when you're with brooke.. your different, and I love you then.
What happened with all your words? With all the 'I'm the guy for you, Brooke Davis'?? You told her to fight for you, and she said no, and you know what? Because she already did. But did you care? Did you actually see all her strugles for you? Did you? I don't think so.
Besides that, I hate Peyton with a passion -.-
And what is happening with the writer? with all the 'People who are meant to be always find their way in the end'? I still will have hopes for the Brucas relationship. But what I really want is Leyton to break up soon xD
Brucas, and Brooke all the way. Forever and Ever.

PEYTON. PEYTON. PEYTON

brucas all the way. peyton had no right whatsoever to tell brooke that she still had feelings for lucas. peyton gave brooke enough troubles the first time when she was sneaking around with lucas. peyton is suppose to be brooke's best friend. what kind of best friend would do that?! peyton knew how brooke felt the first time.

BROOKE BROOKE BROOKE! <3

I'm On Brooke's Side 100%
Peyton doesn't deserve a second chance, No I mean a third chance. Peyton was Brookes best friend and she betrayed that trust and bond twice. BROOKE ALL THE WAY!

TOTALLY PETYON'S SIDE!
umm i started watching one tree hill end of season two and i thought brooke and lucas were the cutest thing. but just recently, over christmas break, i had some time to watch seasons one and two and now i'm a 100% lucas/peyton fan. It just makes me realize (after watching the first two seasons) that lucas and peyton make more sense together than brooke/peyton. and i have to admit, they had great chemistry during that first season. haha. this show is too much of a guilty pleasure.. but hey, it's something to live on when you're bored.

SO when he wrote that Peyton was telling Brooke that she still had feelings for Lucas, he was setting it up for Leyton. As well as the library kiss etc. So the show was always going to go in that direction.

but when that happened peyton liked lucas but he didnt like her, so it was just going to be some kind of peyton thing, when they got the divorce he decided that lucas would like peyton back

Okay.
Well I would have to say that i always loved the idea of Leyton, but when Brooke came along they had such great chemistry and i LOOVED it in the episode where hes says "I'm the guy for you Brooke Davis".
and I think when Lucas is with Peyton he is just soo much more romantic and sexxay. When he was cheating with Peyton though they had great chemistry too. So i was always secretly rooting for Peyton for sure. UNTIL the last couple of episodes. I mean there is like ZERO chemistry and they seem like such buddy buddy too. I think the show itself has j changed Just changed TOO DRASTICALLY like seriously. with haley being pregnant and no more Brucas which has been one of the main relationships for awhile. And now dan and karen getting close and lucas' hair. I mEAN WHAT THE HECK is up with that. TOO FAKKE BLONDE!!! i hate it.
so i guess im kinda just disspointed all in all . i hope that the show starts to go in different kind of direction with Leyton. a more sexxy and romantic change hopefully.So i guess for now I'll be hopeing for Leyton...but ill always miss Brucas!

OMG , your just writing bullshit ! You hardly don´t understand , That makes it even more bullshit .

Peyton!
She and Lucas had a connection from the very beginning, but she wasn't ready for a relationship. That's the only reason Lucas dated Brooke in the first place.
Lucas and Peyton belong together. They are so much alike. They are better for each other.

I totaly disagree with you on this , everything exept one thing that Peyton and Lucas had connection at first in season 1 . But Lucas did never date Brooke just because Peyton wasn´t ready for a relationship , I mean why the hell would Lucas pick brooke in season 2 ,3 if he wanted peyton . He picked Brooke because he wanteed to , he did that even though peyton was all singel . Haha LOL .

UM Peyton wasn't single, she was with Jake you dumb ass.

Anyway which couple has come out on top.. LEYTON.

I do like Brooke, her storylines are fun to watch but when it comes down to it, I'd have to say that Peyton is my favourite. I don't know why I like her character more, but I just do.

BTW Brucas is so over it's not funny. SERIOUSLY can all you Brucas fans out there stop saying the they're are going to get back together because OBVIOUSLY they're not.
HELLO?? They got a divorce. How awkward would that be.

Alot of people say that the only reason the show went back to Leyton was because they couldn't keep Brucas together because of the divorce, but that's WRONG.

When he wrote the scripts for season three, Chad and Sophia were still together. Because that would of been around 2003-2004. Think about it; He would of had to start writing the season 4 script 2005 and then they had to act it which would of been done from 2005-2006. Because it's airing now.

SO when he wrote that Peyton was telling Brooke that she still had feelings for Lucas, he was setting it up for Leyton. As well as the library kiss etc. So the show was always going to go in that direction.

HAHA you know guys, i watched some old clips from the first three seasons and thought that brucas were SOOO SWEET TOGETHER! but now lucas lookes like crap, that hair and his weird face expressions, and the fact that he is a totally different person when he is with peyton makes him sooo unatractive. I think he and peyton looks like brother and sister, they have no chemistry when they act and they are a boring couple to wathc because they can NEVER just be happy about anything but now i dont mind if they are together i just laugh my ass of every time i see the two of them. Brooke should be with someone way cuter than lucas, and someone who doesent change peronality like he does, i think if the show gives brooke a new cute boyfriend ( like steven;) then people will watch to see them not leyton, leyton bores me and they cant even kiss but whenever brooke is in a relationship she spunks it up! i still want brucas back in the end, but for now i dont care. peyton and lucas makes asses out of themselfs and its just so wrong seeing them together but they are a missmatch, you guys can have leyton now because i now realise that you loose ! you want peyton to be the funny one, the one people like to watch but now that she is with lucas noone wants to watch her! HAHAHA its just so funny...leyton it cracks me up i call them pucas cuss they make me puke but whatever...they can have their brother sister relationship and brooke can get a new boy who will tell her that he loves her then not just change...and by the way...im gonna keep voting for brooke because she was right all along!

brucas all the way because they will always love eachother

People I wrote one of those posts, not the two of them. So you can´t really say that I proved myself wrong. Because one of the posts were saying one thing and the next the opposite.

PEYTON DIDNT KNOW SHE WAS DYING AT FIRST, lucas knew she didnt, so she had no right whatsoever to kiss him. she just took the chance because she knew he would not reject her in that situation, and that my friend is pitty from lucas not love...their in a pitty relationship right now to...

dont see you answering that one

i personally, am on peytons side.
she thought she was going to die, so she kissed lucas.
it doesn't matter, it was a kiss because she thought she wasn't going to be able to ever again.
brooke shouldn't be as mad as she is in the third season, she has a right to be angry, but not this angry.
her and peyton lasted longer than her and lucas ever did.
and about jimmy, he didn't MEAN to shoot peyton, he didn't even mean to really pull the trigger. he was scared, lonely, lost, whatever the fuck you wanna call it.
and it just so happens he made a real wrong turn, and a huge mistake.

"Yes and by him saying , I didn´t mean to hurt her , was in fact like saying I didn´t mean to pull the trigger . I didn´t mean to hurt her , He aimed at her what the hell does he expect , that he´ll miss ."

"You don´t just shoot people for no apperent reason ! damn it people he didn´t mean to shoot peyton . He wasn´t desturbd , he was just so hurt by whow the other students were treating him after the time capsule thing . "

Ok in one of those posts you said
"He aimed at her what the hell does he expect , that he´ll miss ."
and then you said:
"damn it people he didn´t mean to shoot peyton "

so in one you said he aimed at her so he was obviously going to hit her, yet in the other one you say he didn't mean to shoot her.

"And by the way your incorrect facts were overwehlming as well ."

actually no they're not. look them up.

And also you weren´t exactly responding at all to my posts , you know when you trying to prove the other one is wrong , Haha Better luck next time buddy (;

don't have to because you prove yourself wrong on your own. Good job contradicting yourself "buddy"

"NO HE DIDN'T. he said he didn't "mean to hurt her"
once again do you see 'I didn't mean to pull the trigger' in there?"

"Yes and by him saying , I didn´t mean to hurt her , was in fact like saying I didn´t mean to pull the trigger . I didn´t mean to hurt her , He aimed at her what the hell does he expect , that he´ll miss ."

no. Do you even watch this show? "I didn't mean to hurt her" = " I didn't pull the trigger". Wow I guess I can't argue with logic like that

???????????????????
HE DIDN'T AIM AT HER. he was going for Marcus. He DID miss .. and that's how Peyton got hurt

if someone shoots you ... even if they had no reason to, are you going to test it? she NEVER told lucas that. she said when he did it he "didn't look evil. He just looked scared."
do you see 'he didn't mean to do it' anywhere in there?

You don´t just shoot people for no apperent reason ! damn it people he didn´t mean to shoot peyton . He wasn´t desturbd , he was just so hurt by whow the other students were treating him after the time capsule thing .

And by the way your incorrect facts were overwehlming as well . And also you weren´t exactly responding at all to my posts , you know when you trying to prove the other one is wrong , Haha Better luck next time buddy (;

NO HE DIDN'T. he said he didn't "mean to hurt her"
once again do you see 'I didn't mean to pull the trigger' in there?

Yes and by him saying , I didn´t mean to hurt her , was in fact like saying I didn´t mean to pull the trigger . I didn´t mean to hurt her , He aimed at her what the hell does he expect , that he´ll miss .

PEYTON DIDNT KNOW SHE WAS DYING AT FIRST, lucas knew she didnt, so she had no right whatsoever to kiss him. she just took the chance because she knew he would not reject her in that situation, and that my friend is pitty from lucas not love...their in a pitty relationship right now to...

yeah?! how do you explain that?!

"Well , peyton hasen´t done anything to jimmy so there was no reason for him to shoot her . And she even said to Lucas that he didn´t do it on purpise .

if someone shoots you ... even if they had no reason to, are you going to test it? she NEVER told lucas that. she said when he did it he "didn't look evil. He just looked scared."
do you see 'he didn't mean to do it' anywhere in there?

"And who the hell would also have a gun ? Good , she must have some brains , same goes for you . "

SOMEONE BROUGHT A GUN TO SCHOOL AND SHOT HER. imagine you were her, you got shot. how the hell could she have known no one else had a gun?
and insulting people over the internet?nice.

"Yes in fact he did [pull the trigger by accident] , if you would have watched the episode carefully , you would have known that jimmy said that he didn´t mean to pull the trigger . And I wouldn´t have to explain myself . "

NO HE DIDN'T. he said he didn't "mean to hurt her"
once again do you see 'I didn't mean to pull the trigger' in there?

wow...the amount of incorrect facts in this post is overwhelming.

actually no .. much more of a chance than that... she wouldnt have left the library because she ONE-couldnt walk and TWO- was afraid of whoever had the gun seeing her .. so she have have remained there and bled to death.
and even in the last episode - the "Its a Wonderful Life" themed one - it showed that if Lucas hadnt been there Peyton would have died.. so yeah it stands to good reason that there was a very good chance of her dying

okay, your right, she was dying...that doesent give her a reason to kiss her best friends boyfriend...especially not since she has don that to the same best friend before. And PEYTON DIDNT KNOW SHE WAS DYING AT FIRST, lucas knew she didnt, so she had no right whatsoever to kiss him. she just took the chance because she knew he would not reject her in that situation, and that my friend is pitty from lucas not love...their in a pitty relationship right now to...

oh my goodness. who is jobless enough to waste time listing 170 absolutely STUPID and RIDICULOUS reasons why brooke and lucas should be together? jeez. get a life.

actually I am, but obviesley you dont have much of a life either because you read all of them...

and how could she have known jimmy didn't shoot her on purpose or that he was the only one with the gun.

Well , peyton hasen´t done anything to jimmy so there was no reason for him to shoot her . And she even said to Lucas that he didn´t do it on purpise . And who the hell would also have a gun ? Good , she must have some brains , same goes for you .

and he absolutely did NOT pull the trigger by accident. He was aiming for Marcus, even though he didn't really want to hurt him, he was just caught up in the heat of the moment.

Yes in fact he did , if you would have watched the episode carefully , you would have known that jimmy said that he didn´t mean to pull the trigger . And I wouldn´t have to explain myself .

c'mon.. please be able to back up your posts.

Oh , Don´t worry I´m perfectly aware what I´m writing and I can back up my posts .. humm Unlike you (;

"actually no .. much more of a chance than that... she wouldnt have left the library because she ONE-couldnt walk and TWO- was afraid of whoever had the gun seeing her .. so she have have remained there and bled to death."

"That´s bullshit . You know if it was about life or death you shure as hell don´t care how much it hurts , you walk anyway . and she actually had nothing to be afraid of , it´s not like jimmy shot her on purpise . And even if he would have seen her if she left , I doubt he would of harm her . Like I said he pulled the trigger by accident . "

she COULD NOT WALK. and how could she have known jimmy didn't shoot her on purpose or that he was the only one with the gun.
and he absolutely did NOT pull the trigger by accident. He was aiming for Marcus, even though he didn't really want to hurt him, he was just caught up in the heat of the moment.

pulled the trigger by accident? God, he had already taken time to pull the gun from his pocket and aim it perfectly and he wasnt going to shoot it?
c'mon.. please be able to back up your posts.

oh my goodness. who is jobless enough to waste time listing 170 absolutely STUPID and RIDICULOUS reasons why brooke and lucas should be together? jeez. get a life.

actually no .. much more of a chance than that... she wouldnt have left the library because she ONE-couldnt walk and TWO- was afraid of whoever had the gun seeing her .. so she have have remained there and bled to death.

That´s bullshit . You know if it was about life or death you shure as hell don´t care how much it hurts , you walk anyway . and she actually had nothing to be afraid of , it´s not like jimmy shot her on purpise . And even if he would have seen her if she left , I doubt he would of harm her . Like I said he pulled the trigger by accident .

"It´s not like this is the first time she´s kissed Lucas , this was just another lame excuse to for her to kiss him . I mean you can never die just because you get shot in the leg , the cases are like 9 out of 10"

actually no .. much more of a chance than that... she wouldnt have left the library because she ONE-couldnt walk and TWO- was afraid of whoever had the gun seeing her .. so she have have remained there and bled to death.
and even in the last episode - the "Its a Wonderful Life" themed one - it showed that if Lucas hadnt been there Peyton would have died.. so yeah it stands to good reason that there was a very good chance of her dying

HAHA!
well if brooke thought she was dreaming, then peyton thought she was dying. HA!
what now?

It´s not like this is the first time she´s kissed Lucas , this was just another lame excuse to for her to kiss him . I mean you can never die just because you get shot in the leg , the cases are like 9 out of 10 . Plus Peyton promised Brooke she wouldn´t make out / kiss Lucas again . But yet she did .. humm lookes like you can not trust Peyton .
Oh I almost forgot : HA ! What now ?
Just bring it on (;

HAHA!
well if brooke thought she was dreaming, then peyton thought she was dying. HA!
what now?

PEYTON!
because brooke kissed pete while she was dating lucas. WHO DOES THAT?! i agree with what most others have to say about her - SHE IS SHALLOW... AND A CLASSIC WHORE!

We have explained this like a thousend times , she thought she was dreaming . End of storie .
A classic whore , yeah right . You can tell that to you beloved peyton instead and I´ll tell you why : First there was lucas , then jake , after that pete , then again lucas . so you tell me Who´s the classic whore here ! And in my opinion she way better of with jake .

PEYTON!
because brooke kissed pete while she was dating lucas. WHO DOES THAT?! i agree with what most others have to say about her - SHE IS SHALLOW... AND A CLASSIC WHORE!

DAH! she thaught she was dreaming when she kissed him. Peyton kissed lucas when she knew brooke loved him...and she went behind brookes back brooke didnt go behind peytons, so that makes peyton the whore. dumbass

ummm PEYTON! coz she's way prettier!

ehm...and you guys have the nerves to call brooke shallow.

PEYTON!
because brooke kissed pete while she was dating lucas. WHO DOES THAT?! i agree with what most others have to say about her - SHE IS SHALLOW... AND A CLASSIC WHORE!

ummm PEYTON! coz she's way prettier!

i think peyton and lucas are very cute together....much better than brooke and lucas.

wow cute together, so they should get married because they LOOK cute together. and you guys call brooke shallow. its about the feelings, brooke and lucas have feelings for eachoter peyton and lucas look like brother and sister

ok major point to be noted - brooke started dating nick literally days after she broke up with lucas.
so tell me - is a couple of days all it takes to move on from a serious relationship? she obviously didnt' love lucas... but peyton does. THEREFORE LUCAS AND PEYTON NEED TO BE TOGETHER.
and that kiss after the game was cute!

Brooke was hurting so bad, so she just stoped thinking, she dated Nick to make herself feel better, i admit it may not be the best way but she just felt like she needed it. She broke up with Lucas because she was scared that the same thing that happened the last time would happend again. Brooke didint think that Lucas liked peyton the first time they were together, but since peyton liked him they betrayed brooke,so she thaught that the same thing would happend again, and so she didnt want to go through that so she ended things with lucas before that happened. And you shouldent talk about brooke having alot of boys, because peyton liked lucas, but then she liked jake, then there was Pete and THEN Lucas. She can never make up her mind.
NOW I WANT TO GET TO MY MOST IMPORTANT POINT, in season two Brooke and Lucas did not date, she didnt know he had feelings for her. And you guys keep going on about how peyton and lucas have a better conncection because they are friends too, but in season two Peyton almoast didnt even talk to lucas at all, and brooke did. She became his friend, she was ready to be his friend when he first broke up with her to, but peyton is all " if he doesent want me as his girlfriend im never gonna talk to him again" and dont say she stayed away from him because she loved him, because brooke loved him to but she still tried to be his friend after they broke up.
Now Peyton and LUcas are going out and i think its so wrong, they have no chemistry whatsoever! and i dont think that two people that have loved eachother in the way brooke and lucas did can just get over it. you dont date you best friends ex! its like an unwritten rule! I mean you can, but not if they had a deep relationship like lucas and brooke had, they loved eachoter so much! i miss that, and oh! peyton kisses like an old lady without a tounge

ok major point to be noted - brooke started dating nick literally days after she broke up with lucas.
so tell me - is a couple of days all it takes to move on from a serious relationship? she obviously didnt' love lucas... but peyton does. THEREFORE LUCAS AND PEYTON NEED TO BE TOGETHER.
and that kiss after the game was cute!

DEFINITELY PEYTON.
i think peyton and lucas are very cute together....much better than brooke and lucas.

I LOVE LEYTON!

Look I no longer have the nervs to read any of you leytoners posts anymore . Lets just see what happens . Only time can tell.
TEAM BROOKE

i'm definitely on peyton's side for several reasons. brooke has pretty much made it clear that she doesn't love lucas... and it doesn't seem like lucas loves her anymore either. so i don't see how or why peyton would be betraying brooke in any way by dating lucas.

Brooke has not actually made it clear she doesn´t love Lucas , she broke up with him just because peyton had feelings for Lucas that´s actually the only reason . You can see how Brooke still loves lucas , I mean it´s pretty obvios when she looked at the pics for example . And plus she she did not give Lucas any apperent reason to brake up with him , if she didn´t love him she could of said that and it would be a pretty good reason , but she still loves him . And peyton is hurting Brooke by dating Lucas beacuse she feels like she´s been betrayed by her bestfriend and boyfriend AGAIN .

" and even throughout seasons two and three...it feels like at some level lucas and peyton definitely had something for each other all along.

No , Lucas and peyton were friends straight out . lucas began to fall in love with Brooke again in season 2 , and still was madly in love with her in season 3 too . It was actuaally Peyton who had a thing for lucas in the end of season 3 . and even at the beggining of season 4 Lucas did not feel anything for peyton , he still loved brooke . And I think he still does .

