The CW Source

people, why fight about brooke and peyton? ok, they all have their bitchy and backstabbing moments but what about Lucas? seems that everyone is forgetting him! he is not all innocent and pure in the story, it is up to him to make a finale decision and stop going back and forth between the two friends. he is the one who brought confusion because he can't make up his mind, i mean, common! i don't know about you but if he is to blame too for the problems, he is not a mindless person to be torn in so many directions

I don't really have an BIG issue that Peyton was mad because it kind of shifted it and made way for them to make up . Because I don't care who's side you're on in the fight but you can't say you didn't love it when they were friends....well you can but in my opinion they were and are GREAT! I loved how close they were and this kind of makes way for that to happen again and through the next few episodes it did.....although I actually liked that Haley was mad at Nathan....because they quickly made up and it wasn't a big deal because it was ALL hormones! Therefore, we got to see a LOT of crazy hormonal Haley scenes and they made me LAUGH SO MUCH!!!

I cant wait to see if Peyton kicks Dereks butt like her brother taught her to! This whole thing about Nathan & Brooke is odd considering in a season one episdode, jokingly, nathan says 'why did we never hook up' to brooke...i believe it was the episode where she hooks him and hailey up on a date to reconcile things she screwed up. The writers must have thought everyone wouldnt remember that.

Hello who says brooke should be with lucas come on brooked is such a slut and from season 1 she knew peynton liked lucas but she ignored it and went out with him and from season 1 brooke has always got what she wanted come on she needs to STOP being so selfish i dont how lucas could fall for her all the time. To the bottom line brooke deserves what she getting she was always acted like the selfish, needy little slut. SO WHY CAN'T PEYNTON EVER BE HAPPY IT ALWAYS HAS TO BE BROOK.

AHHHHHHHHHHH! YOU DRIVE ME CRAZY WATCH THE SHOW SO I DONT HAVE TO REPEAT MYSELF ALL THE TIME! brooke asked peyton three times if it was okay that she wanted lucas and peyton said yes. and from the first moment brooke layed eyes on him she liked him and at that point peyton still hated him SO DONT SAY THAT PEYTON LIKED HIM FIRST BROOKE DID! HE might have liked peyton but she didnt like him. so going out with a boy who your best friends does not like is okay. and brooke was a slut yes, BEFORE LUCAS and she isnt one anymore. peyton isnt miss perfect herself she stole lucas twice! and oh heres a list of things brooke wanted that she didnt get:
Lucas in season one
Lucas in season two
Her parents to stay home
Chase in season four
and then theres ofcourse the stuff she got that she didnt want like a sluty lying best friend, and a cheading boyfriend. and dont call brooke a whore or slut for sleeping with nathan cause he and peyton were BROKEN UP! IT DOESENT MATTER THAT THEY BROKE UP ALL THE TIME THEY WERE STILL BROKEN UP! i recall brooke dating lucas all the times peyton kissed him.

brooke has always got what she wanted come on she needs to STOP being so selfish

Omg , You can´t possibly be saying that ? Everything is being about peyton right now , I mean please . The world doesn´t evolve around peyton .

OMG I LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE BROOKEEEEEEEEE DAVISSSSSSS...SHE ISMY FAVORITE CHACTER AND SHE WILL ALWAYS BEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!=)

Hello who says brooke should be with lucas come on brooked is such a slut and from season 1 she knew peynton liked lucas but she ignored it and went out with him and from season 1 brooke has always got what she wanted come on she needs to STOP being so selfish i dont how lucas could fall for her all the time. To the bottom line brooke deserves what she getting she was always acted like the selfish, needy little slut. SO WHY CAN'T PEYNTON EVER BE HAPPY IT ALWAYS HAS TO BE BROOK.

Does anybody know when OTH is coming back??? I thought it was supposed to be the 28th, but apparently not until April???

OK! enough is enough. brooke is not a slut and peyton is just looking for reasons to turn everything around on brooke. First of all peyton and nathan were broken up and brooke was drunk. if you ask me brooke would not have done it if she wasn't drunk. she, unlike peyton, knows that her friendship is worth way more than some stupid hookup. Mark you seriosly need to make peyton stop being such a prude.Honestly i liked peyton in the first 3 seasons, but now she has become a bitter person. shge needs to stop being so rude to brooke, especially when she did something way, way, way worse. ooooooooooommmmmmmmmmmmmmggggggggggggggg I LOVE NALEY. they are the cutest couple, and that baby will be pretty hot if you ask me.PLEASE, mark dont let anything happen to my favorite couple, i wouldn't watch the show if they weren't on it. Ok thats a lie I LOVE ONE TREE HILL!

