The CW Source

i loved the show but i gotta admit i dint want asia to win and i wanted melissa s to win she was really talented and i couldnt believ it when she was botted because she was way better than chelsea.

Are u Kidding Me u ASIA HATERS! - I think people like you made songs like the 'frog song' a success - sucky ppl.

ANYWAY suckers! ASIA WON yay! Melissa was beautiful but she was a weaker performer. They both can sing, they both can dance but I agreed with RObin when she said performance and stage presents would be the most important thing - Asia had that more then anyone else, Melissa too passive.

....And I don't think Melissa R would've taken attention away from Nicole... that's pathetic, like I said, Melissa's weaker performer, Nicole would've stepped all over her ass to the point where we would've forgotten there was ever a 'FIND THE NEXT PUSSY CAT DOLL' Competition.

...with that being said - 1 point to the MAMAZ!!!

Come on let it be the girl won.

hey um i really think that asia is going to mess up your group. you guys will sell less albums. so way to ruin it robin

hey robin! well first off, i loved that showw ! it was so awesome to watch. And i support your decission to pick Asia, she does deserve it. But my favorite was Melissa R, i loveed her to deathh, they both deserved itt, but i guess only one could have itt, if you do have another season for Search for the next doll, be sure to tell Melissa :p

Robin,

The PCD are talented, but I believe most people watch them because of how they look.
Melissa R is hot and would have brought in more fans.
I do not think anyone would even notice Asia.
Or they may notice her in a bad way.

Hey Robin. Gosh, at the beginning of the Search For the Next Pussycat Doll, my friend and I were like, Asia.. yes. Asia is going to win. So we were voting for her during the whole show. I love your choice Robin. Don't listen to those other people either Robin, those people going around being all "Bad choice, way to ruin the PCDs." and Asia, ignore it too. They are just angry because you're the new member and they're not. I'm so happy for you.

Well done ASIA, you are a good example toall us single mothers, that hey "follow your dream", that=s right you go girl. Let the jelous pigs and RACIST mother fucker cry! YOU GO ASIA!!!!!!!!!!!!! Hold your head up, and join the group. Love u and God bless.........

Hey Robin. Let me just tell you that I love and admire your creativity and personality. Coming up with the concept of the pussycat dolls was genius and they've been such a mainstream success. You're an amazing dancer also just like Mikey. Let me also say that im very happy with the choice you made and you really are great at choosing a pussycat doll. Asia will add more diversity to the group and something different. And although people say she had a bad personality I couldn't disagree more. She's a sweet shy girl who's been through and overcome a lot. She's very talented and very beautiful. Mel R and Chelsea were great. Melissa R was definetly the total package. But I feel that Asia was also she just didn't get as much airtime as Mel R. Great Choice!!! I can't wait until she joins. She's going to grow so much in the group.

Seriously, Melissa R had it all.. Asia is talented too, but when you compare the two, there is an obvious difference. I was so shocked by your decision Robin. If Asia had trouble getting along with the other girls, then i dont see how she would get along with the PCD.

Overall, the show was great. Somehow i felt like they already knew who they wanted to win this competition since day 1... No offense, Asia has her own beauty and talent.... but cmon, open your eyes and just LOOK. Clean out ur ears and jus LISTEN. See/Hear the difference yet? hello?

Pfft what a joke! Out of all the constestant they picked the ugliest, shortest and one with the most annoying voice! Sisley made a mistake in saying "she dances like a drag queen" I think she looks like one! Overall I just did not enjoy watching her. I would've have chosen either Chelsea or Melissa R. Way to ruin the Pussycat Dolls!

I want Melissa R. to win

Robyn it was your decision..However I think you should've put all the pieces of the puzzle together rather then a few. Asia is talented we all know, but has her limits. Also she has a daughter which may become hard to care for, while on tour. etc with the dolls. Melissa R is talented and she is there and ready to become a doll for your group. Overall you should shoot a show telling Asia she is out and give her money or something. And reveal to Melissa R. she's in...If she still wants to be!