" and this last thing is a little biased... but i really don't like brooke... she just seems so shallow... the typical spoilt rich girl... and just the fact that she is on the verge of not graduating high school makes me loose all respect for her. who is stupid enough to not graduate high school?... anyone can do that...

Brooke has totaly changed , I can edmit at first she was shallowed and spoiled rich girl But she´s honestly changed , she´s not even rich anymore . She has a big heart and really .. that´s all that matters . Plus I know many people who cannot graduate from high school . You know people are different everyone may not be smart as you .

She really is something special .

PEYTON SAWYERRR!!!

PEYTON ALL THE WAY.
the show started by portraying lucas/peyton as perfect for each other... and it only makes sense that they should end that way.

umm... just a reminder for all the brucas fans out there... when brooke broke up with lucas, she said it had nothing to do with peyton. the reason she gave was she somehow stopped missing him because they wouldn't have meaningful conversations for days.... so basically, i think it was about time that the whole brooke/lucas thing ended... it was bound to happen sooner or later... i guess peyton's kiss just catalyzed the process... which is good... coz in my opinion, the whole brucas thing was gettin old.

so basically I'M ON PEYTON'S SIDE.

i'm definitely on peyton's side for several reasons. brooke has pretty much made it clear that she doesn't love lucas... and it doesn't seem like lucas loves her anymore either. so i don't see how or why peyton would be betraying brooke in any way by dating lucas.
also, it can't be denied that lucas started dating brooke in season one only because he couldn't be with peyton. so brooke was kind of like a second choice... something to settle for coz he couldn't have what he really wanted.
and even throughout seasons two and three...it feels like at some level lucas and peyton definitely had something for each other all along.
plus again... right before lucas said to peyton that he wanted to be with her when his dreams came true, there's a clip from the very first episode when lucas won his first "real" (for lack of a better word) game... they had a bond from the very beginning.
and this last thing is a little biased... but i really don't like brooke... she just seems so shallow... the typical spoilt rich girl... and just the fact that she is on the verge of not graduating high school makes me loose all respect for her. who is stupid enough to not graduate high school?... anyone can do that... so basically my point is- what is it about brooke that's so special?... what is it about her that anyone could possibly fall in love with?
and just on a side note - i don't see how someone like brooke could be the president of student council.. i somehow can't buy that storyline AT ALL... i mean come on.. she's failing high school here!

BROOKE AND LUCAS!!!!

BROOKE JUST WANTS TO FALL IN LOVE AND WANTS TOO BE LOVED BACK..SHE HAS DEEP FEELINGS FOR LUCAS,AND WANTS TO EXPRESS THESE FEELINGS BUT IS AFRAID OF HER HEART BEING BROKEN AGAIN,BECAUSE EVERY TIME SHE FALLS IN LOVE WITH LUCAS SOMEBODY BREAKS HER HART OR GETS IN THE WAY
1st IT WAS PEYTON AND LUKE THAT BROKE HER HEART,THEN RACHEL CAME ALONG,AND NOW PEYTON IS TRYING TO LOVE LUCAS AGAIN
BROOKE IS HURT INSIDE AND SHE SHOWES THIS HURT BY DRINKING PARTING ect.
BROOKE HAS NO FAMILY BEHIND HER JUST LUCAS AND PEYTON-WHO KEEP LETTING HER DOWN...BROOKE IS AFRAID OF BEING ALONE IN COLLAGE..BROOKE IS ALONE AND WANTS LUCAS TO BE HER LOVE

BROOKE AND LUCAS NEED TO BE TOGETHER...PEYTON IS A THIRD WEEL,HANGIN ON TO LUCAS BECAUSE HE IS THE ONLY GUY LEFT EVERBODY KEEPS LEAVING PEYTON..

BROOKE ADN LUCAS HAVE DEEP AFFECTION FOR EACHOTHER LETS HOPE IT LASTS XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Im a fan of both girls, but if I have to choose, I have say Im on TEAM BROOKE.

Brooke & Lucas belong together. Peyton belongs with Jake & Jenny. Leyton will always have that special connection but I just dont see them together romanticly. Brooke does have a reason to be upset but still I dont like her seeing bash Peyton or vise versa, I just wish the stupid triangle would end once and for all (If it hasnt already), either way I just want B&P to be best friends again. No guy even Lucas, is worth losing what P&B had as tight friends.

Peyton!
She and Lucas had a connection from the very beginning, but she wasn't ready for a relationship. That's the only reason Lucas dated Brooke in the first place.
Lucas and Peyton belong together. They are so much alike. They are better for each other.

I totaly disagree with you on this , everything exept one thing that Peyton and Lucas had connection at first in season 1 . But Lucas did never date Brooke just because Peyton wasn´t ready for a relationship , I mean why the hell would Lucas pick brooke in season 2 ,3 if he wanted peyton . He picked Brooke because he wanteed to , he did that even though peyton was all singel . Haha LOL .

Peyton!
She and Lucas had a connection from the very beginning, but she wasn't ready for a relationship. That's the only reason Lucas dated Brooke in the first place.
Lucas and Peyton belong together. They are so much alike. They are better for each other.

OH....BRUCAS 4EVER!!!

I absolutely lovee Brucas together. I think based on on-screen chemistry, they have a way better chemistry than Peyton and Lucas. I know that Brooke and Lucas have been through alot, but it's the rough times that made them learn and become stronger in their relationship. Personally, I do think that Peyton and Lucas have chemistry but it's more of a friendship kind of chemistry, so it's just not believable for me. I'm not saying that they aren't cute together, but I don't think it will last. When it was Brucas, I was always wondering, hm I wonder what will happen next, but with Leyton it's too boring just because their characters are too much alike. Lucas is more laid back and reserved and Brooke is very outgoing and upbeat so them together is what made a good relationship. & I think Brooke did have a reason to flip out when Peyton told her she had feelings for Lucas because she'd been hurt before and she was so scared of it happening again, which shows how strong her feelings truly are. I don't know, after the banquet when Lucas and Brooke said it just didn't feel right, it wasn't believable and then it showed Brooke looking at pictures of them so I think she still cares. Plus not every love story is going to be the way Whitey described it, there are different types of love stories. I hope Brooke and Lucas find their way back to each other!

Im totally for lucas and peyton.. seriously i mean they look amazin together... and its about time that peyton has somethin good in her life. Everytime Brooke has been with Lucas she has thrown it away and been jealous... get over it!! Lucas belongs with Peyton and Brooke said so herself

peyton has stayed with brooke forever as her bestfriend...eventhough her heart breaks every time she saw the lovey-dovey moments of brucas but still she sacrificed it all just to save their friendship...
she made some flaws yeah you're right..betrayal is definitely not a virtue at all...however she did that in the name of LOVE..and so there's nothing wrong with that since lucas and peyton got this going on since season 1...peyton was kinda hesitant to show her feelings in the beginning simply because she was with nathan, the brother of lucas (whom nathan despised a lot)...and the time she told lucas how she felt, brooke was already there...
c'mon guys!we know for a fact that peyton and lucas started their mutual attraction first...but brooke just keep messing it up...this season 4 is really their time to be together...and you just have to face that...

leyton is endgame...mark said on podcast that hilarie and chad look good together...they have chemistry...DON'T MESS WITH THE CREATOR...HE HIMSELF LOVES LEYTON FOREVER AND EVER AMEN....
those who are pissed are the LOOOSSSSEEERRRSSS!

the forth season sucked hard. okay it used to be this show that kids wathced and now its freaking days of our lives, its just to much stuff going on! i hate it, please give them normal problems again like in the first and second season. the third was pretty good to but they have taken it to far. poll it together! AND GET BRUCAS BACK TOGETHER FOR CRYING OT LOUD!

Lucas and Brooke forever! Brucas needs to be reunited because that could start something with Chad and Sophia again. The show is boring without looking forward to that Brucas kiss. I havent liked this season as much because there was never Brucas and that makes me mad. They are perfect for eachother. And they love eachother. In real life too.

Brooke & Lucas. Brooke is better than Peyton in every way. She is better for Lucas and she's a way better friend

Brooke has made it clear she's not in love with Lucas. she already told him after the banquit that it didn't feel right. and Peyton waited until Brooke wasn't in love with Lucas to tell him her feelings - just like she said she would.

Brooke told lucas that she would probably always love him, and it didnt feel right for brooke because she knew peyton liked him, she felt guilty even though she has no reason to! thats why she said it didnt feel right

Well right now on the show its Leyton...Leyton fans watched for 2 seasons with Brucas in love...why cant u watch one fucking season with Leyton...seriously i dont get it

okay first of all stop using the f word its not nice! second you said " shy cant you watch ONE season?" wow...even you are convinced they wont saty together

Yeah all of you are Brucas die hard fans...right??

Well right now on the show its Leyton...Leyton fans watched for 2 seasons with Brucas in love...why cant u watch one fucking season with Leyton...seriously i dont get it

The writers have been screwing us over , I mean when we watched Brucas fall in love with eachother and when they declared their love to eachother , I was like : Woow this is really going to last for ever , that it would be brucas till the one tree hill ends . I´m thinking we all thought that but nooo , the writers just decided to give us :

Brooke : Lucas don´t be mad at me but i think this was a misstake ..
Lucas : Me too , when I heard whitey talk about his love to camilla ... bla bla blaa !!!

I mean at least they could of given us that they were good together and that they were happy they tried at least . I´m sorry I´m just little pissed of how things are going right now ! And so damn annoying that leyton is the endgame , Yes I´m awere that they have to give something to leytoners too but I still think that the major popularity of OTH audience will say Brucas in the end . And so will I .

You know many leytoners have actually joind our brucas side :D fun huuh .. Yepp seems like it´s only one leytoner who´s writing these posts !

LP'ers went through two seasons of choking on our own vomit while watching BL scenes, yet, somehow other people start ruining it for EVERYONE this season.. Huh.. that's SO funny. I wonder why.

YOur taking this a little to seriously in that case. I never choked on my own vomit just because LP are together again, i just think it kinda sucks....get a life

Lucas and Peyton can't be together because "they're like totally brother and sister!" I mean, the blonde hair right? <-- stfu, you're stupid. we laugh at you.

LP'ers went through two seasons of choking on our own vomit while watching BL scenes, yet, somehow other people start ruining it for EVERYONE this season.. Huh.. that's SO funny. I wonder why.

After that perfect closure, BL still will reunite. Don't make me shoot milk out my nose. Seriously. The only way that's even POSSIBLE is if there is a season 5. I'm personally convinced that LP is endgame, but I'm not gonna jump out a second story window in shock if they break up to go to seperate colleges. But BL again? Please. When LP broke up in s1, Peyton walked away practically SOBBING and Lucas looked after her like his world had just ended. They tried to move on, but there was no closure. Let's not kid ourselves here.

If you thought LP would never come back, and you could live in your la-dee-da world of NHBLJP<--- LMFAO. You're absolutely motherfucking idiotic. I hope this kills you. And y'know what? PLEASE stop watching. I couldn't give two FUCKS if you do. Our numbers jumped by nearly 1 million when LP got together. Do you think the BL numbers really [Censored] matter. Get over yourselves.

Lastly, if this deeply offends anyone, feel free to cut me.. Because I'm offended by some [Censored] I've had to read and I'm sick and tired of it. I'm going to defend my ship and all of my friends who ship it with me. I have that right.


Oh and no Leytoner in the world wouldn't have been happier with their kiss.A fucking Brucas fan is posing as a Leytoner.I'm surprised he/she had the balls to do it!

is the same person writing all of these posts? wow.

" You know what, that sceen when lucas and peyton first kissed after the game in the gym could have been so damn cute but those two acters dont have any conection between them. It just looked so fake too me that I could not enjoy it, i mean the chemistry between Sophia and Chad when they act is sooo good and it really makes you belieev that they are very much inlove, but hilarie and chad cant really capture that feeling together...i dont know really it just didnt work for me. Im a Leytoner and I thauht that I would be SO happy when they finally got together but i didnt feel a thing and i think its because they dont have that special IT feeling that makes me feel all warm inside...sorry but its not right. "

Same here I actually thought I Would be jumping up and down , but I didn´t feel a thing . It was like okay . So sad . Cuz I´ve been waiting a long time , and now I´m like not lookong forward to leyton :/ I hate to admit it but Brucas actually makes more of a couple and much more real/funny . GOD that took me real curriage to write that !

You know what, that sceen when lucas and peyton first kissed after the game in the gym could have been so damn cute but those two acters dont have any conection between them. It just looked so fake too me that I could not enjoy it, i mean the chemistry between Sophia and Chad when they act is sooo good and it really makes you belieev that they are very much inlove, but hilarie and chad cant really capture that feeling together...i dont know really it just didnt work for me. Im a Leytoner and I thauht that I would be SO happy when they finally got together but i didnt feel a thing and i think its because they dont have that special IT feeling that makes me feel all warm inside...sorry but its not right.

Dont´t worry brucas lovers it´s not the end for them , it´s still a lot time to go till the season end , They are meant to be , And I shore hope the writers can see that too .

lets hope they can see that

Dont´t worry brucas lovers it´s not the end for them , it´s still a lot time to go till the season end , They are meant to be , And I shore hope the writers can see that too .

whatever im over it

this topic has been discussed out
lucas is with peyton

pce

PUCAS SUCK

grose! fine stupid writers loose about all the oth lovers over this mistake lucas and peyton are discusting me, obviesly he never even loved broóke because if he did then he would not have been with peyton now and he is...so fine leytoners you win! lucas and peyton are finally together and my poor brucas heart is bleading

I JUST WANNA SAY THAT IM NEVER GONNA WATCH ONE TREE HILL AGAIN BECAUSE THAT KISS BETWEEN LUCAS AND PEYTON IN THE GYM MADE ME SICK AND BROOKE ACTING ALL OKAY ABOUT IT IT SUCKED SO HARD THAT I ALMOAST DIED! I HATE THE WRITERS THANKS FOR NOTHING

lucas and brooke

Lucas && Peyton=)

Ok people!! Well All know that Brooke is a sweetheart i actually like her very much on the show...But she has always been portrayed as a little sl**t that cheated on lucas how many damn times, she was always sleeping around with someone. Now on the other hand lets be realistic peyton and lucas have always been the best of friends, always there for each other and peyton was first to go out with lucas, and i think they make a perfect match. The best od friends always make the best of lovers....And hopefully the story lines start getting better and peyton and lucas can remain together.

HAHA! BULLSHIT
first you point out that peyton and lucas should make a great couple since they have always been friends, well brooke and peyton were best friends and that didnt stop peyton from stealing brookes boyfriend so obviesly her friends dont mean a damn thing to her. And you also say that brooke cheated on lucas, give me one single time and i will prove yu wrong and dont say keller because she was not dating lucas at that point! And the fact that she was sleeping around is not true at all, she went to alot of partys but we never once saw her sleeping around. she made out with boys and she was not a virgin but it doesent mean that she slept with every boy she met...and she is not a slut because beeing a slut is beeing a damn teese who only cares about sex and brooke cares about love, why would she get mad at lucas AND mr chavez for cheating on her if she didnt?
your post sucked okay...i just proved it

Ok people!! Well All know that Brooke is a sweetheart i actually like her very much on the show...But she has always been portrayed as a little sl**t that cheated on lucas how many damn times, she was always sleeping around with someone. Now on the other hand lets be realistic peyton and lucas have always been the best of friends, always there for each other and peyton was first to go out with lucas, and i think they make a perfect match. The best od friends always make the best of lovers....And hopefully the story lines start getting better and peyton and lucas can remain together.

HAHA! BULLSHIT
first you point out that peyton and lucas should make a great couple since they have always been friends, well brooke and peyton were best friends and that didnt stop peyton from stealing brookes boyfriend so obviesly her friends dont mean a damn thing to her. And you also say that brooke cheated on lucas, give me one single time and i will prove yu wrong and dont say keller because she was not dating lucas at that point! And the fact that she was sleeping around is not true at all, she went to alot of partys but we never once saw her sleeping around. she made out with boys and she was not a virgin but it doesent mean that she slept with every boy she met...and she is not a slut because beeing a slut is beeing a damn teese who only cares about sex and brooke cares about love, why would she get mad at lucas AND mr chavez for cheating on her if she didnt?
your post sucked okay...i just proved it

fine, let brooke and lucas be just friends for now but he will fall for her charm again and she will fall for him! they are supposed to be together and they cant be friends without that happening okay..leyton should get a chance and then maby they can finally move on!

I´m a leyton fan , but wow now that I think about it peyton and lucas do seem like brother and sister !! eeewww OMG , why didn´t I see this sooner eeeeeeeewwwwwwwww!

HAHAHA THATS SO FUN!:D

Ok people!! Well All know that Brooke is a sweetheart i actually like her very much on the show...But she has always been portrayed as a little sl**t that cheated on lucas how many damn times, she was always sleeping around with someone. Now on the other hand lets be realistic peyton and lucas have always been the best of friends, always there for each other and peyton was first to go out with lucas, and i think they make a perfect match. The best od friends always make the best of lovers....And hopefully the story lines start getting better and peyton and lucas can remain together.

I am on team brooke, honestly I understand the whole divorce in real life issues...but its TV people and the audience would rather Brooke and Lucas be together because quite honestly Luke and Brooke are a match made in heaven. Brooke is the sweet girl everyone loves and Peyton just whines about everything and seems really vulnerable all the time. She needs to buck up and get back together with Jake because he would do anything for her and lets face it...he is hot and perfect for her. So my perfect couples are Luke and Brooke and Peyton and Jake.

Brooke and lucas of course! but nathan and haley are merveillus!!
laisser les tout les 2!! ne les separer pas jvou en supli!
tanks you
byby

Brooke penelope scott & Lucas eugene Scott = Sounds perfect

I was devastated to hear when brooke said that maybe it was a misstake for them getting back together and lucas said the same :/ But fore now it´s good that they are just friends , they have a lot think about right now . But in the end I hope the get togther , because they belong together and we all see that . So it would be wrong to keep them apart .
and they would have really great looking kids :P Tihi

And one more thing : Get leyton over soon please it´s getting old that they are going back and forth all the frakinn time . Peyton belongs with jake , They are sooooo Sweet :)

I´m a leyton fan , but wow now that I think about it peyton and lucas do seem like brother and sister !! eeewww OMG , why didn´t I see this sooner eeeeeeeewwwwwwwww!

Brooke and lucas are not even close to look like brother and sister , But peyton and lucas on the other hand .. almost like twins :D Haahahhaha

Now that was funny !!

Peyton && Lucas

brooke and lucas!!!

But Yah the producers should really consider Brooke and Lucas together not a couple that look like they could be brother &sister!! that is disgusting

haha funny:)

I hope that lucas and brooke can build up their friendship at first then get back together . allthough I would like to kinda see how it works out with peyton and lucas , even though I think that they are a miss mch and that it will not work . But putting them in the end ( if they do ) would be totally wrong , because bbrucas as been trough all lot and I mean a lot the past seasons Like a couple . It wpuld be ashame if they couldn´t be togeher in the end .

And i woud like for brooke to get more sorylines , its like peytonhill and not ONE TREE HIL . and it´s not just me who feel this way . ad that she shoul get her life together before she decides to do somethig drastic .

As I was saying I would like to se brucas rebiuld their friendship and then be romantic again :D and for lucas to spend more time with brooke all I see is peyton and lucas , it´s starting toget kinda boring :/ and even mark told us brucas will spend time tgether this season and we eould like to see taht actually happening soon .