PSYCO DERECK IS HOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! EVEN THOUFGH HES RELE MEAN TO MII FAVORITE CHARACTER WHITS IS PEYTON!!

Peyton may have a right to be angry but she should not of punched her when what Peyton did to Brooke was alot worse. Nathan and Peyton had split up when Brooke slept with him and Peyton had no feelings for Nathan where as Brooke and Lucas were together when Peyton cheated with Lucas and Brooke was falling in love with Lucas and Peyton knew that.

omg....i think mouth should be with brooke even though i liked her better with lucas. If u think about it peyton is better with lucas because he liked her since eposide1 and + lucas is always saving peyton.also i love naley together. and i love ONE TREE HILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IM GONNA HAVE A HEART ATTACK, ONE TREE HILL NEEDS to come back on now, i cant wait till the 28th!!!! god this sucks...oh and brooke and lucas belong together, not peyton, peyton stole him...payton and jake were good.

I love One Tree Hill but I really really want Lucas to stay with Brooke and Jake should absolutely be with Peyton and of course we all want Haley and Nathan together. The show hasn't been on for a couple of weeks what is going on. I miss my One Tree Hill

Ok.. I totally think that Peyton is a HUGE hippocrite for getting mad at Brooke. First of all, Brooke didn't get with Nathan while Peyton was with him - unlike Peyton who continued to see Lucas while he was with Brooke, and even after they split up and Brooke was devestated, Peyton still ran around with Lucas.. and then doesn't even have the decency to tell her supposed best friend what was going on - she had to find out by seeing them together. So as for Peyton hitting Brooke - Peyton needs to just grow up and realise she's been a whole lot worse of a friend to Brooke than the other way around...and the writers really need to stop p***ing people off by making this whole Lucas-Peyton thing the centre of the show. I much preferred it when Brooke and Lucas were together, because Peyton just irritates me to the bone and I'm so sick of everything being about her... Brooke is soooo much better! What ever happened to Lucas loving Pretty Girl? They've been throgugh too much to see him end up with a selfish cow like Peyton.

I dont think that every should hate brooke for what happen and nathan and Haley should stay 2gether, they r having a baby, n i belive he is not like his father, but dan should stay away for karen =, i hope krane dont fall for him...

i think brooke and lucas should be 2gether

I LOVE NATHAN AND HALEY TOGETHER. PPPPPLLLLLLLEEEEAAAAAASSSSSSEEEEEE mark don't let anything happen to them. Rachel can not just leave. she's the only one that makes this show really interesting. OMG everyone should just forget about the tape, it was in the past when everyone was bad. Nathan is a better person with haley.I LOVE ONE TREE HILL

I love the show One Tree Hill to death! I think in the episode Mouth should be the most upset. He lost the tree things that really ment something to him. I mean the whole sex tape thing was a huge shocker, but i think Brooke should get what she deserves. She always through back in Peyton's face that she cheated with Lucas, but she could not own up to what she did with Nathan. Brooke is just as bad as Peyton in this situation. Plus Nathan was not the best person back then, and Brooke has always been kind of a slut... and we all know that.If Peyton and Brooke are not friends for a while i understand.
Also, i really like chase, but i dont like him with brooke. I loved when she was with Lucas. And i like Peyton with JAKE! (oh, dont we all miss jake!) I just LOVE Nathan and Haley together, they have somethimg that is so real and amazing. Please Mark.... dont let anything happen to NALEY!

Peyton said to nathan that he could go and slep with whoever he wanted so he did. she should NOT say things she doesent mean.

OMG , Brooke and nathan are hot together !

omg! i so knew that when they made it look like lucas was going to take his keys off his dresser to go pick up peyton that it wasnt him! i could tell by his fingers! immediately i was like..OMGGG DERRICK! and completely flipped out. so it wasnt a total shocker. but i love the show, and i love peyton and lucas together, hopefully derrick doesnt like kill her. and i also love nathan and haley, they're amazing.

wow the derek thing supprised me.. i love brooke and nathan together i think thye should go out. lucas and payton are so annoying together and hailey is just there i hope she goes with lik chris keller or something. but i love the showw

HOLY CRAPPP! can anyone seriously freaking believe that derek came back! like holy freaking crap! oh my gosh! i was shaking so hard. and i can't believe that we HAVE to wait two weeks for another eposode b/c of Americas next top model. =[

I want to know where Peyton got her dress from...she looked so nice.