Peyton and Lucas

If Lucas and Brooke got back together it would be boring . we've already seen how they function (or rather how they don't function) together. It would end in boring and repeating storylines ..
Peyton and Lucas's relationship is pretty much brand new .. anything can happen

Peyton && Lucas
ye YA

One Tree Hill=)

Everyone who is saying that they are going to boycott the show if Brooke and Lucas don't get together .. that sucks . ur gonna stop watching it cuz u dont get ur way? cmon...
the show doesn't need fans like yall anyway

p+l

I think its stupid that they're fighting over him. They've known each other longer and to lose that friendship over a stupid boy is gay. This has happened way too many times and I hate it!

I am on Brooke side because Brooke love Lucas and Peyton is it the one for Lucas Brooke is !!!!! an i think Brooke should be with Lucas !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I am on Brooke side Brooke love Lucas an i think Peyton should back of Lucas

Ok ,so look everybody it doesn´t really matter what we think or what we are writing here .
Peyton and lucas will be together in the end I hate to say it ( my poor brucas heart is bleading ) but I mean it´s been about them from the very beginning and may I say eeewww !!!! That´s why it´s taking so long for them to hook up so they can be together in the end , OMG , I think I will puke when that happens . but anyways and that´s why they are blowing brooke of with that stupid teacher . And it´s so damn annuying because peyton and lucas are a totaly miss mach . Brucas on the other hand are totaly right fro eachother , I just hope the writers are seeing it too I mean it didn´t really work out between brucas the way I think the audience hoped it would because that some one was always in the way . But I think the whole leyton thing should get strting so we can move on to brucas . untill then hope you enjoy the show . Peace out !

Okay I'm on Brooke's side!!! woohooo. Peyton doesn't deserve happiness because she ruins everyone elses. && this season no one will watch it except pucas fans because if brucas don't get to gether you are going to lose alot of viewers. No doubt in my mind because there is MORE ppl who l.o.v.e our brucas time then pucas time. I know I do. One Tree Hill makes me cry every single wensday just because they don't get together which I think is retarded they are meant for each other. && yet no one is doing anything about it. Peyton had her chance now it's Brooke's. Peyton gave up on Lucas in s1 so she needs to deal with the mistakes she made. Brooke went after him and should now rightfully deserve him. I <3 this show and I would really hate to quit watching it and alot off ppl on here would to. I never miss a eppi but if Peyton and Lucas get together I'm never watching it AGAIN. Because right now how there hanging out get's on my nerves Lucas should have some respect and not hang out with Peyton but there just FRIENDS it don't matter. BUt I am a definantly "TEAM BROOKE" Because my captain knows how to get a boyfriend the right way!!.

But Yah the producers should really consider Brooke and Lucas together not a couple that look like they could be brother &sister!! that is disgusting I woulnd't want to date someone that looked like they could be blood related. haha
well bye I'm done here b4 I get to carried away

THE DAY PYTON N LUCAS GO OUT!!!!!!!!THERE WILL BE LESS ONE TREE HILL FANS...TRUST ME...TRUST..ME!!!!!!!!!
PEYTON LOST HER CHANCE EVEN BEFORE BROOKE STARTED DATING LUCAS, SHE ASKED PEYTON IF IT WAS OK.THATS THE TIME PEYTON SHOULD'VE BEEN HONEST!NOT WHEN BROOKE HAS FALLEN IN LOVE!!! DAMN WHAT SO HARD!!!!!!!PRODUCER PLEASE I'M CRYING THERE'S NO TREE HILL WITH OUT BRUCAS.....WITH NALEY OK...BUT THEY NEED BRUCAS.....PEYTON SHOULD'VE JUST STAY WITH JAKE.........KILL HER DO SOMETHING WITH HER........I DON'T CARE DON'T LOSE BRUCAS....WELL DON'T KILL HER, BUT LEAVE BRUCAS ALONE

YO RIGHT NOW I'M SO PISSED!!!!!THERE'S NOTHING TO THINK ABOUT........BROOKE FINALLY MEETS A GAY THAT MAKES HER FEEL RIGHT FOR ONCE IN HER LIFE, THROUGH ALL HER DRAMA IN HER LIFE..SHE FINALLY..PEYTON HAD ALL HER CHANCES.NO ONE SCREWED IT UP FOR HER SHE DID. LUCAS BROOKE BROOKE'S HEART ONCE, SHE FORGAVE HIM.......THEN TWICE, EVEN THOUGH IT WAS A LIE, BUT HE STILL LOVES HER.BROOKE LOVES HIM.......IF A GAY SCREW UP ONCE SOME OF US WON'T GIVE THEM A CHANCE, BUT BROOKE DID...SHE SAW A FUTURE.NO ONE TREAT HER THE WAY LUCAS DOES. SHE TRIED IT WITH ANOTHER GAY IT DIDN'T WORK. THERE'S NO OTHER GAY FOR HER BUT LUCAS.PEYTON'S A BAD FRIEND.FRIENDS DON'T DO THINGS EVEN THOUGH WHEN THEY KNOW IT WILL HURT THEIR FRIEND. PEYTON SELFISH.LUCAS ANOTHER ONE.HE SEES BROOKE HURTING BUT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT. BUT THATS NORMAL HIS A GAY. BESTFRIENDS SUPPOSE TO UNDERSTAND.PEYTON'S NOT THAT. BROOKE TRIED LETTING GO BUT SHE CAN'T!!!!!!!WHATS SO HARD TO DECIDE..NOTHING!!BROOKE AND LUCAS 4EVA!!4 EVA....REMEBER THOSE DAYS.....

teammmmm Peyton=)

DEFINATELY TEAM PEYTON!! :D

one question here, doesent peyton know how to use her tounge when she kiss? it always looks so not nice

team brooke

team Peyton!=)

team brooke. lucas and brooke belong together. i just want this whole peyton crush to get resolved and for lucas to not settle for peyton...

Team Peyton, Brooke forgave her once why can't she forgive her now, Also I mean it's not like peyton slept wiht lucas or anything she just told brooke how she felt. Peyton really needs a friend right now and since haley is busy it would really help if brooke was there for her, I mean Peyton ALWAYS had her back. I would like to see Brooke return the favor.

Y'know what anonymous,I have an answer to your last post.But I'm not gonna type it.Instead I've decided to listen to "othrules!" and stop.
Pal,no amount of argument is gonna change the fact about whose side we are on.
Lets just continue watching the show.
And I agree that we would get a slap on our face when and if Peyton and Brooke make up.All this argument will go waste.What say you?
Peace?

Oh right,you won't ever because you're so thickheaded

i think peyton is the thickheaded one in her goldielocks image

LUCAS: Yeah. (she walks away starting to cry)

she doesent cry, she wipes her nose, and it doesent matter if they decided not to be together, because they decided that after they had almoast slept together, and then peyton told lucas they couldent be together at school and they kissed in the library, so they probably would have keept on doing it after this time too if brooke had not found out. and it doesent matter because they had already betraied her just because they decided not to do it anymore it doesent changes the fact that they already broke up a couple

TEAM BROOKE

One Tree Hill =)
Gotta love that show...

Anonymous,you first say well said and you're still not ready to stop the fight.Great!

Now I know no one wants to accept defeat.But hear me out.If you don't stop fighting it won't be over.Please make peace.I think both sides win because both have good arguments.

And it doesn't matter who wins does it because one fine day,the two WOULD make up.

And instead of fighting for this please fight for OTH so we have Season 5,6,7,8....and so on.

Right now,we see Brooke happy with Nick and I've never seen her so happy with Lucas.We see Peyton trying to get over the stalker incident and Lucas helping her.What is wrong with that?It's One Tree Hill and we'll have to watch it the way it is.
People saying they'll boycott the show are not true fans of the show.You should love OTH as a whole rather than just a character or two.

I plead,make peace.The only characters worth hating is Rachel and Dan.Please stop fighting over Peyton & Brooke and fight instead for OTH.

I've said all that is to say right now and I'll be back to check if you guys have made peace.

PEYTON: When I saw you lying there in the hospital right after the accident all I could think about was how my mom wasn’t as lucky as you. And then I remembered, after she died, it was Brooke who was there for me. We were just little kids and she would come over, every single day, to make sure I was okay. She’s been my best friend ever since.

LUCAS: Well life’s short, Peyton.

PEYTON: Too short to live it as a bad person. I cant betray her, Lucas.

LUCAS: You mean even more than we already have. (She gets up to leave) Peyton. I’m sorry.

PEYTON: Me too. But it‘s better this way, right?

LUCAS: Yeah. (she walks away starting to cry)

Now there you have it.Firstly,she did cry all you going on about how you never saw a single tear.Secondly,she did choose Brooke over Lucas and that was before she knew Brooke found out.Thirdly,she's made that mistake only once and that was when she hadn't told Brooke how she felt.And lastly,she didn't want to repeat that mistake that's why she told Brooke how she felt.

"brooke has to badmouth peyton or she will have NO friends since peyton and lucas are getting friendlier every minute...whats the girl to do? just be alone, no thats not brookes thing and when she deals with pain she doesent lock herself up like peyton she needs to be around people to heal."
So all I'm saying is that atleast Peyton does not badmouth her ex-bestfriend that's not her thing.Yeah go on defend Brooke for her thing and I'll defend Peyton for her thing.
And Brooke's not alone,she's got Nick now!And right now I think all she wants is him.

"peyton didnt chose brooke over peyton because she made out with lucas behind brookes back and it doesent matter if she said that they werent gonna do it anymore because she said that before and they still did. and brooke doesent chose lucas over peyton because she broke up with him to let him spread his wings, and if he wants to be with peyton she will let him.
and the fact that you say that you dont care if peyton betrayed brooke it shows that your okay with betrail, wich shows why your on peyton side.

there you have it"

Give me a break.She's so over him didn't you see last night!Oh right,you won't ever because you're so thickheaded.And yeah,Peyton did choose him over Brooke because she could have made up with Lucas after Brooke broke it off with her.But no,she fought for her the last time.
And Peyton's not the one who's badmouthing Brooke.And look at Brooke,badmouthing her infront of Haley and Rachel.Of course you think it makes no difference.

first of all nyou didnt answer to the fact that peyton and lucas made out behind brookes back. second, brooke has to badmouth peyton or she will have NO friends since peyton and lucas are getting friendlier every minute...whats the girl to do? just be alone, no thats not brookes thing and when she deals with pain she doesent lock herself up like peyton she needs to be around people to heal.

Y'know what'll really make me happy...people Loving OTH for the way it's going and stop fighting over petty issues such as this.

You'll all get a slap on your face when Peyton and Brooke make up.

Both Rock!Both make One Tree Hill!

well said

" My reason for being on her team is that,back in season 1,when Peyton had a choice,she chose Brooke,her best friend over the first guy she fell in love with.Now,Brooke chooses the guy she loves over her best friend. "

First of all peyton didn´t chose brooke over lucas . Second peyton didn´t fall in love wuth lucas before brooke did . And when brooke hooked up with lucas she still was friends with peyton .

Y'know what'll really make me happy...people Loving OTH for the way it's going and stop fighting over petty issues such as this.

You'll all get a slap on your face when Peyton and Brooke make up.

Both Rock!Both make One Tree Hill!

My reason for being on her team is that,back in season 1,when Peyton had a choice,she chose Brooke,her best friend over the first guy she fell in love with.Now,Brooke chooses the guy she loves over her best friend.
Now I don't care if Peyton betrayed Brooke.The choice of the matter is that Peyton always puts Brooke above herself.She could have easily broken it off with Brooke(back then)and gone with Lucas.But no,she chose Brooke.
And after choosing Lucas,she breaks up with him.
So I'm on Team Peyton.

peyton didnt chose brooke over peyton because she made out with lucas behind brookes back and it doesent matter if she said that they werent gonna do it anymore because she said that before and they still did. and brooke doesent chose lucas over peyton because she broke up with him to let him spread his wings, and if he wants to be with peyton she will let him.
and the fact that you say that you dont care if peyton betrayed brooke it shows that your okay with betrail, wich shows why your on peyton side.

there you have it

"ehm...first you say beat it because she didnt trust him then you say she trust him."

No I didn't say bout that NY thingy.But yeah,one Brucas fan says one thing then someone the other.Atleast us Team Peyton folks are united in our stand.That probably was added because one Brucas fan said she had a hard time trusting Lucas.And I don't get why you want them to be together if she can't trust him and last night said all those things about him!

"Brooke was hurt because they kissed again, and peyton didnt tell her about that when she told her that she still liked lucas, and brooke could have changed her mind about stop beeing friends with peyton if peyton just told her about the kiss. BROOKE SAID IT HERSELF TO HALEY, they kissed again, she didnt tell her that peyton liked him...she understands that peyton cant help it, what she doesent understand is why peyton didnt tell her about the kiss."
Yaha!Brooke called it quits with Peyton BEFORE she knew about the kiss!

"I read all of the answers to my last post, and i dont feel like copying it because i already explained everything that you bring up and im sick of it. why doesent it get through to you guys? i can not answer because you keep bringing the same stuff up...im on team brooke but im of this page for good, hope some other brookefan will take over for me..."
Honestly,things don't get through you.I'm off too cause nothing new is to discuss.Took me 2 hours to go through this page and it's getting way too monotonous.

Oh and this one thing was new:
My reason for being on her team is that,back in season 1,when Peyton had a choice,she chose Brooke,her best friend over the first guy she fell in love with.Now,Brooke chooses the guy she loves over her best friend.
Now I don't care if Peyton betrayed Brooke.The choice of the matter is that Peyton always puts Brooke above herself.She could have easily broken it off with Brooke(back then)and gone with Lucas.But no,she chose Brooke.
And after choosing Lucas,she breaks up with him.
So I'm on Team Peyton.

More emphasised and clear.Hope some Brooker comes and argues on this and a Peytoner beats the Brooker.

"anyone on team brooke?"
Not me.Not now,not ever.

anyone on team brooke?

So beat it!Brooke doesn't need to be with Lucas if she can't trust him."

Can't say she didn't trust him coz when Brooke returned from NY and saw Lucas with Peyton,she did trust him when he said they didnt do anything.

ehm...first you say beat it because she didnt trust him then you say she trust him.

Brooke was hurt because they kissed again, and peyton didnt tell her about that when she told her that she still liked lucas, and brooke could have changed her mind about stop beeing friends with peyton if peyton just told her about the kiss. BROOKE SAID IT HERSELF TO HALEY, they kissed again, she didnt tell her that peyton liked him...she understands that peyton cant help it, what she doesent understand is why peyton didnt tell her about the kiss.

I read all of the answers to my last post, and i dont feel like copying it because i already explained everything that you bring up and im sick of it. why doesent it get through to you guys? i can not answer because you keep bringing the same stuff up...im on team brooke but im of this page for good, hope some other brookefan will take over for me...

""But Brooke didnt trust lucas now completely either thats why she broke up with him. but it doesent mean that she doesent love him, first you love someone and then you start trusting them, she had just started to trust him again and then BAM! peyton drops the bomb..."
So beat it!Brooke doesn't need to be with Lucas if she can't trust him."

Can't say she didn't trust him coz when Brooke returned from NY and saw Lucas with Peyton,she did trust him when he said they didnt do anything.

As regards to who being with who,Lucas with Peyton!

"so, you have to have a bad selfimage to be with lucas. does she have to think that she is bad company to be with him?!
IT DIDNT MEAN SHE DIDNT MISS HIM, HOW MANY TIMES AM I GONNA HAVE TO SAY IT BEFORE IT GETS THROUGH???"

First,chill.Second,she implied that she wasn't feeling lonely without Lucas.And Lucas needs someone better than that.

"not counted?! Brooke liked him first, when peyton called him choke?! HOW MANY TIMES AM I GONNA HAVE TO REPEAT THAT?! and even if she had real feelings for him ( i doubt it) so did brooke."
Yeah but Peyton bonded with Lucas first.

"fine, then peyton and lucas are not ment to be either, because they couldent survive in the first season, and you say yourself that peyton is more vulnerable then brooke."
Peyton does not feel vulnerable when with Lucas.And they couldn't survive because Peyton chose Brooke over Lucas!I hope that settles it!

"yeah, but before that peyton knew how brooke felt about lucas. brooke just wanted to see if peyton would really do that to her. ONCE AGAIN SICK OF REPEATING MYSELF!"
Ho hum.Brooke only wanted to sleep with him at first.And when Peyton did indeed kiss Lucas,that should've cleared ti to Brooke that she had feelings for him because that's how she truly felt.

"But Brooke didnt trust lucas now completely either thats why she broke up with him. but it doesent mean that she doesent love him, first you love someone and then you start trusting them, she had just started to trust him again and then BAM! peyton drops the bomb..."
So beat it!Brooke doesn't need to be with Lucas if she can't trust him.

"yeah, why should they get to hear it? if brooke didnt love him then why did she stay with him when he didnt call her, and why did she support him after the shooting and why did she throw him a party and why did she tell him that she loved him? that shows that you love someone and peyton should get that she loves him from that!"
Because she was protecting him.She said herself.

"why not, she flirted with him when he was with brooke. Right, she only wants what she can not have, do you remember that she didnt start liking him until he had gone out with brooke"
No she didn't flirt with him.She went behind Brooke's back.That was last time but.This time,it's another story.And last time,she did try helping Brooke connect with Lucas,something she never could have done alone because all she was good at was sex.

"you know what, this is my last post to, im over this site. I think Peyton is grate! she has personality, she can be a really good friend but I think Brooke is right in this matter! Hats of to you for sticking with your side and giving good arguments, but i think Brucas is the way its supposed to be"
It was always supposed to be Leyton.And still is!

I'm on Team Peyton and I'm not here to argue.
My reason for being on her team is that,back in season 1,when Peyton had a choice,she chose Brooke,her best friend over the first guy she fell in love with.Now,Brooke chooses the guy she loves over her best friend.
Now I don't care if Peyton betrayed Brooke.The choice of the matter is that Peyton always puts Brooke above herself.She could have easily broken it off with Brooke(back then)and gone with Lucas.But no,she chose Brooke.
And after choosing Lucas,she breaks up with him.
So I'm on Team Peyton.

Egon is on team brooke:D

Brooke was hurt because they kissed again, and peyton didnt tell her about that when she told her that she still liked lucas, and brooke could have changed her mind about stop beeing friends with peyton if peyton just told her about the kiss. BROOKE SAID IT HERSELF TO HALEY, they kissed again, she didnt tell her that peyton liked him...she understands that peyton cant help it, what she doesent understand is why peyton didnt tell her about the kiss.

Besides,if Brooke isn't fake,why the hell she tells Rachel that stuff of not lying about her age and then doing the same thing.

because brooke is hurting from loosing a boyfriend, rachel just lies for the hell of it

if Brooke loved and missed him so much,why did she say she's not bad company

so, you have to have a bad selfimage to be with lucas. does she have to think that she is bad company to be with him?!
IT DIDNT MEAN SHE DIDNT MISS HIM, HOW MANY TIMES AM I GONNA HAVE TO SAY IT BEFORE IT GETS THROUGH???

First reason not counted since Peyton had real feelings for Lucas when Brooke hooked up with him

not counted?! Brooke liked him first, when peyton called him choke?! HOW MANY TIMES AM I GONNA HAVE TO REPEAT THAT?! and even if she had real feelings for him ( i doubt it) so did brooke.

Second,if Brooke's so vulnerable,maybe they are not meant to be.A relationship not strong is not a relationship at all

fine, then peyton and lucas are not ment to be either, because they couldent survive in the first season, and you say yourself that peyton is more vulnerable then brooke.

Brooke dared Peyton by saying,I dare you to show us how you really feel. Kiss Lucas.So there we have it

yeah, but before that peyton knew how brooke felt about lucas. brooke just wanted to see if peyton would really do that to her. ONCE AGAIN SICK OF REPEATING MYSELF!

Peyton didn't tell Brooke how she felt.And last time was different.Lucas had feelings for Peyton too back then.And last time too Peyton tried,this time she would have tried harder.And it would have all been easier if Brooke was with her this time,helping her to get over him rather than slapping her.Look at it this way,she's not told Lucas yet about her feelings.She's bloody waiting for him to come back.And also yeah...if Brooke could trust Lucas,the guy who betrayed her for her best friend,how hard it could be to trust her best friend.You seriously keep blaming Peyton for not thinking whereas I think she must have given it a lot of thought.

But Brooke didnt trust lucas now completely either thats why she broke up with him. but it doesent mean that she doesent love him, first you love someone and then you start trusting them, she had just started to trust him again and then BAM! peyton drops the bomb...

yeah,Brooke loves him so much that she thinks neither Peyton nor Rachel deserve to hear it!

yeah, why should they get to hear it? if brooke didnt love him then why did she stay with him when he didnt call her, and why did she support him after the shooting and why did she throw him a party and why did she tell him that she loved him? that shows that you love someone and peyton should get that she loves him from that!

She had a boyfriend in namesake!What was she supposed to do,flirt with him??

why not, she flirted with him when he was with brooke. Right, she only wants what she can not have, do you remember that she didnt start liking him until he had gone out with brooke?

you know what, this is my last post to, im over this site. I think Peyton is grate! she has personality, she can be a really good friend but I think Brooke is right in this matter! Hats of to you for sticking with your side and giving good arguments, but i think Brucas is the way its supposed to be!

"okay, so Peyton didnt single out Brooke when she was with Jake?"
And Brooke singled out her first for Felix,when she had the episode with drugs.
"and she dindt single brooke out when she stole lucas behind brookes back?"
And so did Brooke while she was having fun with Lucas.

"but peyton teeses them. Yeah thats her game, she gets into bed with them and then she runs of acting all sad and hurt:S whats that about, brooke isnt fake!"
No she didn't want to tease Lucas,she got scared.A boyfriend only for benefit,two dead moms and a fake bro is all it takes.And she didn't run acting sad and hurt.Besides,if Brooke isn't fake,why the hell she tells Rachel that stuff of not lying about her age and then doing the same thing.

"okay, so if best friends are supposed to be mindreaders then peyton should know that its not okay to steal your best friends boyfriend, she should know that brooke was already valrnualbe in her relationship with lucas and she should absolutely know that Brooke loved and missed him even though she said she wasnt as dependet on him as she used to.
and she knew that even in the beginning brooke liked him first but it didnt stop her from kissing him at the party... now did it?"
First reason not counted since Peyton had real feelings for Lucas when Brooke hooked up with him.Second,if Brooke's so vulnerable,maybe they are not meant to be.A relationship not strong is not a relationship at all.Third,if Brooke loved and missed him so much,why did she say she's not bad company.Clearly,she didn't miss Lucas' company so much.And if she loved him,why didn't she jump at Rachel when she said Brooke didn't love Lucas.Lastly,Brooke dared Peyton by saying,I dare you to show us how you really feel. Kiss Lucas.So there we have it.She knew how Peyton felt.Yet when Peyton ran off because she was done with the drama of dating,that too right after breaking up with Nathan,it didn't stop her from seducing Lucas.So Peyton has a reason for not committing so easily.

"because peyton didnt Bury it the last time then she almoast slept with lucas, why should brooke believe her now? please think! im sick of saying this over and over again"
And I'm sick too saying last time,Peyton didn't tell Brooke how she felt.And last time was different.Lucas had feelings for Peyton too back then.And last time too Peyton tried,this time she would have tried harder.And it would have all been easier if Brooke was with her this time,helping her to get over him rather than slapping her.Look at it this way,she's not told Lucas yet about her feelings.She's bloody waiting for him to come back.And also yeah...if Brooke could trust Lucas,the guy who betrayed her for her best friend,how hard it could be to trust her best friend.You seriously keep blaming Peyton for not thinking whereas I think she must have given it a lot of thought.

"that doesent mean that peyton can steal her boyfriend, and it shure as hell doesent mean that peyton dosnt have the knack for that because she obviesly thaught it was okay to tell brooke that she likes lucas...thats right LIKES not LOVES like brooke"
Well lucas is no longer her bf.Last time I explained and yeah,Brooke loves him so much that she thinks neither Peyton nor Rachel deserve to hear it!

"peyton only wanted to hurt him in the beginning dissing him and stuff! and that grew...so did brookes interest, and also how do we know that she only wanted to sleep with him she never said that...she probably wanted him because she really liked him even if she didnt say so, I mean you should know and so should peyton since bestfriends are supposed to be mindreaders...right?"
She had a boyfriend in namesake!What was she supposed to do,flirt with him??

Yeah,agreed Brooke really liked him.But Peyton like him too,more than just physically.I say that because Brooke stripped in his car and said to Peyton "Brooke: No, I think he’s just nice. Anyway, it’s gonna be so great when he sleeps with me!"So we know what Brooke really wanted,at first.

"everybody just stop it with the LOL its so lame, the only time you can ever say that is when someone sais Peyton and Lucas for life, now thats LOL!"
ROTFLOL to that!

"this site is seriously getting boring. argueing the same things over and over...some of you i seriously think are like 10 years old"
Yeah and this is why this is my last post.I have my reaons for Leyton and they have their reasons for Brucas.I'm not fighting that.I'm fighting people always blaming only Peyton and regarding Brooke as an angel,because honestly,I love Brooke.But she's not blameless in this whole thing.

this site is seriously getting boring. argueing the same things over and over...some of you i seriously think are like 10 years old.

everybody just stop it with the LOL its so lame, the only time you can ever say that is when someone sais Peyton and Lucas for life, now thats LOL!

That does not absolve her.I do blame her because she said she'd never single out Peyton for a guy and that's what she does all the time.

okay, so Peyton didnt single out Brooke when she was with Jake? she only spend time with him then, and she dindt single brooke out when she stole lucas behind brookes back?

"brooke knew lucas and peyton was there right behind her"
No Lucas wasn't.Beside,Peyton had a solid reason for kissing Lucas.Atleast she doesn't go around kissing guys just for the heck of it(like Brooke with Pete and fake Derek)

okay, fist of all, peyton was there, second of all she thaught she was dreaming and third peyton didnt love Pete. And maby she kisses guys for the hell of it, but peyton teeses them. Yeah thats her game, she gets into bed with them and then she runs of acting all sad and hurt:S whats that about, brooke isnt fake!

Absolves Peyton for being a good friend while it lasted.But not Brooke.BFF are supposed to be mindreaders.

okay, so if best friends are supposed to be mindreaders then peyton should know that its not okay to steal your best friends boyfriend, she should know that brooke was already valrnualbe in her relationship with lucas and she should absolutely know that Brooke loved and missed him even though she said she wasnt as dependet on him as she used to.
and she knew that even in the beginning brooke liked him first but it didnt stop her from kissing him at the party... now did it?

Yeah she believes Peyton when she tells her she's cool with that but not when she tells she's gonna bury it.LOL!"

because peyton didnt Bury it the last time then she almoast slept with lucas, why should brooke believe her now? please think! im sick of saying this over and over again...

Right.Brooke has quite the knack of believing what she wants to.Not what she should.

that doesent mean that peyton can steal her boyfriend, and it shure as hell doesent mean that peyton dosnt have the knack for that because she obviesly thaught it was okay to tell brooke that she likes lucas...thats right LIKES not LOVES like brooke

Haha!Forgot that at first Brooke only wanted to sleep with him!

peyton only wanted to hurt him in the beginning dissing him and stuff! and that grew...so did brookes interest, and also how do we know that she only wanted to sleep with him she never said that...she probably wanted him because she really liked him even if she didnt say so, I mean you should know and so should peyton since bestfriends are supposed to be mindreaders...right?

I rest my case

That does not absolve her.I do blame her because she said she'd never single out Peyton for a guy and that's what she does all the time.

okay, so Peyton didnt single out Brooke when she was with Jake? she only spend time with him then, and she dindt single brooke out when she stole lucas behind brookes back?

"brooke knew lucas and peyton was there right behind her"
No Lucas wasn't.Beside,Peyton had a solid reason for kissing Lucas.Atleast she doesn't go around kissing guys just for the heck of it(like Brooke with Pete and fake Derek)

okay, fist of all, peyton was there, second of all she thaught she was dreaming and third peyton didnt love Pete. And maby she kisses guys for the hell of it, but peyton teeses them. Yeah thats her game, she gets into bed with them and then she runs of acting all sad and hurt:S whats that about, brooke isnt fake!

Absolves Peyton for being a good friend while it lasted.But not Brooke.BFF are supposed to be mindreaders.

okay, so if best friends are supposed to be mindreaders then peyton should know that its not okay to steal your best friends boyfriend, she should know that brooke was already valrnualbe in her relationship with lucas and she should absolutely know that Brooke loved and missed him even though she said she wasnt as dependet on him as she used to.
and she knew that even in the beginning brooke liked him first but it didnt stop her from kissing him at the party... now did it?

Yeah she believes Peyton when she tells her she's cool with that but not when she tells she's gonna bury it.LOL!"

because peyton didnt Bury it the last time then she almoast slept with lucas, why should brooke believe her now? please think! im sick of saying this over and over again...

Right.Brooke has quite the knack of believing what she wants to.Not what she should.

that doesent mean that peyton can steal her boyfriend, and it shure as hell doesent mean that peyton dosnt have the knack for that because she obviesly thaught it was okay to tell brooke that she likes lucas...thats right LIKES not LOVES like brooke

"And Brooke tried to look after Peyton but she felt so guilty, she was confused she didnt know what to do because she loved Keith and she lost him that day, and her boyfriend was depressed and her bestfriend was shoot and she felt responsible for the whoal thing so you cant blame her for beeing a distracted."

That does not absolve her.I do blame her because she said she'd never single out Peyton for a guy and that's what she does all the time.

"brooke knew lucas and peyton was there right behind her"
No Lucas wasn't.Beside,Peyton had a solid reason for kissing Lucas.Atleast she doesn't go around kissing guys just for the heck of it(like Brooke with Pete and fake Derek)

"so?! then you prove yourself that it wasnt just looks that attracted Brooke to Lucas."
Haha!Forgot that at first Brooke only wanted to sleep with him!

"you guys make us say stuff over and over again, because you just cant listen"
So can't you.What about this:

"but did she?! no she did not so if she couldent even say that she loved him when he was unconscious then she obvielsy didnt love him"
I said she said that when he was unconscious.To Hayley.

"When Keith died,Peyton told Lucas not to shut out Brooke even when Brooke didn't tell her so.When Brooke slept with Chris and Lucas was angry,Peyton tried to convince Lucas otherwise."
Absolves Peyton for being a good friend while it lasted.But not Brooke.BFF are supposed to be mindreaders.

""Why should Brooke always know that when Peyton sais something is cool its infact not, then you prove youself that when peyton sais that she is not going to go after lucas brooke has no reason to believe her since peyton clearly (you said it yourself so dont fight it) has a history of telling brooke that she is cool with stuff that she infact not is."

Yeah she believes Peyton when she tells her she's cool with that but not when she tells she's gonna bury it.LOL!"

Right.Brooke has quite the knack of believing what she wants to.Not what she should.

"if she wasent sneaking around then why didnt she tell brooke?"
When Brooke kissed Pete Lucas wasn't there.So why didn't she tell Lucas?Her reason for kissing Pete was that she was dreaming so Peyton's reason for kissing was that she was dying.

brooke knew lucas and peyton was there right behind her.

It does.If Lucas wasn't so good to her(like he is with everybody)she would never have taken him seriously.And she always got what she wanted.

so?! then you prove yourself that it wasnt just looks that attracted Brooke to Lucas.

Brooke and Lucas are so meant to be together. Brooke is so bubbly and sweet and he is sucha great boyfriend to her. they belong together!
i also think peyton and brooke really need echother they are so cute when they have their little girltalks. Peyton and Lucas are to much alike they would make great friends and I hope they will always be friends because Brooke needs to understand that Lucas and Peyton are friends but Peyton needs to understand thta Lucas and ehr are not supposed to be with eachoter and that he loves brooke. Brooke loves him to and they will find their way back i think evantually

"WHAT?! Brooke didnt make any mistakes after the shooting! was it a mistake when she lost peyton and ran out to tell lucas that peyton was still in there, was it a mistake when she tried to talk to peyton about it? was it a mistake when she tried to look after her boyfriend? you said that she was to busy with herself, when she was trying to make lucas feel good!, throwing him a party and trying to talk to him is not thinking about yourself.
and it gets on my nerves that you guys say that just because peyton said she was cool with it it didnt hurt, and when you say that brooke should have known without having to ask that it wasent okay for her to date lucas. she isnt A DAMN MINDREADER! Why should Brooke always know that when Peyton sais something is cool its infact not, then you prove youself that when peyton sais that she is not going to go after lucas brooke has no reason to believe her since peyton clearly (you said it yourself so dont fight it) has a history of telling brooke that she is cool with stuff that she infact not is."

Well she didn't exactly run out to tell Lucas about Peyton.She just found him there and blurted it.
Yeah,throwing a party after Keith's death would have made him feel good.Looking after her boyfriend mattered more to her than looking after her best friend.
Agreed she isn't a mindreader.But she's supposed to be her best friend and best friends should know about these things.And here I mean Brooke should have known that Peyton had a hard time opening up to people.
And also here I add that it was wrong of Peyton to go behind Brooke's back.That's what she shouldn't have done.
Again,Peyton has a history of telling Brooke she is cool with stuff like that and all.But let me remind you,this time she didn't say she was cool with it.She said she will bury it.And if Brooke had said that night that she missed Lucas very much,I'm sure Peyton would never had told Brooke that.

Brooke did tell Lucas and she was panicing, what do you expect? If it was okay that Peyton kissed Lucas because she was in chock then its okay for brooke not to tell Lucas, but she did tell him that peyton was inthere. And its not Brookes fault because even Peyton was going through the panic that brooke was going through because she said herslef to lucas "Lucas I lost Brooke Im sorry" so it wasent anybodys fault.
and Brooke knows peyton has trouble letting people in but she obviesley thaught that she didnt have trouble letting her in because they had been friends for ten years. So when Peyton told Brooke something Brooke believed her because she tahaught that peyton atleast trusted her.
And Brooke tried to look after Peyton but she felt so guilty, she was confused she didnt know what to do because she loved Keith and she lost him that day, and her boyfriend was depressed and her bestfriend was shoot and she felt responsible for the whoal thing so you cant blame her for beeing a distracted.

"if she wasent sneaking around then why didnt she tell brooke?"
When Brooke kissed Pete Lucas wasn't there.So why didn't she tell Lucas?Her reason for kissing Pete was that she was dreaming so Peyton's reason for kissing was that she was dying.
So you really can't keep slamming only Peyton.

And now one last thing(because this is getting boring,trying to explain the same issues over and over):

you guys make us say stuff over and over again, because you just cant listen

Because if she did,Brooke would have exploded again.And oh,when she did tell Brooke about her feelings for Lucas,what did Brooke do???

she got mad, there is nothing wrong with that. And I know your gonna say that brooke slapped her but she ddnt slap her because of that she slapped her because she twisted her words. and if she could tell brooke that then why couldent she tell her about the kiss?

"Peyton gave him a CD Brooke gave him her hart

that is so completley true!"

No it's not.When Lucas was unconscious,Peyton just wanted to tell him that she loved him

but did she?! no she did not so if she couldent even say that she loved him when he was unconscious then she obvielsy didnt love him

"she isnt A DAMN MINDREADER! "

When Keith died,Peyton told Lucas not to shut out Brooke even when Brooke didn't tell her so.When Brooke slept with Chris and Lucas was angry,Peyton tried to convince Lucas otherwise.
It's not Brooke's fault if she's not a mindreader.And neither is it Peyton's that she is.Except of course when she told about her feelings to Brooke.

"Why should Brooke always know that when Peyton sais something is cool its infact not, then you prove youself that when peyton sais that she is not going to go after lucas brooke has no reason to believe her since peyton clearly (you said it yourself so dont fight it) has a history of telling brooke that she is cool with stuff that she infact not is."

Yeah she believes Peyton when she tells her she's cool with that but not when she tells she's gonna bury it.LOL!

.Yeah Peyton betrayed Brooke the last time.But it was because Brooke stole the guy Peyton had feelings for in the first place.And even Lucas had feelings for her.

but brooke didnt steal him because see, she liked him first.

"a lot of the people on this site aren't, i think, good One Tree Hill fans

cuz if yall were then u wouldnt be badmouthing every character..i like every single character and i love the show"

I love you for saying this.Though I must add that I like Brooke and am on Team Brooke.But I don't like Brooke with Lucas.He should be with Peyton.

"peyton stole brookes boyfriend once and you dont think it makes her a boyfriendstealer and backstabber"
Most of Peyton lovers do.But that was first season not now.

"doesent really take a genious to figure out who she is talking about?!"

It does.If Lucas wasn't so good to her(like he is with everybody)she would never have taken him seriously.And she always got what she wanted.

"yeah I twisted your words, but it isnt an argument for peyton, now is it?
and just because i twisted your words once it doesent make me an official wordtwister because peyton stole brookes boyfriend once and you dont think it makes her a boyfriendstealer and backstabber"

You mentioned that I was okay with wordtwisting which I wasn't.Yeah Peyton betrayed Brooke the last time.But it was because Brooke stole the guy Peyton had feelings for in the first place.And even Lucas had feelings for her.

"OH MY GOD DYLAN! Me and many more Brucasers answered to your last posts with really good answers and THIS is the best you have? haha you really get a lot of credit for that one! it rimes...oooo"

I've read Dylan's posts and I think she is giving you a taste of your own medicine.

"if she wasent sneaking around then why didnt she tell brooke?"
Because if she did,Brooke would have exploded again.And oh,when she did tell Brooke about her feelings for Lucas,what did Brooke do???

"why should brooke care for a friend that keeps liking her boyfriend?"

Because you simply saying Peyton isn't trying to get Brooke back is not done.They are both done for now and that's the end of story.

"WHAT?! Brooke didnt make any mistakes after the shooting! was it a mistake when she lost peyton and ran out to tell lucas that peyton was still in there, was it a mistake when she tried to talk to peyton about it? was it a mistake when she tried to look after her boyfriend? you said that she was to busy with herself, when she was trying to make lucas feel good!, throwing him a party and trying to talk to him is not thinking about yourself.
and it gets on my nerves that you guys say that just because peyton said she was cool with it it didnt hurt, and when you say that brooke should have known without having to ask that it wasent okay for her to date lucas. she isnt A DAMN MINDREADER! Why should Brooke always know that when Peyton sais something is cool its infact not, then you prove youself that when peyton sais that she is not going to go after lucas brooke has no reason to believe her since peyton clearly (you said it yourself so dont fight it) has a history of telling brooke that she is cool with stuff that she infact not is."

Well she didn't exactly run out to tell Lucas about Peyton.She just found him there and blurted it.
Yeah,throwing a party after Keith's death would have made him feel good.Looking after her boyfriend mattered more to her than looking after her best friend.
Agreed she isn't a mindreader.But she's supposed to be her best friend and best friends should know about these things.And here I mean Brooke should have known that Peyton had a hard time opening up to people.
And also here I add that it was wrong of Peyton to go behind Brooke's back.That's what she shouldn't have done.
Again,Peyton has a history of telling Brooke she is cool with stuff like that and all.But let me remind you,this time she didn't say she was cool with it.She said she will bury it.And if Brooke had said that night that she missed Lucas very much,I'm sure Peyton would never had told Brooke that.