OMG,I cannot believe this episode! I really think Haley should be mad but not too much. I know Nathan didn't even know her then, but for her to find out like the way she did, i'd be a little mad too.I really think Mark is going overboard with Peyton.He is just trying to make everyone feel sorry for her.Don't get me wrong, Peyton is awesome!Brooke should get a little credit, She was totally drunk that night, she had no idea what was going on.And why won't Derek leave??? Hasn't he caused Peyton enough trouble?!Brooke should not be called a slut, because Peyton did it to her twice and Lucas and Brooke were still together.Here is what I think couple wise
Lucas=Peyton
Brooke=Mouth
Nathan=Haley
Bev=Skills
Rachal=Chase
But that is just my opinion!

well i thought this episode was good first of all. many things went wrong so lets see if things turn out good the next episode.. and i hope that guy is gone for good the next episode.

I really dont think they should make me have to wait til next week to find out what happens to Peyton..lol..Come on can't we get a OTH show a night....just thought i would share my take on it..hagn

O, my god! Derek comes back. Peyton turns around and thinks its Lucas good thing she's taking boxing lessons!

OK, i liked the episode. but the end, when that guy came back. Peyton looked so pretty and he just ruined her prom by showing up. I can't wait for next episode

yoo last weeks episode wus good i used to think rachel wuss sooo stupid but now i like what she did for brooke =] and girl fight between her and PEYTON!!! but i love peyton shes actually my favorite characterr besides lucas =]

ok so i love the episode. and it really made me like rachel more. but sorry if no one knew...rachel's leaving the show for a while. she's going off to shoot for Harold and Kumar go to White Castle 2.

so this is just a story line for her to leave on a good note.

I think Peyton has every right to be mad at Brooke becuase Nathan cheated on her with Brooke while they were going out.
But that was the old Brooke and Nathan. They have totally grown and changed over the years. They are both really good characters.
Haley has no reason to be mad at Brooke because that was in the past. And the only reason she would have to be mad at Nathan would be that he didn't tell her.
But like I said that was the old Nathan. We all know he was a jerk before but he has totally grown up. But I cant wait to see whats gonna happen.

I think that both Haley and Peyton have every right to be mad! Nathan's a jerk, how could he cheat on Peyton, with her best friend(Use to-be best friend). Anyway, I feel bad for poor Mouth, he deserves to be happy for once. Beven is so dumb,but she's still one of my favorite characters, and Skillz rox! Tonight's episode is going ot be awesome, I hope there's another fight, like the one between Rachel and Haley, that was awesome! Yet Rachel isn't that bad, she's kind of cool. That's all I have to say, peace out!

hmm...i thought it was weird though as soon as peyton heard sex tape she jumped uppp and ran downstairs...i mean if shes a virgin then she should have nothing to worry about..

You know, I'm really, really tired of the Brooke is a slut storylines. Seriously. It's old. Stop making her seem like a flake. The sex tape and plotline is just another way to degrade a character who deserves more. Way to go, only not. And if anyone's mad, they're fools. Everyone hooks up in that circle, and if none of them were attached, well, really who are they to say anything. The only one who doesn't sleep around is Haley. No one else is exactly discriminating, and Rachel rocks for helping Brooke. I couldn't help but feel sorry for her after seeing all those boxes of high schools she's been to. Rachel and Brooke are both shafted pretty frequently. It's a shame, too. They're more than boy-crazy girls. Too bad the writers can't see the jewels they have.

Personally I don't really care about the whole Nathan/Brooke thing, because it happened so long ago. It would be stupid for anyone to be mad. But if anyone is it should be Peyton because she was with Nathan then. But it says that they were broken up at the time. I also think it would be really stupid for Haley to be mad. Anyway, it was a good episode and the next one looks good too. All I can say is keep em coming!

i think brokke is the greatest and the prettyiest and she should get back with lucas.... i think there cute together

I dont´get why haley is mad , I mean ok it might be a bit hummiliating to see yourhusband like that but still . They didn´t even know eachother back then , Brooke and haley didn´t know eachother either . So what´s the deal i just dont´get it . And as for peyton punching and attacking her is just so lame . What the hell peyton went behind brookes back with lucas and kisseed him in season 3 , But still brooke didn´t punch peyton or anything . But she slapped her once and that was about the kiss and because peyton twisted brookes words . And as you see in the promo peyton even starts to fight with brooke . So lame .