"I have never heard an explenation...bring it"
Scroll down,like I did.

"Peyton gave him a CD Brooke gave him her hart

that is so completley true!"

No it's not.When Lucas was unconscious,Peyton just wanted to tell him that she loved him.

And now one last thing(because this is getting boring,trying to explain the same issues over and over):

Right now,Brooke has broken up with Lucas,after all Lucas did to get her back,because she has stopped missing him.Lucas needs to be with someone whom he has meaningful conversations with and whom he misses when he isn't around her.It could be Peyton,it could not be Peyton.But it's definitely not Brooke because neither Brooke nor Lucas are fighting for each other.
And Peyton is only doing what Jake told her to do.Return to Tree Hill and find out what she really wanted.

And now that Brooke and Lucas are no longer together and neither are Peyton and Brooke,Peyton is doing nothing wrong by going after a guy who has feelings for her ex-best friend (and also feels that it's over) because Brooke has done that too and you cannot deny that.

a lot of the people on this site aren't, i think, good One Tree Hill fans

cuz if yall were then u wouldnt be badmouthing every character..i like every single character and i love the show

Peyton && Lucas

Peyton gave him a CD Brooke gave him her hart

that is so completley true!

Comon Brucasers you guys have such good comments dont leave me hanging here:) answer to the posts that the Pucasers write, its not so hard since they all pretty much suck...

p.s Pucasers dont have do answer this post is for Brucasers only

brooke sucks , peyton rocks !!

OH MY GOD DYLAN! Me and many more Brucasers answered to your last posts with really good answers and THIS is the best you have? haha you really get a lot of credit for that one! it rimes...oooo

Well then you don't say Peyton kissing Lucas was wrong because she was dying.She wasn't sneaking around.

if she wasent sneaking around then why didnt she tell brooke?

Why should Peyton care for such a friend who keeps insulting her.

why should brooke care for a friend that keeps liking her boyfriend?

The kiss was explained,yet you keep bringing it up.

I have never heard an explenation...bring it

And after the shooting,when Brooke was so busy with herself.Was she there for Peyton.And before you say Peyton was totally cool about that,lemme say who will force herself on her best friend saying--"Oh damn!Why weren't you there I needed you and you weren't there for me"She didn't say it doesn't mean she didn't get hurt.

WHAT?! Brooke didnt make any mistakes after the shooting! was it a mistake when she lost peyton and ran out to tell lucas that peyton was still in there, was it a mistake when she tried to talk to peyton about it? was it a mistake when she tried to look after her boyfriend? you said that she was to busy with herself, when she was trying to make lucas feel good!, throwing him a party and trying to talk to him is not thinking about yourself.
and it gets on my nerves that you guys say that just because peyton said she was cool with it it didnt hurt, and when you say that brooke should have known without having to ask that it wasent okay for her to date lucas. she isnt A DAMN MINDREADER! Why should Brooke always know that when Peyton sais something is cool its infact not, then you prove youself that when peyton sais that she is not going to go after lucas brooke has no reason to believe her since peyton clearly (you said it yourself so dont fight it) has a history of telling brooke that she is cool with stuff that she infact not is.

Good one and I'll add a fact to that.Nikki wasn't Peyton's best friend of 8 years(back then)

but brooke was peytons friend for eight years back and she stole her boyfriend...its worse than hitting somebody

Yeah sure Peyton called him a choke.You hit on a guy in front of your boyfriend.And when Brooke was talking about a serious relationship,it wasn't Lucas that she mentioned specifically.

Peyton: why are you so hung up on lucas, shouldent you already have moved on normally?

Brooke: yeah, but maby I want a serious relationship with someone

doesent really take a genious to figure out who she is talking about?!

she didn't want to run after a guy who didn't like her? all abercrombie wanted was to sleep with her..
and if she REALLY cared about Lucas back then, then it would seem to be pretty soon for her to just give herself up like that...hmmm kinda like her now with the teacher...
after Lucas and Peyton stopped hooking up in season 1 she told him after the whole nikki thing --"It’s just that, after all the stuff that you and I had been through, where my head and my heart were at I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger."apparently Brooke's feelings toward Lucas weren't as strong because she did sleep with some random person TWICE!

"but that is just the way brooke moves on!"

and you think theres nothing wrong with that?

Those ain't 2 arguments.It's one reason for 2 different things.

still didnt see a good argument for peyton in there, then atleast i have one, you have non

"oh sorry, i thaguth you were okay with wordtwisting since your on peytons side...my bad:P"

And that makes you an official wordtwister!Congrats!You admitted you twisted my words.

yeah I twisted your words, but it isnt an argument for peyton, now is it?
and just because i twisted your words once it doesent make me an official wordtwister because peyton stole brookes boyfriend once and you dont think it makes her a boyfriendstealer and backstabber

"tackle, slap?tackle someone is even worse. and if i need to get my fact straight then why do you guys keep saying that peyton liked lucas first when brooke was the one wanting a serious relationship with him and peyton was the one who called him a choke..."

So she shoulda just let Nikki get the better of her.Gimme a break!

Yeah sure Peyton called him a choke.You hit on a guy in front of your boyfriend.And when Brooke was talking about a serious relationship,it wasn't Lucas that she mentioned specifically.

"oh sorry, i thaguth you were okay with wordtwisting since your on peytons side...my bad:P"

And that makes you an official wordtwister!Congrats!You admitted you twisted my words.

"Once you say Brooke freaked cause Peyton liked Lucas and once you say she freaked because she twisted her words.Can you be more clear than use the same defence for two completely different things.Oh right,you can't come up with anything new,not to mention better.

you know what, atleast I have those two arguments, you insult my arguments but dont give any of yourown. atleast i have some, you cant even give that"

Those ain't 2 arguments.It's one reason for 2 different things.

"actually Peyton tackled Nikki .. AFTER nikki slapped her..get ur facts straight"

Good one and I'll add a fact to that.Nikki wasn't Peyton's best friend of 8 years(back then)

"pete, i explained derek she kissed to teese peyton"
Well then you don't say Peyton kissing Lucas was wrong because she was dying.She wasn't sneaking around.

"ehm...peyton made some mistakes at the wedding that could probably have saved her friendship with brooke. I mean when she told brooke she cried, when she was at the wedding she dissed her and said stuff like "Go brooke yourself" and when she got home she cried to brooke again. confusing...first she sais she wants her as a friend, then she totally disses her, and then all of a sudden she wants to be friends with her again. whatta?!
ofcourse brooke doesent take it seriousley...i mean why should she?"

Well she dissed her at the wedding because Brooke said "now I know how that dress looks like on a witch"Why should Peyton care for such a friend who keeps insulting her.

"atleast we have new arguments, you guys have non. your arguments are usually like this "brookes a slut" and im sorry but it doesent win you a damn thing"
What new arguments?You're bickering about the same things over and over.With Jake and Pete was explained but you keep delving into that.The kiss was explained,yet you keep bringing it up.

"we have edmitted that brooke has made mistakes but her mistakes have never been bad for her best friend."
And after the shooting,when Brooke was so busy with herself.Was she there for Peyton.And before you say Peyton was totally cool about that,lemme say who will force herself on her best friend saying--"Oh damn!Why weren't you there I needed you and you weren't there for me"She didn't say it doesn't mean she didn't get hurt.

Peyton gave him a CD Brooke gave him her hart

brooke sucks , peyton rocks !!

actually Peyton tackled Nikki .. AFTER nikki slapped her..get ur facts straight

tackle, slap?tackle someone is even worse. and if i need to get my fact straight then why do you guys keep saying that peyton liked lucas first when brooke was the one wanting a serious relationship with him and peyton was the one who called him a choke...

but Brooke has been notorious for saying "a kiss always means something", so by her kissing Pete and Derek she must either be a liar and a hypocrite, or the kisses meant something

a kiss always means something but it has different meanings. When you see a big popstar and kiss them it means that you think they are awsome, when you kiss Derek it means that you want to teese peyton and when you kiss your best friends boyfriend and tells him that you love him it means that you love him and want him

she didn't want to run after a guy who didn't like her? all abercrombie wanted was to sleep with her..
and if she REALLY cared about Lucas back then, then it would seem to be pretty soon for her to just give herself up like that...hmmm kinda like her now with the teacher...
after Lucas and Peyton stopped hooking up in season 1 she told him after the whole nikki thing --"It’s just that, after all the stuff that you and I had been through, where my head and my heart were at I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger."apparently Brooke's feelings toward Lucas weren't as strong because she did sleep with some random person TWICE!

but that is just the way brooke moves on! she cant just sit aroung her house feeling blue, she needs to do stuff or she will just think about Lúcas.
and brooke and luca had neveer been together at that point she had just started to like him but not love him. And they had not been through anything together so it wasent so strange that she could sleep with abercrombie, because you just compared two totally different moments in time.
And this time with the teacher Brooke needed that because she couldent just sit around doing nothing it was the way she delt with it. And my point with that whoal story was just that brooke liked lucas first, and so you guys can not say that peyton did. Just because Brooke almoast slept with abercrombie it doesent mean that she didnt like lucas, they had never even kissed yet then so it was nothing going on between them. but as you know lucas started liking brooke and it blossomed...

"brooke didnt think that she would get lucas so she tried to move on, later that night she noticed that he was interested in her, and went for it. I mean she didnt want to run after a guy who didnt even like her (unlike peyton), so she tried to give it up. but lucas started liking her...and you know the rest"

she didn't want to run after a guy who didn't like her? all abercrombie wanted was to sleep with her..
and if she REALLY cared about Lucas back then, then it would seem to be pretty soon for her to just give herself up like that...hmmm kinda like her now with the teacher...
after Lucas and Peyton stopped hooking up in season 1 she told him after the whole nikki thing --"It’s just that, after all the stuff that you and I had been through, where my head and my heart were at I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger."apparently Brooke's feelings toward Lucas weren't as strong because she did sleep with some random person TWICE!

"And if a kiss is a kiss,Brooke needs that more because she kissed Pete as well as fake Derek

pete, i explained derek she kissed to teese peyton"

but Brooke has been notorious for saying "a kiss always means something", so by her kissing Pete and Derek she must either be a liar and a hypocrite, or the kisses meant something

" What are you doing then?Saying Peyton and Lucas suck together doesn't help you either. "

"I never said that . Check your information before you wright . Haha LOL ,
atleast I Give rasons for brucas insetad of humilliate other fellow OTH fans . Peace Out ! :D "

"PEYTON AND LUCAS

suck together"

hmmmm...

"peyton NEVER dumped lucas, or what show have you been watching?"
Durk!Forget "Life As A Glass House",where Lucas and Peyton hook up and she leaves him when he talks of getting serious?What show have you been watching?

dump is breaking up with someone, and you guys sais that brooke doesent love lucas cause she dumped him, but then why did peyton dump lucas?"

to "dump" someone you need to be dating them, Peyton never actually dated Lucas .. she did not dump him, she stopped him... something she later realized was a mistake ...
Brooke simply DUMPED him

ONE reason why Brooke and Lucas should not be together:

1. Recently Lucas announced to Brooke's face "I was wrong. I am not the guy for you Brooke Davis"

"well after your best friend tells you she wants your boyfriend for the second time it would seem appealing to slap them i think"
No she didn't say she wanted him.And slapping someone is immature don't you think?"

"when you like someone you want them, and peyton slapped nicki...immature much?"

actually Peyton tackled Nikki .. AFTER nikki slapped her..get ur facts straight

Brucas because

1. Peyton gave him a CD Brooke gave him her hart

2. Because Brooke told him she loved him on the phone

3. Because Brooke trusted him to go away with Peyton alone and look for Peytons dad

4. Because Brooke gave him a necklace

5. Because they have matching tatues

6. Because Lucas made a "sad face" when Brooke called Peyton on her cell

7. Because Brooke cried when he was in the accident

8. Because Peyton ran away when they made out

9. Because Brooke didnt get scared

10. Because Brooke called him superstar

11. Because Brooke wanted to become friends with his friends

12. Because she wanted to connect more with him

13. Because she wanted him even when she was with Felix

14. Because he wanted her when she was with Felix

15. Because Peyton wished for Jake

16. Because the first boy Peyton told she loved was not Lucas

17. Because it wasent a goodbye kiss

18. Because Brooke took down all the pictures exept the one with her and Lucas

19. Because he painted the door black when Brooke hurted him, he didnt do anything when Peyton and him stopped hooking up

20. Because Brooke cried when he broke up with her, Peyton didnt shead a tear when he started dating Brooke

21. Because Lucas and Peytons relationship is built of off "My mum is dead and your dad hates ýou"

22. Because Lucas and Brookes relationship is built of off LOVE

23. Because they kissed in the rain

24. Because she wrote him a bunch of letters

25. Because she makes him laugh

26. Because he wants her back

27. Because she said that she will love him forever

I used to really enjoy watching peyton. She was this cool converse and tshirt kinda girl, who made a mistake and then got her friend back again and the whoal peyton lucas brooke love triangle was very exiting! but now she is just so complicated that it sucks! it started going to far when ellie died, then she got shot, then she started liking lucas and now she has a stalker! its going to far! and i dont like it one bit. she was sucha cool musicloving artistic girl but now...its just sad.
I want peyton to get her life backtogether, and leave lucas behind, become friends with brooke again (cause lets face it she needs that girl) and just become the peyton i liked.
i am a brucas fan by the way, just wanted to tell you my piece.

VOTE FOR BROOKE GUYS (L)

"well after your best friend tells you she wants your boyfriend for the second time it would seem appealing to slap them i think"
No she didn't say she wanted him.And slapping someone is immature don't you think?

when you like someone you want them, and peyton slapped nicki...immature much?

but peyton slapped nikki after she slaped her

well, a slap is a slap so its as immature to slap someone back

And if a kiss is a kiss,Brooke needs that more because she kissed Pete as well as fake Derek

pete, i explained derek she kissed to teese peyton

Yeah it is.Besides,who's Brooke to say thanks for not hitting on him.After all,she's the one to say the friendship's over between them.And that's no reason for Peyton to stop talking to Lucas.

ehm...peyton made some mistakes at the wedding that could probably have saved her friendship with brooke. I mean when she told brooke she cried, when she was at the wedding she dissed her and said stuff like "Go brooke yourself" and when she got home she cried to brooke again. confusing...first she sais she wants her as a friend, then she totally disses her, and then all of a sudden she wants to be friends with her again. whatta?!
ofcourse brooke doesent take it seriousley...i mean why should she?

Atleast Peyton fans admit where she has been wrong.You guys don't even do that!On top of it,you defend her!

we have edmitted that brooke has made mistakes but her mistakes have never been bad for her best friend.

"lucas needed space and brooke gave it to him, and peyton didnt let lucas in on season one and you still say that she loved him"
Yeahbecause before she knew Brooke was Lucas's official girlfriend,she came out clean about her feelings and she mentioned she got scared."With Arms Outstretched"Because Brooke wasn't the dating type.Hook n Loose was her thing.

but brooke told peyton that she wanted a serious boyfriend. so peyton knew

Fine,what about Abercombie then.Clearly you didn't answer that because you have no answer to that.So liking him first,when Peyton was callin him a choke,doesn't count either.Cause that didn't stop her from hitting on other guys.

brooke didnt think that she would get lucas so she tried to move on, later that night she noticed that he was interested in her, and went for it. I mean she didnt want to run after a guy who didnt even like her (unlike peyton), so she tried to give it up. but lucas started liking her...and you know the rest

"peyton NEVER dumped lucas, or what show have you been watching?"
Durk!Forget "Life As A Glass House",where Lucas and Peyton hook up and she leaves him when he talks of getting serious?What show have you been watching?

dump is breaking up with someone, and you guys sais that brooke doesent love lucas cause she dumped him, but then why did peyton dump lucas?

Tell Brooke that when she kissed Pete.

brooke knew peyton was there, and she went for it because she thaught she was dreaming, she didnt sneak around or anything

Once you say Brooke freaked cause Peyton liked Lucas and once you say she freaked because she twisted her words.Can you be more clear than use the same defence for two completely different things.Oh right,you can't come up with anything new,not to mention better.

you know what, atleast I have those two arguments, you insult my arguments but dont give any of yourown. atleast i have some, you cant even give that

Look before you twist my words.

oh sorry, i thaguth you were okay with wordtwisting since your on peytons side...my bad:P

" What are you doing then?Saying Peyton and Lucas suck together doesn't help you either. "

I never said that . Check your information before you wright . Haha LOL ,
atleast I Give rasons for brucas insetad of humilliate other fellow OTH fans . Peace Out ! :D

"at least in the first season she tried to get brooke back, now she doesent give a damn. that shows that she is a bad friend"
If she was a bad friend she wouldn't have tried the first time.

And if you've been watching carefully you'd know that the only reason why Brooke and Peyton became friends again was because Peyton stopped being even just friends with Lucas because of that whole Nikki thing.They almost made it at the cheerleading competition,but she saw Lucas talking to Peyton and there she goes again.Then it was the first pregnancy scare,and Peyton blabbered about Lucas being upset and off went Brooke again.
This time,Peyton's done nothing wrong.Why should she give it all when Brooke doesn't want it.

And if a kiss is a kiss,Brooke needs that more because she kissed Pete as well as fake Derek

"but a kiss is a kiss and you shouldent kiss your best friend boyfriend"

Tell Brooke that when she kissed Pete.

"But thats about me, not brooke, so dont use that as a comment. Peyton said the "thanks for the sex" thing to brooke. I thought the stalker thing about peyton was funny, but correct me if IM wrong but isnt this site about brooke and peyton?"

Yeah it is.Besides,who's Brooke to say thanks for not hitting on him.After all,she's the one to say the friendship's over between them.And that's no reason for Peyton to stop talking to Lucas.

"when you like someone you want them, and peyton slapped nicki...immature much?"
Well firstly,you talked bout Peyton "SAYING"she "wanted"Lucas.You should be clear about what you really meant rather than keep arguing about it over n over.And Peyton slapped Nikki after Nikki slapped her.Besides,Nikki's not Peyton's best friend of ten years.And clear me on this.Once you say Brooke freaked cause Peyton liked Lucas and once you say she freaked because she twisted her words.Can you be more clear than use the same defence for two completely different things.Oh right,you can't come up with anything new,not to mention better.

"you just edmitted that peyton is a bad friend, thanks by the way brooke cares but its up to peyton"

Yeah,Brooke cares so much that she called Peyton's mom a slut.Peyton "WAS" a bad friend cause 3 seasons ago she went behind Brooke's back.And this time she's not doing that.So I admitted nothing like that.Look before you twist my words.

"peyton NEVER dumped lucas, or what show have you been watching?"
Durk!Forget "Life As A Glass House",where Lucas and Peyton hook up and she leaves him when he talks of getting serious?What show have you been watching?

"lucas needed space and brooke gave it to him, and peyton didnt let lucas in on season one and you still say that she loved him"
Yeahbecause before she knew Brooke was Lucas's official girlfriend,she came out clean about her feelings and she mentioned she got scared."With Arms Outstretched"Because Brooke wasn't the dating type.Hook n Loose was her thing.

"brooke is not stupid she probably figured out that the doctor could give her something for the pain LOL"

Fine,what about Abercombie then.Clearly you didn't answer that because you have no answer to that.So liking him first,when Peyton was callin him a choke,doesn't count either.Cause that didn't stop her from hitting on other guys.

"Have you lost you grip leytoners , Hu ? cuz by picking on others comments instead of giving reasons for leyton doesn´t really help you leytons lovers ! "

What are you doing then?Saying Peyton and Lucas suck together doesn't help you either.

Games are getting old Team Brooke.Stop bickering and face it,Brooke's back to her old ways.You are defending her for the way she's behaving now so I'll defend Peyton now in the same way.

She has two dead moms.
Didn't like it did you?So don't use the excuse of her angry at Lucas and Peyton and that being the reason for returning to her old ways.

Atleast Peyton fans admit where she has been wrong.You guys don't even do that!On top of it,you defend her!

"if you were the girlfriend that had been betraied not only buy your friend but also buy your boyfriend then i dont think you would feel that it was "funny as hell"
look at it from brookes perspective"

Ahem and when you said fake/stalker Derek is good for Peyton that made it funny.Look at it from Peyton's perspective.

But thats about me, not brooke, so dont use that as a comment. Peyton said the "thanks for the sex" thing to brooke. I thought the stalker thing about peyton was funny, but correct me if IM wrong but isnt this site about brooke and peyton?

"well after your best friend tells you she wants your boyfriend for the second time it would seem appealing to slap them i think"
No she didn't say she wanted him.And slapping someone is immature don't you think?

when you like someone you want them, and peyton slapped nicki...immature much?

Yeah let her be.If Brooke doesn't care why should she?

you just edmitted that peyton is a bad friend, thanks by the way brooke cares but its up to peyton.

Kissing is not making out.And they haven't made out yet.And why shouldn't she make moves on him.He's not tied down to anyone is he?Like Brooke did after Peyton dumped him.

but a kiss is a kiss and you shouldent kiss your best friend boyfriend. and you shouldent hook up with her exboyfriend either. and by the way peyton NEVER dumped lucas, or what show have you been watching?

And you feel responsible only when you love someone.Why the hell does he take Brooke for granted if he loves her so much?I mean,he didn't let her in when Keith died.

lucas needed space and brooke gave it to him, and peyton didnt let lucas in on season one and you still say that she loved him

No I didn't.She hit on him before she knew he could give him something.And if you still don't think it is,what about ABERCROMBIE?She did hit on him!

brooke is not stupid she probably figured out that the doctor could give her something for the pain LOL

Have you lost you grip leytoners , Hu ? cuz by picking on others comments instead of giving reasons for leyton doesn´t really help you leytons lovers !

""Ill say it again, lucas spends all that time saving peyton because nobody else does it and because he has sucha good hart that he cant see anyone in trouble. But that is not love that is feeling risponsible for someone."

I'll add one more thing to that.Keith felt responsible for Karen.Now say he didn't love Karen!

"and brooke didnt hessitate on her love for lucas she hessitated to tell peyton about it, simply because she didnt deserve to hear it"

Then why did she not hit back at Rachel(the thing she's best at)when Rachel got it straight(now do I have to repeat what she said in the bar while celebrating Brooke's Birthday?)

"she didnt freak because peyton told her she freaked because she twisted her words just like your doing."

Ahem.Well I heard her shouting at Peyton before she twisted her words.

"When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was..."

wow.. well you can't deny chemistry like that

"she hitted on him to get medicine because of the pain she felt in her leg...did you miss it?"

No I didn't.She hit on him before she knew he could give him something.And if you still don't think it is,what about ABERCROMBIE?She did hit on him!

"Ill say it again, lucas spends all that time saving peyton because nobody else does it and because he has sucha good hart that he cant see anyone in trouble. But that is not love that is feeling risponsible for someone."

And you feel responsible only when you love someone.Why the hell does he take Brooke for granted if he loves her so much?I mean,he didn't let her in when Keith died.

"ehm that is what peyton did! and when brooke caught him she started kissing him behind brookes back...superficial much?"

And when she dumped Lucas cause she didn't miss him anymore.Superficial much?

"And she kisses him in the library, starts liking him again and when brooke brakes up with him she starts making moves on him. "
Kissing is not making out.And they haven't made out yet.And why shouldn't she make moves on him.He's not tied down to anyone is he?Like Brooke did after Peyton dumped him.

"You guys sais that Brooke has no respect for the deads but Peyton have no respect for either her best friends or for her exbestfriends. Its dissrespectfull to say "thanks for the sex" to lucas when brooke is there, at least in the first season she tried to get brooke back, now she doesent give a damn. that shows that she is a bad friend"

Yeah let her be.If Brooke doesn't care why should she?

"well after your best friend tells you she wants your boyfriend for the second time it would seem appealing to slap them i think"
No she didn't say she wanted him.And slapping someone is immature don't you think?

"if you were the girlfriend that had been betraied not only buy your friend but also buy your boyfriend then i dont think you would feel that it was "funny as hell"
look at it from brookes perspective"

Ahem and when you said fake/stalker Derek is good for Peyton that made it funny.Look at it from Peyton's perspective.

"When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was..."

Yeah well I think the same things about Brad Pitt lol.. doesnt mean theres anything going on

PEYTON AND LUCAS

suck together

and that "thanks for the sex" thing was funny as hell ..

if you were the girlfriend that had been betraied not only buy your friend but also buy your boyfriend then i dont think you would feel that it was "funny as hell"
look at it from brookes perspective

- Brooke stops missing Lucas
- Brooke hessitates when asked if she loves Lucas

did you miss the episode or did you just hear what you wanted to hear?
Brooke said that she didnt felt like she needed lucas as much anymore, that she was more independent now, and that is just a good thing, it doesent mean that she does not miss him when hes away.

and brooke didnt hessitate on her love for lucas she hessitated to tell peyton about it, simply because she didnt deserve to hear it

when Brooke found out about Peyton and Lucas in season 1, she said to Peyton
"I don't know what hurts worse you and lucas sneaking around behind my back or you lieing about it my face."
this time Peyton tells her the truth about her feelings toward Lucas and she completely flips out?

she didnt freak because peyton told her she freaked because she twisted her words just like your doing.

we have answers to whatever you bring...

well after your "best friend" slaps you .. I don't think respecting them would seem too appealing

well after your best friend tells you she wants your boyfriend for the second time it would seem appealing to slap them i think

"You guys sais that Brooke has no respect for the deads but Peyton have no respect for either her best friends or for her exbestfriends. Its dissrespectfull to say "thanks for the sex" to lucas when brooke is there, at least in the first season she tried to get brooke back, now she doesent give a damn. that shows that she is a bad friend"

well after your "best friend" slaps you .. I don't think respecting them would seem too appealing

and that "thanks for the sex" thing was funny as hell ..

Just wanted to edit this a little...

1 peyton sees lucas and gets mad because he is blocking the road

2 Peyton disses Lucas

3 Brooke sees Lucas and thinks that he is cute

4 Brooke tells Peyton how she wants a serious boyfriend

5 Peyton and Lucas become friends

6 Brooke starts dating Lucas

7 Peyton "starts to like him"

8 Lucas and Peyton go behind Brookes back

9 Brooke finds out, gets mad forgives them

10 Peyton gets together with Jake

11 Brooke starts dating Felix

12 Brooke dumps Felix because he sprayed DYKE on Peytons locker

13 Brooke and Lucas starts liking eachoter again

14 Peyton and Jake break up
no .. Jake has to leave .. they do not break up

15 Brooke and Lucas starts dating again

16 Peyton starts dating Pete

17 Brooke keeps dating Lucas

18 Peyton starts dating Jake again

19 Brooke keeps dating Lucas

- Brooke stops missing Lucas
- Brooke hessitates when asked if she loves Lucas

20 Peyton starts "liking" Lucas again and tells brooke

brooke gets mad....how in the hell is all this brookes fault?????

when Brooke found out about Peyton and Lucas in season 1, she said to Peyton
"I don't know what hurts worse you and lucas sneaking around behind my back or you lieing about it my face."
this time Peyton tells her the truth about her feelings toward Lucas and she completely flips out?

PEYTON AND LUCAS

You guys sais that Brooke has no respect for the deads but Peyton have no respect for either her best friends or for her exbestfriends. Its dissrespectfull to say "thanks for the sex" to lucas when brooke is there, at least in the first season she tried to get brooke back, now she doesent give a damn. that shows that she is a bad friend

Brooke: if Lucas and I couldent make it as a couple the last time what makes you think that we could do it this time

Peyton: Well I wouldent make out with him this time

And she kisses him in the library, starts liking him again and when brooke brakes up with him she starts making moves on him.

1 peyton sees lucas and gets mad because he is blocking the road

2 Peyton disses Lucas

3 Brooke sees Lucas and thinks that he is cute

4 Brooke tells Peyton how she wants a serious boyfriend

5 Peyton and Lucas become friends

6 Brooke starts dating Lucas

7 Peyton "starts to like him"

8 Lucas and Peyton go behind Brookes back

9 Brooke finds out, gets mad forgives them

10 Peyton gets together with Jake

11 Brooke starts dating Felix

12 Brooke dumps Felix because he sprayed DYKE on Peytons locker

13 Brooke and Lucas starts liking eachoter again

14 Peyton and Jake break up

15 Brooke and Lucas starts dating again

16 Peyton starts dating Pete

17 Brooke keeps dating Lucas

18 Peyton starts dating Jake again

19 Brooke keeps dating Lucas

20 Peyton starts "liking" Lucas again and tells brooke

brooke gets mad....how in the hell is all this brookes fault?????

Yeah how about goin after a guy who had feelings for her best friend?All these guys on Tree Hill care about themselves.So that makes them all superficial!?!!

ehm that is what peyton did! and when brooke caught him she started kissing him behind brookes back...superficial much?

"yeah ofcourse were jealous, i mean we dream of having a rapist after us every day"

I shoulda known.Like Brooke,like her lovers.Jumping onto conclusions.Obviously the person meant from "Jealous" that Leyton are getting their shot and you're burning up cause of it!

ehm...that didnt answer too what I wrote...

"look up the word superficial, its only caring about your looks and yourself, and brooke doesent do that"

Ouch!Brooke doesn't care about only herself??Yeah how about goin after a guy who had feelings for her best friend?All these guys on Tree Hill care about themselves.So that makes them all superficial!?!!

once again, wread my post from the top and see that its about brooke not the guys on tree hill and also you didnt answer me

Peyton doesn't strip or drops her jeans does she?Brooke does it and hats off to you if you think that makes a great personality.

no right, peyton just teeses them and gets into bed with them and then leaves them all turned on because "she gets scared" when it gets deep. How can you call brooke a slut when peyton leaves the sack when lucas starts talking about getting serious

"You know what , I hope peyton and lucas get a chance , but hoping for that relationship to work is like hoping for peace on earth . No offense to you leyton lovers but I just think that lucas and brooke are more of couple and I enjoy seeing them together . "

Probably that's why Lucas loves Brooke but spends all his time saving Peyton!

Ill say it again, lucas spends all that time saving peyton because nobody else does it and because he has sucha good hart that he cant see anyone in trouble. But that is not love that is feeling risponsible for someone.

"it doesent matter if brooke was attracted to lucas in the beginning because of how he looked, my point was that she liked him first."

And that didn't stop her from hitting on the medicine guy in the one where Lucas and Nate are thrown off the bus.So liking him first there doesn't count.

she hitted on him to get medicine because of the pain she felt in her leg...did you miss it?

"yeah but then you guys cant say that brooke doesent love lucas anymore just because she is with the teacher now, she is doing exactly what peyton did that is my point"

Then you guys can't say she dumped him cause of Peyton cause as much as she told Lucas she loved him,she said it wasn't about Peyton.

"it doesent matter if brooke was attracted to lucas in the beginning because of how he looked, my point was that she liked him first."

And that didn't stop her from hitting on the medicine guy in the one where Lucas and Nate are thrown off the bus.So liking him first there doesn't count.

"look up the word superficial, its only caring about your looks and yourself, and brooke doesent do that"

Ouch!Brooke doesn't care about only herself??Yeah how about goin after a guy who had feelings for her best friend?All these guys on Tree Hill care about themselves.So that makes them all superficial!?!!

"yeah ofcourse were jealous, i mean we dream of having a rapist after us every day"

I shoulda known.Like Brooke,like her lovers.Jumping onto conclusions.Obviously the person meant from "Jealous" that Leyton are getting their shot and you're burning up cause of it!

"so, that doesent defend the fact that she doesent have a life, brooke gets a guy by showing her grate personality and peyton gets a guy by sitting around trying to look cute infront of a webcam"

ROTFLMAO
Peyton doesn't strip or drops her jeans does she?Brooke does it and hats off to you if you think that makes a great personality.

"No , it´s not , see you just want something to pick on . Get a life !"

Crunch!And when someone said:
Peyton Sawyer what an ugly ass of a name,that got you a life or won you the debate.How cool.Brooke lovers are hypocrites as well!

"You know what , I hope peyton and lucas get a chance , but hoping for that relationship to work is like hoping for peace on earth . No offense to you leyton lovers but I just think that lucas and brooke are more of couple and I enjoy seeing them together . "

Probably that's why Lucas loves Brooke but spends all his time saving Peyton!

You know what , I hope peyton and lucas get a chance , but hoping for that relationship to work is like hoping for peace on earth . No offense to you leyton lovers but I just think that lucas and brooke are more of couple and I enjoy seeing them together .

Peyton and Lucas deserve their shot!!!

they had their shots and they blew it.

" Maybe you should use your spare time to read a dictionary or something...because your spelling is wicked retarded! "

No , it´s not , see you just want something to pick on . Get a life !

" atleast Alyssa uses her time online to tell people her oppinions unlike you who uses her time online talking trash about people you dont even know...now you tell me who doesent have a life. By the way Peyton spends all her time by the computer showing off her ugly face to Lucas so that makes her life empty "

And Lucas looks at her. LOL.

so, that doesent defend the fact that she doesent have a life, brooke gets a guy by showing her grate personality and peyton gets a guy by sitting around trying to look cute infront of a webcam

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

Ugh, you guys keep talking in circles about the same things...Peyton and Lucas were never given a chance to see what could become of the relationship they started, because Peyton didn't want to hurt Brooke. So she stepped away from what she wanted, because that was the kind of person she is, Brooke is a different person than Peyton is, she goes after what she wants and she usually gets it, she did with Lucas, maybe the fact that she is NOT going after Lucas now shows us all just how much she WANTS Lucas back...

that wasent an answer that was even worthy, you can not disagree that brooke liked lucas first!

I just dont understand how anybody can call Brooke superficial when Peyton is the one showing of herself to the whoal world on her stupid webcam i mean its pathetic!

How can you NOT call Brooke superficial? When most everything about her character is superficial. She has all these relationships that aren't meaningful or deep, her relationship with Felix and her relationship with the new teacher, are both superficial. They barely scratched the surface at something real, the closest thing that she had to being real was her relationship with Lucas and most of that was Lucas' doing...between Brooke and Peyton, the superficial winner is Brooke, hands down.

And why does having a web cam make you superficial? It's a peek into her life, she's not on there taking her clothes off or having wild monkey sex with anyone, it's just her life...what's so wrong and superficial about that?

look up the word superficial, its only caring about your looks and yourself, and brooke doesent do that! just because she likes clothes and to go shopping it doesent mean that she is superficial, and having wild sex doesent make you superficial it makes you (in brookes case) a sad person who misses the person who completed her (lucas).
Peyton uses her cam to show herself to the whoal world and that is more superficial...

" Alyssa you have almost comment on every thing we brucasers have said . Congratilations , How long did ít take ? all day ? Since I actually have a life I use my sparetime to other things then this .
I hate to break it to you hunny , ( who am I kidding I love it ) That OTH isn´t a reality thing it´s a show :D so you might wanna loosing up a little

Maybe you should use your spare time to read a dictionary or something...because your spelling is wicked retarded!

wow Dylan! that comment just won you guys the debate

Hey Dylan did we scare you away or did you just start to agree with us brookelovers?
please read our comments carefully and see that brooke is the only one thinking straight in this mess

Nope, I'm not scared, I've just had other issues in my REAL life to deal with then sit and wait for the moderators to approve my comments and all of yours to get back to this place...I would have continued to forget about this place but I got a comment on my blog reminding me about this blog.

oh so the real life you lead that your talking about is your blog! that sounds really intreasting

" haha right...the only one who likes peyton is a mentally disturbed freak "

HA! What a load of crap, why does wanting Lucas to have a more meaningful relationship with someone else who has the same interests as him make you a mentally disturbed freak? I think you guys are just jealous.

yeah ofcourse were jealous, i mean we dream of having a rapist after us every day...

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

Ugh, you guys keep talking in circles about the same things...Peyton and Lucas were never given a chance to see what could become of the relationship they started, because Peyton didn't want to hurt Brooke. So she stepped away from what she wanted, because that was the kind of person she is, Brooke is a different person than Peyton is, she goes after what she wants and she usually gets it, she did with Lucas, maybe the fact that she is NOT going after Lucas now shows us all just how much she WANTS Lucas back...

but dont you find it amusing how peyton started liking lucas when brooke mentioned that she was interested? my point was that brooke wanted him first

Okay, so are you Brooke fans fighting against each other? Maybe we should just step back and let ya'll go at it...us Leytoners can just point and laugh at you guys.

laugh all you want, ive done it almoast evey time i wread one of you leytoners posts

I am on Peytons side.. I mean what kind of person says someones dead mother is a whore.. Well Brooke does.. Lucas and Peyton bellong together, I mean they have that great conection from the start..

what kind of person steals her best friends boyfriend, fooles two other guys that she likes them and then starts to like her best friends boyfriend again?

She only liked him because he looked good, not at all the same kind of like that Peyton had for him. Peyton liked him as a person, Brooke just wanted to screw him....at first.

it doesent matter if brooke was attracted to lucas in the beginning because of how he looked, my point was that she liked him first.

Yeah we can. Because remember, she was hiding from her feelings for Lucas. She had no plans to reveal her feelings for Lucas and so she threw herself into her relationship with Jake, and though she does LOVE him, she's not in love with him, she's in love with Lucas.

yeah but then you guys cant say that brooke doesent love lucas anymore just because she is with the teacher now, she is doing exactly what peyton did that is my point

Peyton and Lucas deserve their shot!!!

Whoever that Annonymous person is, you're completely right...it does get a little old trying to explain the SAME thing over and over again to a bunch of adolescents who can't spell, think for themselves or come up with compelling arguments, so yeah it's no wonder all the Leytoners are leaving, this place just isn't fun anymore, it's like kicking a dead dog over and over again...what's the point?

My last thing on this whole thing is this...

Brooke is a good person, she's made some nutjob decisions but that's neither here nor there...but the truth of the matter is, Lucas would be holding her back from finding the true love of her life, I don't think Lucas is it. Chad wasn't it in real life for Sophia and Lucas isn't it in OTH for Brooke, she deserves a shot at finding the true love of her life. Just as Peyton deserves that shot with Lucas. Right or wrong, they deserve the chance to see what can blossom between the two of them.

Those that think Peyton deserves to be with the fake Derek, the Derek who beat and raped the hooker girl? That just goes to show how shallow and dimwitted people can be.

All of you guys can say what you want behind my back because I really doubt I'll be back here, it was fun while it lasted but well, regardless of who's in the right, Peyton IS winning the battle on the original poll on this blog entry anyway, so if anything else, we have THAT, Leytoners! =)

What really bothers me is that lucas spend all this time to try to get brooke back , with the help of PEYTON OMG !! He has to be incredible stupid if he think that is going to help .