Another thing I just noticed after watching it twice is that... Nathan still had his nipple piercing... therefore, it happened before Haley...

Come on guys! We all know that the sex time was way before Nathan and Haley and probably after Peyton and Nathan. Although, I'm a bit effy about the whole Brooke and Nathan scene towards the end when they were outside playing in the sprinklers... that to me is being more than just friends... almost like Nathan had a crush on Brooke, but who knows... I'm not really concerned about that part. As far as the whole Rachel ordeal with the boxes labeled a different high school... I'm thinking it's because she's having a hard time fitting in, therefore she transfers to different school... again, who knows. I guess we'll have to wait and find out. I really like Peyton and Lucas as a couple... their chemistry is perfect!

I just loved this episode.
I know that Peyton it's mad at Brooke and Brooke cheated on Peyton first, but Brooke forgave Peyton the first time.
And Peyton did it to Brooke 2 and that's wack.
I love Brooke, she's a good actress, and I really hope Lucas breaks up with Peyton and get back togheter with Brooke... PeaCe

back in series 2 after naley got married brooke ripped nathan's towel. Peyton said so much better if you havent seen before and then they all had. Brooke looks like a joke now and its as if they want us to hate her instead of peyton
poor mouth.
i think erica will be on nathan's list and was the one who got her pregnant.

It´s still not the same , peyton went behind brookes back with lucas . And then she kissed him . And there was even no feelings involved between N/B , like there was between L/P , plus both nathan and brooke were drunk unlike peyton and lucas . And it sais in the spoilers that N/P had just broken up when N/B slept together , So they weren´t a couple at the time , Know it doesn´t help much :/ But as I was saying it´s still not the same it was a one time thing , But the peyton and lucas thing went on for a while . It was a little too much when peyton PUNCHED brooke , i think .

wow... good episode but i am freaking sick of this leyton business. i love brooke and i hate peyton so i really dont care what brooke does to peyton. Peyton has no right because she isnt with nathan anymore. by the way...BRATHAN was so hott. to bad they cant be together. these leyton scenes are gross and not necessary. ok peyton is the whore...she wont do it at lucas' where they are ALONE but she will do it at a party where there are tons of people. yea people should rethink liking peyton because she is the whore. i hope brooke beats the s**t out of peyton. lucas looks retarded with that hair cut too. i feel really bad for rachel and chase and haley because they were caught in the cross fire. i do not feel bad for payton or lucas. mark needs to seriously break leyton up. i mean whats up with lucas suddenly "loving" peyton after him obsessing about brooke for 2 years. yea thats crap. and dont even get me started about how peyton thinks she is the greatest friend. i support Brooke all the way.

omg i loved the episode
so good... felt soo bad for mouth
i officially love rachel that was really sweet of her
omg peytons gonns kill brooke cuz brooke was pissed at peyton and she never slept with lucus...(she still hasnt) omg but like still hayley cant be mad its not his fault she knew he was a man whore but w.e
omg love one tree hill
and i love james lafferty
<333

what was with the end when rachel had like all of these boxes with different high schools???? anyone know?

Nathan and Brooke didnt cheat...I think it was when Peyt and Nathan were broken up for the thousandth time...didn't y'all ever think of that?

I knew about the sex tape since the beginning of the season cuz of my addiction to spoilers. Anyways...the Pucas scenes were D-i-s-g-u-s-t-i-n-g...with a capital D!!! Mark is propping up Peyton once again...big surprise there...but what she did is still waaay worse than what Brooke did...the only way Peyton will EVER feel as horrible and broken-hearted as Brooke did, would be if she(Brooke) had cheated with Jake...anyways I've always wanted Brathan..sooo hot together...sucks they can't be a couple=(
Peyton and Lucas were extremely ANNOYING in this episode...there should definitely be less of them....so we can have more room for the hot people.....Sophia and James have great chemistry..soo cute together...I wish they had more friendship scenes...
One more thing...to Brooke: You BETTER punch Peyton the way you punched Rachel after she punched you...so she'll learn to "never hit you again"...but then again the writing is coming from a "Peyton Fan"....*shudders*....My Gawd he just has total favortism to a certain 2 ppl...and that's just unprofessional.....I'm done with this show...I can't take it anymore....I REALLY REALLY hope sophia leaves this show and goes on to movies...Mark is wasting her talent on stupid storylines.......PLEASE SAVE OUR SOPHIA!!!!!!!!!!!!