Well, in Lucas' defense, he didn't ask Peyton for help to get Brooke back, she offered it. But, he is a little dense in the head if he thinks he'll actually get Brooke back by spending all that time with Peyton, but it IS commendable of him to stick with his FRIENDSHIP with Peyton instead of tossing her to the wind just so that he can be with Brooke again.

atleast Alyssa uses her time online to tell people her oppinions unlike you who uses her time online talking trash about people you dont even know...now you tell me who doesent have a life. By the way Peyton spends all her time by the computer showing off her ugly face to Lucas so that makes her life empty

You can't say that, because everyone in here is throwing insults left and right...

a little hipocritical dont ya think? since in that post you just called a whole bunch of people dumb and sad

I give what I get..but at least I know why Peyton and Lucas should be together and it's more than because Peyton rocks, which is a lot more than I can say for a lot of the Brooke fans on here. There are a handful of you Brooke fans that I think have legit reasons for wanting Brooke and Lucas to be together and I respect and applaud those of you that do, but there are more Brooke fans on here that are just retarded dumb in their reasonings.

This is no debate . but you Pucasers don´t seem to get that yet . JUst get over your selfs and stop kalling it a debate !! Morons

Then what is it smart guy?

then you guys can not say that peyton loved lucas all this time, because she was with jake and she told him she loved him

Yeah we can. Because remember, she was hiding from her feelings for Lucas. She had no plans to reveal her feelings for Lucas and so she threw herself into her relationship with Jake, and though she does LOVE him, she's not in love with him, she's in love with Lucas.

I don't think this is true because at this point, I think Brooke could not care less about Peyton's happiness. I think she broke up with Lucas because she was tired of constantly feeling threatened by Peyton and Lucas's friendship and also I don't think she really loved him as much as she used to.

I don't think she's doing it for Peyton at all, because you're right, she couldn't care less about Peyton's happiness right now, I think she's doing the whole distance thing for LUCAS and not Peyton. I also agree that I don't think she loves him anymore.

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

She only liked him because he looked good, not at all the same kind of like that Peyton had for him. Peyton liked him as a person, Brooke just wanted to screw him....at first.

" atleast Alyssa uses her time online to tell people her oppinions unlike you who uses her time online talking trash about people you dont even know...now you tell me who doesent have a life. By the way Peyton spends all her time by the computer showing off her ugly face to Lucas so that makes her life empty "

And Lucas looks at her. LOL.

"FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !! "

"wow that was a really good argument for Leyton..."

" hey buddy , that was actually an arguement for Brooke "

Yes , it was an argument for brooke , not peyton . Think before you wright please .

Okay, so are you Brooke fans fighting against each other? Maybe we should just step back and let ya'll go at it...us Leytoners can just point and laugh at you guys.

" Alyssa you have almost comment on every thing we brucasers have said . Congratilations , How long did ít take ? all day ? Since I actually have a life I use my sparetime to other things then this .
I hate to break it to you hunny , ( who am I kidding I love it ) That OTH isn´t a reality thing it´s a show :D so you might wanna loosing up a little

Maybe you should use your spare time to read a dictionary or something...because your spelling is wicked retarded!

" haha right...the only one who likes peyton is a mentally disturbed freak "

HA! What a load of crap, why does wanting Lucas to have a more meaningful relationship with someone else who has the same interests as him make you a mentally disturbed freak? I think you guys are just jealous.

I just dont understand how anybody can call Brooke superficial when Peyton is the one showing of herself to the whoal world on her stupid webcam i mean its pathetic!

How can you NOT call Brooke superficial? When most everything about her character is superficial. She has all these relationships that aren't meaningful or deep, her relationship with Felix and her relationship with the new teacher, are both superficial. They barely scratched the surface at something real, the closest thing that she had to being real was her relationship with Lucas and most of that was Lucas' doing...between Brooke and Peyton, the superficial winner is Brooke, hands down.

And why does having a web cam make you superficial? It's a peek into her life, she's not on there taking her clothes off or having wild monkey sex with anyone, it's just her life...what's so wrong and superficial about that?

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

Ugh, you guys keep talking in circles about the same things...Peyton and Lucas were never given a chance to see what could become of the relationship they started, because Peyton didn't want to hurt Brooke. So she stepped away from what she wanted, because that was the kind of person she is, Brooke is a different person than Peyton is, she goes after what she wants and she usually gets it, she did with Lucas, maybe the fact that she is NOT going after Lucas now shows us all just how much she WANTS Lucas back...

Hey Dylan did we scare you away or did you just start to agree with us brookelovers?
please read our comments carefully and see that brooke is the only one thinking straight in this mess

Nope, I'm not scared, I've just had other issues in my REAL life to deal with then sit and wait for the moderators to approve my comments and all of yours to get back to this place...I would have continued to forget about this place but I got a comment on my blog reminding me about this blog.

Yeah Dylan where are you ? I don´t see a singel post from you here anymore Haha :D LOL ! Seems like we brucasers are winning this whole thing ! :D Stop fighting it Pucasers your not going to win this !! :D

Oh my bad, sorry I have a LIFE outside of this blog.

Yeah Dylan where are you ? I don´t see a singel post from you here anymore Haha :D LOL ! Seems like we brucasers are winning this whole thing ! :D Stop fighting it Pucasers your not going to win this !! :D

I am on Peytons side.. I mean what kind of person says someones dead mother is a whore.. Well Brooke does.. Lucas and Peyton bellong together, I mean they have that great conection from the start..

Hey Dylan did we scare you away or did you just start to agree with us brookelovers?
please read our comments carefully and see that brooke is the only one thinking straight in this mess

COMON YOU GUYS! WE BRUCASERS ARE SO CLOSE:D please vote:) i want brooke to win!!!
but one more thing! Leytoners please dont get angry i dont want any trouble i ust happend to be on brookes side, i cant really see what she has done wrong...peyton is not really a good person...i dont think so atleast,
anyhow VOTEVOTEVOTE BRUCASERS! WE ARE GONNA WIN THIS THING

this comment right here makes us Brookelovers win

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

I just dont understand how anybody can call Brooke superficial when Peyton is the one showing of herself to the whoal world on her stupid webcam i mean its pathetic!

" haha right...the only one who likes peyton is a mentally disturbed freak "

Haha that one cracked me up :D It actually is true tough :P Brucas fan !

thanks;)

" wow that was a really good argument for Leyton... "

I wrote that argument for brooke ! Get it right .
I´m a brucas fan !

haha then im glad you found your path in life i totally agree:D

" haha right...the only one who likes peyton is a mentally disturbed freak "

Haha that one cracked me up :D It actually is true tough :P Brucas fan !

" Alyssa you have almost comment on every thing we brucasers have said . Congratilations , How long did ít take ? all day ? Since I actually have a life I use my sparetime to other things then this .
I hate to break it to you hunny , ( who am I kidding I love it ) That OTH isn´t a reality thing it´s a show :D so you might wanna loosing up a little .

FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !! "

Okay I´m writing this again to explain myself . Look I thought that alyssa was sidíng with peyton cuz I read a post when it did seem like that . But maybe it was someone else you wrote it . So I´m sry , But I am a BRUCAS FAN and I thought that I was supporting brooke wich I actually did , but according to some people I didn´t . Anyways some was taking it the other way around like I was supporting peyton wich I would never ever do ! :D But the truth is that I´m supporting brooke 100% :D
I just wanted to explain myself and if you leytoners would of read the post carefuly you would see that I was supporting brooke . Next time think very very carefuly before you wright , take the time you need :D Because I think your going to need it .

Brucas Fan!

"FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !! "

"wow that was a really good argument for Leyton..."

" hey buddy , that was actually an arguement for Brooke "

Yes , it was an argument for brooke , not peyton . Think before you wright please .

" atleast Alyssa uses her time online to tell people her oppinions unlike you who uses her time online talking trash about people you dont even know...now you tell me who doesent have a life. By the way Peyton spends all her time by the computer showing off her ugly face to Lucas so that makes her life empty "

OMG ! I´m a brucas fan !

" wow that was a really good argument for Leyton... "

I wrote that argument for brooke ! Get it right .
I´m a brucas fan !

hey buddy , that was actually an arguement for Brooke

oh, well keep upthe good work;)

"FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !! "

"wow that was a really good argument for Leyton..."

hey buddy , that was actually an arguement for Brooke

Brooke overeacted and Peyton is sly. Lucas is innocent as the chaos goes by. When will this triangle love be over, no one will know. But it will be nice to Leyton finally come into being. Hey you never know THAT they'll realise that they were never made for each other. Im with Lucas who is clueless and lost in this complex triangle

jag älskar brooke peyton suger ritigt hårt asså!

COMON YOU GUYS! WE BRUCASERS ARE SO CLOSE:D please vote:) i want brooke to win!!!
but one more thing! Leytoners please dont get angry i dont want any trouble i ust happend to be on brookes side, i cant really see what she has done wrong...peyton is not really a good person...i dont think so atleast,
anyhow VOTEVOTEVOTE BRUCASERS! WE ARE GONNA WIN THIS THING

WHY CANT YOU GUYS ANSWER ME THIS?

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys cant say that Brooke made a mistake by dating him because her bestfriend liked him, peyton kissed him when she knew brooke liked him

Brooke said she loves Lucus..

But I don't believe it...if you love someone, you either know it or you don't, it doesn't take more than a minute to answer someone when they ask you if you love someone, Brooke has hesitated twice, so yeah I'm not believing it.

then you guys can not say that peyton loved lucas all this time, because she was with jake and she told him she loved him

FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !!

wow that was a really good argument for Leyton...

i just think that brook needs to grow up and calm down and trust her supposidly best friend am i right or not..

You are wrong and here is why...

Peyton: Brooke you can get any guy you want and now you have lucas...so just trust him, trust ME and try trusting yourself

and then peyton made out with lucas and they almoast slept together while brooke was waiting by peytons phone to see if her father was still alive.Brooke has no reasons whatsoever to trust peyton

"have even a single person thought that maybe brooke is taking a few steps back for peyton . that she want´s to give them a chance . And maybe she´s putting peytons happiness over her own . "

I don't think this is true because at this point, I think Brooke could not care less about Peyton's happiness. I think she broke up with Lucas because she was tired of constantly feeling threatened by Peyton and Lucas's friendship and also I don't think she really loved him as much as she used to.

right, you dont think! whatabout knowing...if brooke sais that she loves lucas then we have to believe that because she has never given us any reasons why we shouldent believe her when she sais that she loves a guy because the only guy she ever loved is lucas and she has sticked to that.
peyton on the other hand said that she loved jake, but you guys keep saying that she loved lucas all along, and when she visited jake and they were getting engaged then she told him that she loved him, but she really loved lucas? how messt up is that?
i cant trust that peyton loves lucas because i dont have reasons to

brooke already seemed to be distancing herself from lucas,

oh, Lucas kisses peyton again, and goes away without calling her and she is distancing from him?

Brooke all the way

TEAM BROOKE

"have even a single person thought that maybe brooke is taking a few steps back for peyton . that she want´s to give them a chance . And maybe she´s putting peytons happiness over her own . "

I don't think this is true because at this point, I think Brooke could not care less about Peyton's happiness. I think she broke up with Lucas because she was tired of constantly feeling threatened by Peyton and Lucas's friendship and also I don't think she really loved him as much as she used to.

Im on team BROOKE for sure Peyton betrayed her friend and does not seem to be sad that she (Brooke) does not speak to her anymore !! Im desapointed in her character , for me she has to much interations in everyone life she just would have been with her true love Jake !!

And Peyton ain't pretty?Brooke doesn't have a stalker.

haha right...the only one who likes peyton is a mentally disturbed freak

PEYTON PEYTON PEYTON!!!!!!! ok first of alll brooke couldnt even say she loved lucas!!!!!

she could but peyton didnt deserve to hear it

"I'm definitely missing the old Brooke--just a little bit, but she has a heart--other than Rachel and Nikki!
Meh, whatever.
comon...is that really the best answer you have?"
Okay..hmm...you mean the old Hooker Brooke?Better?
hey, how about a good argument instead...calling her that doesent exactly help you leytoners"

You asked for something better,not an argument.

if you had a good argument then you would have said so without me asking

Alyssa you have almost comment on every thing we brucasers have said . Congratilations , How long did ít take ? all day ? Since I actually have a life I use my sparetime to other things then this .
I hate to break it to you hunny , ( who am I kidding I love it ) That OTH isn´t a reality thing it´s a show :D so you might wanna loosing up a little .

FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !!

atleast Alyssa uses her time online to tell people her oppinions unlike you who uses her time online talking trash about people you dont even know...now you tell me who doesent have a life. By the way Peyton spends all her time by the computer showing off her ugly face to Lucas so that makes her life empty

Alyssa you have almost comment on every thing we brucasers have said . Congratilations , How long did ít take ? all day ? Since I actually have a life I use my sparetime to other things then this .
I hate to break it to you hunny , ( who am I kidding I love it ) That OTH isn´t a reality thing it´s a show :D so you might wanna loosing up a little .

FYI : when you write all that crap , no one even have the nervs to read it . Haha LOL !!

What really bothers me is that lucas spend all this time to try to get brooke back , with the help of PEYTON OMG !! He has to be incredible stupid if he think that is going to help .

peyton did not steal lucas away from brooke. she told her about her feelings for him, like any good friend would, and made sure she knew that she had no intentions of going after him. brooke already seemed to be distancing herself from lucas, and she made the decision to break up with him. she still hasnt even given him an actual reason for the break up. so, GO LEYTON. its gonna happen bc they are meant to be.

I'm a huge Brucan fan, but this really is getting ridiculous. What's wrong with having sex? Yes, Brooke had sex with a few guys. Why should she be ashamed of it? It's a personal choice, don't put your own beliefs on other people. Also, Lucas has had sex with as many people as Peyton, yet no one is calling him any names. Why? That's just stupid. I'm not even going to bother arguing for Brooke and Lucas, I love them together but I understand they might not end up like that. It's a TV show, if Lucas ends up with Peyton, it really won't change my life in any way.

"I enjoyed the relationship the BRUCAS had but can we come back to the real reason y they aren't together on the show. THEY GOT DIVORCED IN REAL LIFE!!!"

ok well that is obviously not the real reason because they were divorced from the start of season 3 but still were together practically all season

Okay, I think people on this site now are just trying to show other people up because the reasons for each side are starting to get worse and worse

and the whole thing about rooting for a side because you think the girl is prettier? come on ... first of all that is absolutely no reason, and secondly because all 3 girls on this show are gorgeous.

"All of you guys keep reverting to name calling because you can't really say much of anything else...awwwww, what happened, you're not intelligent enough to come up with something clever and witty to say?
You guys are the sad ones."

a little hipocritical dont ya think? since in that post you just called a whole bunch of people dumb and sad

hey
i jsut wanted to say that i am the biggest Brucas fan but completely understand why the can't be together. I mean if my ex cheated on me and then decided to marry a girl who was basically jailbait i wouldn't want to do romantic scenes with him either. I think peyton and lucas should get there chance otherwise they will always wonder. Then peyton should dump his sorry butt because it is his fault that they are no longer friends. I don't care who the guy is hes not worth breaking up a friendship.

i just think that brook needs to grow up and calm down and trust her supposidly best friend am i right or not.. i dont know its a really really weird situation.. i dont know anyways thats my opinion been watching tree hill since day 1 and i love this show... my fav charactor would prolly have to be payton cuz i relate to her .. im quiet and independant. well thanks for reading.. OTH Fan

have even a single person thought that maybe brooke is taking a few steps back for peyton . that she want´s to give them a chance . And maybe she´s putting peytons happiness over her own .

Guys, I'm kind of sad about how mean this board has become! I mean, it's just a TV show, right? These people AREN'T REAL! And we're all fans of OTH, whether we love Peyton or Brooke, right? It's gotten to the point where I'm kind of afraid to say which side I'm on because I might get ripped apart. Anyway, I love how people are so into OTH -- it's my favorite show, hands-down, so I like finding a place to talk about it with other fans. But it'd be so great if we could all tone it down a bit and try to respect each other's opinions! Thanks for listening -- Cristina.

I totally agree:) im on team brooke by the way

im all in for BROOKE..BRUCAS forever..even though peyton just said that she loves luke..brooke wud be hurt coz he cheated on her w/ peyton above all that peyton was brooke's bff so it's really not proper..peyton should've explain everything to brooke she should've exerted effort if she really love brooke as bff..if i got a bff same as peyton, she is not worth keeping..i really really LOVE BROOKE

Brooke said she loves Lucus..

But I don't believe it...if you love someone, you either know it or you don't, it doesn't take more than a minute to answer someone when they ask you if you love someone, Brooke has hesitated twice, so yeah I'm not believing it.

then you guys can not say that peyton loved lucas all this time, because she was with jake and she told him she loved him

You guys are the sad ones.

o comon Dylan, is that really the best you can do? your losing your grip...

Well, I have always been a BRUCAS fan since Day 1. They have a certain chemistry that is beautiful that I don't think Leyton share.However I personally think this whole love triangle has been played out! To have Lucas go back and forth b/w those two is so tedious. And he doesn't help the situation by hanging with Peyton so much if he was so determined to win Brooke back! C'mon now! And I understand Brooke flippin out the way she did at Peyton considering their history. Why should Brooke even know that information if Peyton wasn't planning on doin anything about it??..Bury it and move on!..and Lucas totally went against what he told Brooke. That if he ever got a 2nd chance he would never let her go. BUT HE DID!..For Leyton to resurface now..would be a terrible mistake!

i am all for brooke and lucus to be together because they are made for each other because peyton think that she is in love with jake and i think that brooke is right about what she called her

I like both characters, but Brooke is my favorite character. Lucas and Brooke are my favorite couple on OTH...And Peyton and Jake are soooo good together and I want Jake to come back...It get old seeing Lucas back and forth...He's best with Brooke NOT PEYTON!!!

Brooke is the BEST!

Guys, I'm kind of sad about how mean this board has become! I mean, it's just a TV show, right? These people AREN'T REAL! And we're all fans of OTH, whether we love Peyton or Brooke, right? It's gotten to the point where I'm kind of afraid to say which side I'm on because I might get ripped apart. Anyway, I love how people are so into OTH -- it's my favorite show, hands-down, so I like finding a place to talk about it with other fans. But it'd be so great if we could all tone it down a bit and try to respect each other's opinions! Thanks for listening -- Cristina.

" I'll just stick to what I've always believed.Leyton that is!=D "

Yeah , you just stick to that . i hope you drive yourself nuts . :D And just remember we brucasers are defenetly not bakick down , just bring it on !!

All of you guys keep reverting to name calling because you can't really say much of anything else...awwwww, what happened, you're not intelligent enough to come up with something clever and witty to say?

You guys are the sad ones.

I'm on Brookes side.

I love Brooke and Lucas together, they just light up the screen. I think it was hard for Brooke because even though Lucas loved her he wasn't always there for her and never really let her in. Brooke has put everything into their relationship and Lucas is distant and spends a lot time with Peyton. How can she not be insecure, her boyfriend cheated on her with her best friend. They are both at fault. Brooke forgave both of them.

Peyton had her chances to tell Lucas her real feelings and she never did. I think Brooke decided to break up with him because she needs someone to be there for her and put as much into their relationship as she does.

What I don't understand is Lucas says that he loves her and wants to be with her but spends all of his time with Peyton and doesn't even try to get Brooke back or even remember her birthday. She sees them together and figures that they are a couple. So she goes off and sleeps with someone else, not that i think its right but maybe its a way for her to deal with it. Be with someone else and take her mind of them, people do it all the time.

I think Lucas has caused a lot of drama between the girls. He is at fault and so is Peyton. If he really loved her he would do whatever it takes to get her back. She isn't a good friend if she has to question Brooke to make sure that she misses him and wants to be with her own boyfriend. How would you feel if your best friend screwed things up for you and then comes back and tells you she has feelings for your boyfriend?

If Brucas were meant to be then they will be together.

Peyton: whos it gonna be?

Lucas: Brooke

i'm on Peyton's side mostly, even though I like both girls. I think Brooke could've been more careful with what she was doing..it's not that big of a deal when your bff likes your boyfriend unless she does something bad.

shure that is true, but since peyton has gone behind brookes back with lucas before then she has every right to act the way she does. and one more thing. If this was the first time peyton told brooke that she had feelings for brookes boyfriend then i dont think brooke would have made sucha big deal about it since the girl we all first saw in season one was a girl that would do anything for her best friend but since that happend before i think it made brooke the person she is today. i actually peyton and lucas need to be blamed for the way brooke is acting, they made that girl by sneeking around behind her back two years ago

You have an explanation for Brooke givin' a lecture to Rachel about the whole not lying about age part,then lying to her date herself,then hookin' up with him?
Oh wait I guess you have."She's hurt about Lucas and the WRITERS are showing her like that.She's not like that!"

actually that was exactly what i was about to say, see your already joining our side

Besides,Peyton DID NOT steal Lucas.

she stole him away from brooke in the first season, even tough she did not keep him for herself( ofcourese she didnt he was free then so suddently he wasent so atractive anymore)
and in the second season she caused the brake up

"that is exactly what brooke is doing. She broke up with lucas because she wanted to givev him and peyton a chance. and if it doesent work between them and if he comes back to her then she will know that he is the one for her."
If it doesn't work...

???

Brooke wouldn't have slept with the new teacher if she loved Lucas.IT WAS ALL JUST DRAMA!

peyton would not have slept with jake or pete if she really loved lucas it was all just drama...

257. Because you cant build a relationship off of oh, i dont have a mom and your dad hates you.
¨
that is so true, its sucha pitty relationship
brucas all the way

Besides,Peyton's love did not start from physical attraction.

well you cant exactly use that excuse because A) physical attraction is important and B) peyton knows that lucas is out of her leuge...i mean she is not exactly pretty to look at

Oh , She had many chanses . that was the most lames excuse ever !"

She and Lucas were gonna tell her together.The accident happened.Lucas broke up with Brooke.Peyton left Lucas because she couldn't lie no more to Brooke.She would tell her but Brooke found out before she had the chance to explain!See....that ain't so lame!

how about telling her when brooke asked her. instead of saying something so lame as "brooke Im cool with you and Lucas" with her rispy voice

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys can chuck that reason off!"

"Brooke didnt steal lucas okay. you can not steal something that doesent belong to somebody and he didnt belong to peyton back then"

His heart did.

well considering that he made out with brooke it was probably hard for her to realize that his heart belonged to someone else...

Are there no leyton fans out here , all I see is Dylan?s comments . Dylan you must be here all day to try to support peyton . Haha . Good Luck with that .

Peace Out !

You Dylan have got to chill out . Read a book or something , Haha . you seem like a really sad person .
And by the way your comments do not speak very highly for leyton . !

Peace Out !

have even a single person thought that maybe brooke is taking a few steps back for peyton . She maybe want to give them a chance .

"THANK YOU FOR THAT! LUCAS SLEPT WITH NIKKI BECAUSE HE NEVER REALLY CARED ABOUT PEYTON IT WAS ALL JUST DRAMA...he would not have slept with nikki if he loved her"
Ah...Brooke's love is also drama then...she hooked up with the new teacher.

Peyton Sawyer!!

is a ugly ass name

You know what Dylan , take your stupid comments and shuv them up in your ass , that?s where they really belong .
Just get a life for Gods sakes !! You seem like a very very sad person .

I enjoyed the relationship the BRUCAS had but can we come back to the real reason y they aren't together on the show. THEY GOT DIVORCED IN REAL LIFE!!!

im so sorry to have to brake this to you hunny...but one tree hill isnt real, its just acting so their personallifes dosent have much to do with it, and by the way...santa claus isnt real either

"right, and if she gets together with Lucas now you will probably say that she did not steal him since him and brooke are not together now."

Right.Because Brooke hooked up with the new teacher.NOW!And Peyton's waited and waited!

ehmmm....that wasent even an answer to my whoal postnow was it? read it again please

Peyton should be with DEREK (the stalker, he is good enough for her)

HAHA your funny;)

"peyton didnt dident cry at all all of the times lucas rejected her"
And when did Lucas reject her??

when he was dating brooke, i mean dating another girl kind of shows that your not interested anymore, so when she came to his room and saw brooke she was rejected.also when he told her that he loves brooke after the kiss in the library...i didnt se one single tear

"I'm definitely missing the old Brooke--just a little bit, but she has a heart--other than Rachel and Nikki!

Meh, whatever.

comon...is that really the best answer you have?"

Okay..hmm...you mean the old Hooker Brooke?Better?

hey, how about a good argument instead...calling her that doesent exactly help you leytoners

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys can chuck that reason off!"

She smiled between the conversation they had when he got the tow truck

HAHA she smiled at Keith to, are you gonna say that she was inlove with him to?

"then sleeping with chris doesent make brooke a slut because she wasent with lucas at the time"

So don't say she loved him.

fine then peyton didnt love him either when she slept with jake and pete

i am on brookes side. i think peyton should have kept her feelings to herself. and waited to see if brooke and lucas lasted. i love lucas and brooke together but i think she deserves better. someone that will rescue her like lucas is always doing for peyton.

Peyton's a little backstabbing wh**e who doesnt care whos feelings she hurts on the way to getting what she wants. Then, when she gets it she doesnt want it anymore and does the same thing when she thinks she wants something else. i hope brooke doesnt forgive her.

S1 comment...........

brooke and peyton talk about lucas.....

BrOoKe: P. sawyer do u like him???

PeYtOn: no i have a boyfriend named nathan. remember???

then they talk bout how brooke wants a serious relatioship....

um so how is brooke stealin lucas?? cuz i juss dont get how that works............

brooke said it herself when she was breaking up with lucas "this is not about her, i thought it was but it wasnt. its ABOUT ME." brooke DUMPED lucas, brooke DUMPED peyton. its brookes fault. peyton said she would bury her feelings, not like she told lucas OR even has told him yet! brooke on the other hand has already slept with another guy, so if she was so in love with lucas... how did she already sleep with another guy? if you really think lucas didnt love peyton back in season one because he slept with nikki, you must not think brooke really loved lucas, right? if not, then your acting like a hypocrite.

peyton will never change her mind once she has lucas, lucas is the guy for her. she wanted jake b/c she couldnt have lucas, which has been shown MANY times is what her heart has truely wanted all along. she loves lucas more than anybody, end of story.

oK so i just think that Sophia and Chad should just get over themselves and stay together in the show. They are like the main reason i watch the show. also did you know you can trace everything that has gone wrong this school year back to the Rachel slut like Keiths death, Jimmy Edwards death, she wrecked Haley and Nathan's wedding it was because the whole time capsul thing she caused that made Lucas realize he can't play basketball that he loves and the whole time capsul commotion is what drove lucas and brooke apart there you have it Rachel just needs to mind her own flippin buisness

brooke is being stupid. she broke up with lucas anyway so why let a 10 year friendship go for a guy who she didn't even keep. just because peyton has these feelings doesn't mean anything will come of it.and even if it did brooke doesn't want him anymore.

immm all for brooke! she rocks..

brooke's side forever

i think that Lucas should be with Brooke.i read somewhere that lucas and peyton will rebulid their relationship.how is that possible?he told Peyton"You can't help who you love" and by that he meant about Brooke.it's not fer.i want brucas back together.they are so cute together.and peyton should just forget about Lucas if she want's her best friend back

personally, i want brooke and lucas to get back together because brooke makes lucas fun.. and anyways.. i dont think peyton should really be getting involved in a relationship now that she almost got rapped and has a new brother.. and i just dont think peyton and lucas look cute together.. I WANT JAKKKEE TO COME BACK!!

I REALLY THINK PEYTON HAS A PROBLEME!IN SAISON 3 SHE DID LOVE JAKE!then she was with the guy of fall out boy then she proposed to jack and 1 episode after she loved lucas!!!!A BIG PROBLEME HERE?????
you will see the productors know how many people love brucas(you can see all the websites there are about brucas much more than leyton)and at the end they will come back together!! so don't fight about that!!!!

Brooke and Lucas definetely!
I find it really funny how people have enough time to critique ALL the comments posted here. Fine 3 or 4, understandable...but every single Brooke and Lucas post, wow... someone has NO LIFE. Don't you have a job or school work or...anything better to do with your time. Since I actually have a life, this will be the 1 and only post I write. If anyone chooses to disect it with a fine tooth comb, go ahead. However, please note that I will not defend my comments just because, I don't have to :) I know that this is a fictional "SHOW", not reality TV. My oppinion is just that, OPPINION. It will not change any of the real life situations going on in our world today. So therefore, I will only write this one post and dedicate the rest of my spare time to doing something more productive.
So here goes.
My reasons why Brooke and Lucas should be together and why Peyton and Lucas should not.
BROOKE and LUCAS light up the screen. They make the show interesting, fun, romantic & sweet. They make you smile when your watching. And really that's all that's important. The purpose of a TV show should be to entertain. They are entertaining. Peyton and Lucas are NOT.
PEYTON and LUCAS are totally BORING!!! I fall asleep when they are on screen together. Their characters are two of the most boring on TV right now. Pairing them up only enhances that fact.
I know Lucas is boring, but at least Brooke livens him up a little. If Peyton and Lucas hook up, all we have to look forward to is watching them write, read & draw, while listening to some sad songs in Peyton's room. How exciting!
I've watched this show for a while and the only reason for Brooke and Lucas to be together is because with them apart, the show sucks. Unless, they stop showing Lucas and Peyton all together. Then that might actually be worth watching. BUT... if they have to be on the show, then they should be apart, beacause watching them together only makes me want to snore.

PEYTON PEYTON PEYTON!!!!!!! ok first of alll brooke couldnt even say she loved lucas!!!!! cause peyotn said she would bak off if she just said her, but brooke didnt!!!! so i dont care but I LOVE PEYTON na dbrooke is getting on my nerves!!!! but i like brooke too!

i'm on Peyton's side mostly, even though I like both girls. I think Brooke could've been more careful with what she was doing..it's not that big of a deal when your bff likes your boyfriend unless she does something bad.

Peyton - "i didn't wish for this alright. i wished for jake"
Brooke - "oh right you wished for jake; after you wished for pete, and THEN lucas"

How do we know when Peyton gets Luke, she wont just change her mind again?

Brook Brook she i really dont like peyton right now she messes every up for lucus and brook who are soppose to be together

I'm with Peyton. Brooke is too self-centered and always whining about something. Yes, she did have her heart broken, but she always finds a way to rub it in everyone's face and make them feel bad for her. Peyton was honest from the begining, she even stood aside when Brooke was dating Lucas. Then she found Jake and forgot about Lucas. Brooke acts she was there with Peyton and Lucas in the library during the school shooting. She wasn't there! Peyton has enough to worry about with some psyco after her, she doesn't need Brooke's pettieness.

"he said a lot of time he is the guy for her!!"
Season 4 episode 3=)Remind me what he said.

"Brooke didnt steal lucas okay. you can not steal something that doesent belong to somebody and he didnt belong to peyton back then"
His heart did.

"peyton didnt dident cry at all all of the times lucas rejected her"
And when did Lucas reject her??

"i hope Mark know what is the best for the show, and put brooke and lucas together again"
I hope he puts Lucas n Peyton back for good!

"right, and if she gets together with Lucas now you will probably say that she did not steal him since him and brooke are not together now."
Right.Because Brooke hooked up with the new teacher.NOW!And Peyton's waited and waited!

"if that is a dumbreason then why are you guys alowed to use the argument"because their haircolors doesent match" against lucas?"
Because in the first 170 reasons for...ugh..Brucas,It said their Haircolors match!I was correcting that!

"I'm definitely missing the old Brooke--just a little bit, but she has a heart--other than Rachel and Nikki!

Meh, whatever.

comon...is that really the best answer you have?"

Okay..hmm...you mean the old Hooker Brooke?Better?

"then sleeping with chris doesent make brooke a slut because she wasent with lucas at the time"
So don't say she loved him.

"actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys can chuck that reason off!"
She smiled between the conversation they had when he got the tow truck.That was before Brooke called him all that.Besides,Peyton's love did not start from physical attraction.Bring more on!

"PEYTON: So she was just some stranger in a bar you slept with? Lucas, you don’t need to apologize. Okay? It’s just that, after all the stuff that you and I had been through, where my head and my heart were at I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger."

THANK YOU FOR THAT! LUCAS SLEPT WITH NIKKI BECAUSE HE NEVER REALLY CARED ABOUT PEYTON IT WAS ALL JUST DRAMA...he would not have slept with nikki if he loved her

In return,Brooke slaps her best friend of 10 yrs for her boyfriend of...duh 1 or 2 yrs!

Peyton steals her best friend for 10 years boyfriend...i think that is worse

Peyton just didn't respect Brooke enough, I mean she is her best friend, Brooke forgave her easily the first time but that was stupid. It's all about the betrayl of trust, thats what got me. How is Brooke supposed to feel when Peyton and Lucas are around each other. Is she supposed to drive herself nuts thinking that they are gunna cheat on her everytime they are together, or that Lucas will see Peyton in a different light? It is not fair to Brooke, I understand why she broke up with Lucas even though it may not be what she wanted. I hope that Brooke finds someone much better than both Peyton and Lucas, because they both do not deserve her! Peyton should be with DEREK (the stalker, he is good enough for her)

actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that brooke liked him so you guys can chuck that reason off!
bring it on

Can we say "Die Hard Fans" here. I am for Peyton all the way. I mean let the story ride, that's why we watch the show. Truth be told, for whatever the reason, LEYTON never got the chance to embrace whatever potential they had. Be it that she was messed up in the head the first season or the relationship that evolved between Brooke and Lucas. I enjoyed the relationship the BRUCAS had but can we come back to the real reason y they aren't together on the show. THEY GOT DIVORCED IN REAL LIFE!!! Which I know shouldn't make a difference, but hello, it does.

At some point or another they all played the bad guy in this love triangle. I never thought Nathan and Lucas would get along and look at them now. Tears are going to be shed and feelings are going to be hurt but HOPEFULLY the friendship will persevere. That is what I ROOT FOR!

"Oh , She had many chanses . that was the most lames excuse ever !"
She and Lucas were gonna tell her together.The accident happened.Lucas broke up with Brooke.Peyton left Lucas because she couldn't lie no more to Brooke.She would tell her but Brooke found out before she had the chance to explain!See....that ain't so lame!

"Yes , in fact I Do and you know what they suck !!"
Well,get something for your myopic eyes and then lets get real and go beyond being mean as a Brooke fan said once.
Admit it.We're making sense and you're just denying it.And after last night's episode,where Brooke hooks up with this teacher after givin' a sermon to Rachel about lying about her age thing and not telling the truth herself,I guess I'll just stick to what I've always believed.Leyton that is!=D

BROOKE BROOKE BROOKE I CANT STAND PEYTON!!!!!!!!!!!

" it wasn't like Peyton had NEVER planned to tell Brooke, she just never got the chance. "

Oh , She had many chanses . that was the most lames excuse ever !

" Hmm...do you even read our posts?
"

Yes , in fact I Do and you know what they suck !!

Brookelover !

" Hmm...do you even read our posts?
"

Yes , in fact I Do and you know what they suck !!

Brookelover !

Peyton Sawyer!!

I love brooke , but I hate that the writers are showing of all her bad sides all the time . We all know Brooke is a good person and have a big heart . she´s an incrediple girl . I just hope the writers know that and that they stop making her so cruel .

If Lucas and Peyton end the show together, i will hate for the last of my life. I the time that i spend watching.. man.. leyton is the most terrible couple ever!!!! lucas belong to brooke, and that's what a i want to see. this season four, was terrible.. the season 3 was perfect, but this one.. afffff!!! i hope Mark know what is the best for the show, and put brooke and lucas together again.

Here is what I think, they both need to get away from Lucas. I never thought he was good enough for Brooke and although I never liked Peyton from when her and Lucas went behind Brooke's back, I don't think he is good enough for her either. I know the town is small but geez, you mean to tell me they can't find some other guys to like!! Lucas isn't all that you know. This is way too soaperish for me, remind me of Bold and Beautiful where Brooke goes through every guy on the show, even her daughter's husband. I am surprised she haven't gone after her son. Brooke needs a nice guy who will treat her right and Peyton needs another one. Lucas needs to be alone cause he bores me, always had.

brooke!team brucas!!!
i'm sure in saison 4 lucas and peyton will be together but at the end of the show he will come back with brooke!!!
their love is very true and deep...
he said a lot of time he is the guy for her!!

lucas is the guy for brooke,like pacey for joey(dawson),like seth for summer(oc)!!even with a lot of difficulties in their relationship they will come back together!!
so team brOOOOOOKKKKKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

brooke cried when she and lucas broke up, peyton didnt dident cry at all all of the times lucas rejected her...who really loves him?

You would've been pissed if your best friend told you that she had feelings for your boyfriend? Well, imagine how Peyton felt when she came to bare her feelings for Lucas and saw HER BEST FRIEND in bed with the guy she liked. Imagine that.

but Lucas wasent peytons boyfriend

Ever heard the expresion
"they say if you love something let it go, and if it comes back its yours thats how you know"???
that is exactly what brooke is doing. She broke up with lucas because she wanted to givev him and peyton a chance. and if it doesent work between them and if he comes back to her then she will know that he is the one for her.

You guys keep going on and on about how brooke and lucas relationship cant work because she doesent trust him. Imean she doesent exactly have reasons to trust him, he got together with her, told her he "loved her to" on the phone the very same day as he took peytons clothes off, and he broke up with her to be with her best friend. Then he tried to make her jelaouse by beeing with rachel...brooke can not be blamed for not trusting lucas...it doesent mean that she does not love him

we don´t get to see who peyton sleeps with beacuse she´s a slut undercover !

Or maybe she didn't sleep with anyone else and she's not a slut at all, but even if she did, she was entitled because she wasn't tied down to anyone...

then sleeping with chris doesent make brooke a slut because she wasent with lucas at the time

Tsk tsk tsk.Now I'll show you what twisting of words mean.

"If she hadn't stole him,then she seduced him.Get a tattoo and drop your pants before a guy!I don't mean that in an offensive way.Just that Lucas didn't fall for Brooke before he kissed her.He was drunk and need I say more to that.Brooke did steal Lucas!
You said it yourself, she seduced him she did not steal him. And there is nothing wrong with seducing a guy who isnt dating anyone"

You just agreed Brooke's a whore.Soz,but I ain't taking back what I'm sayin'.This my dear friend,is twisting of words.

a whore gets payed for sex, incase you did not know that. watch pretty woman and learn something. what are you five? people who uses words that they dont know the meaning off are way to immature to discuss this matter.

210. Because Haley knew it was wrong of Lucas to be with Peyton... and Haley knows EVERYTHING!

haha! that one cracks me up;) go brooke:D

If she hadn't stole him,then she seduced him.Get a tattoo and drop your pants before a guy!I don't mean that in an offensive way.Just that Lucas didn't fall for Brooke before he kissed her.He was drunk and need I say more to that.Brooke did steal Lucas!

You said it yourself, she seduced him she did not steal him. And there is nothing wrong with seducing a guy who isnt dating anyone

That would be true if your best friend didn't like him.

actually Brooke liked him before Peyton. When Peyton was calling him a choke Brooke was saying how good he looked from behind and how cute he was, and how she wanted a seríous boyfriend so when Brooke challanged peyton to kiss Lucas at the party peyton knew that