Brooke=Slut and LP=Heaven.
Peyton and Nathan were still together whilst Brooke had sex with Nathan. Nathan was a jerk back then and Brooke was just a whore. Haley has no reason to be angry with Nathan. He didnt even no about her at the time, or care about her for that matter.
Rachel is such a good friend and I cant believe that she is going to leave. Thanks Mark, for killing off the best character of the show.

I felt so bad for Mouth. I really did, I think its bogus he gets the short end of the stick so often.

Oh Nathan.... Nathan... how many chicks in Tree Hill did you have sex with ??? I hear the dogs barking.... are those the ones your pack ??

I love that Karma has its way of coming back around... Oh I'm sorry did it just slap Brooke upside the head LOL.

Dude. I'm freaking SICK of the CW, or WHOEVER for CONSTANTLY SPOILING the episode in the preview!! It happend with the derek episodes, with Daunte hitting haley, and NOW with the sex tape. you ALWAYS know whats gonna happen. Can you for ONCE not have a preview that is basicly an Episode SUMMARY!?!?!?! PLEASEEEEE

irony of all ironies...brooke helped nathan cheat on peyton way before peyton and lucas cheated. karma. ha. i was so mad. im really not all that big of a fan of brooke anyway, and the fact that she is a huge hypocrite made me dislike her even more. and i feel bad for haley too because her and brooke were really close before rachel came into the picture...i find it hilarious that brooke has been horrible to peyton for a year for the exact same thing that she did to peyton. very good episode though. i loved it. i felt so bad for mouth :( skills was hilarious when he walked in on them. and i LOVED haley slapping rachel! that was the greatest thing i think i've ever seen.

I feel that the sex tape was a good idea. And, I'm very angry with Brooke, because she did the same exact thing that Peyton did to her, only before Peyton betrayed her. Brooke betrayed their friendship first, and treated Peyton like crap. I also liked how Brooke was shocked that Peyton would sign over the artwork. It proved, once again, that Peyton is a much better person, and friend, than Brooke. Nathan is an idiot, Nathan and Peyton together are my favorite couple, and Haley has no right to be angry. The others didn't even know she went to their school at that time.

drama,drama,drama.mouth finally loses his virginity but is heart broken,lucas and peyton wants to do it but but is again cut out because of some tape,brooke ,brooke she was my girl both she and peyton but now i can see whos a real friend and thats rachel.peyton have the right be mad at brooke iwould but thats brooke and i still love her but im sorry for peyton and all the hearts that got broken,but make sure that peyton doesnt kill brooke ,but this episode was fantastic cant wait for next week wednesday .love it

oh my gosh ,i would never believe it,nathan and brooke.although i like brooke ,just how how much i like peyton but to do that to your friend is wrong thats why lucas called her easy ,she is .peyton should never forgive her for that ,this episode was the bomb,well atleast mouth got some and rachel tried to the right thing for the first time . i am so sorry for peyton ,but this was the best episode i like it now u could see who brooke is a whore.

I love this episode shocking but awsome Brooke with nathen doesnt surprise me shes like that.

it was a good episode i guess, but im not sure about the nathan brooke thing its good if nathan and peyton were broken up but if they werent i dont like itit feels like mark wants people to like peyton more than brooke.comon how much are you going to take from the poor girl?

I can´t believe that mark would just throw in something like this out of the blue , I mean what the hell it´s just so people should like peyton more . It´s ridicolous I hate mark for the sex tape .

i think they should get real riskey and have brooks new boyfriend be gay and come out of the closet after sleeping with her....

this episode was great and full of surprises! The whole nathan and brooke thing--that was an absolute shocker. The slap that haley gave rachel. poor mouth...and lucas and peyton once again. I can only imagine whats gonna come next...

I loved this episode. I can't believe lucas and phyton, i thought they would wait. I feel sorry for mouth and rachel. I really think rachel was trying to be a friend this time around!

wow !! i loved the episodee !! i cannot believe the ending, it was SO good though. i feel horrible for mouth and rachel, but im kind of suspicious about rachel .. after all, theres got to be something in this for her. it sucks to be thrown out of school a couple of months before graduation. shes probably kicking herself in the butt right now. cant wait for the next episode, KEEP EM COMING !!! =]

i like