Wow Robin.. you made the worse descion ever. And by that, all the people in my town hates your group now.. Just because Lil`Kim likes Asia doesnt mean she can pick. YOUR THE MANAGER AND SHYT! Even Mr. Ron Fair said so! Hes more important cuz hes a producer! And whats Lil`Kim? A girl that went to jail? Uhm Yeah.. I thought so... Melissa R totally rocked it. You made a suckass descion.

Your loss anywys.

You all should be ashamed of yourselves..Asia won and she deserved it..Just because she is biracial does not mean she's not talented!You all are a bunch of haters!Yes, pun intended!Grow up!!And get a life!Stop trashing someone you don't even know!

Omg i didnt want asia that fugly to win i wanted chelsea!! chelsea looks like a pussycat doll not asia!! (P.S) u rock chelsea keep up the good work! and keep smiling!!! =)

hi robin why did you pick asia mellissa r was apost to win not asia and asia is not pretty. and hey you robin old lady your a jackass.

Melissa R sould have won! Asia is NOT good for the PCD! They have lost a lot of fans beacuse of asia! Everybody here in Norway wanted Melissa R to win!

oo ma days how could u robin..how could u choose asia to be next pcd...shes a bitch

i used to love pcd but now i hate it coz of asia. how could she be in der.. she dosent deserve dats melissa r should've won that. wts wrong wit melissa r..shes have everythin to be a pcd.she pretty..she can sing.. she can dance
even asia is jelous of her because she better than her.

What were you thinking Robin ? Asia ? Come one.. Melissa R won by miles. She had everything. No offence to Asia but if she misses her baby so much, y join in the first place when u know ur gonna be even busier when ur in the group....DUH!!!

ROBIN i cant believe u choose asia to win... EVERYONE WHATS MELISSA R to win, on the internet, the whole world wanted to her to win, everyone see's her with talent and U DONT ROBIN? Did u know ASIA IS A BITCH? she is rude and she will make the PCD Kick her out . Well if you think Melissa R would look like Nicole too much, you never know what nicole thinks? did she say she didn't want melissa r? no she didn't,
MELISSA R was Grown to be a pussy cat doll, but you had to blew it, you had to choose mean rude ASIA, DID U EVEN REMEMBER she had a baby? HOW can she take care of her? Cant you tell asia is not a responsible person? SHES JUST 18 and she has a baby with NO DAD.. how could she fit in the PCD?And her voice sound so bad, Especially when she was singing Too Little Too Late by jojo.. Melissa R has talent in everything.. she can sing dance and has the look... BUT U BLEW EVERYTHING AWAY ROBIN, if melissa r was in the pussy cat dolls, everyone would be buying the C.D, but U HAD TO PICK ASIA! NOW I REALLY HATE THE PUSSY CAT DOLLS...

i think melissa R should have won...i think every1 felt guilty becouse asia is black ghetto poor arse no hoping single mother clearly melissa R should have won her face dosnt look like it has been hit with a fry pan

OMG like why didnt melissa r. win? geez asia is a bossy inconsiderate person and the dolls will have a difficult time getting along with her. she doesnt even know how to speek proper english.shell be kicked out of the group before i say DUH!
who ever agrees with me then just say yes OMG $$ then u might win $1000 dollars!

so anyways wtf were u thinking. watch the dolls split up becuz of her. she wont fit in with the gruop honestly shes is a dragqueen even tho i like hate sisly but still like she is soooo rite learn to dance like a girl BATCH

ROBIN YOU TERRIBLE PERSON YOU!

Sad that they decided for diversity in the PCD rather then talent. That's reverse racism if I ever saw it. Melissa screwed herself by sounding and looking so good on her last song. Imagine doing the best in a TALENT contest and not winning because you looked and sounded too much like the lead singer. How sad for her.

Congrats to Asia. Right color, right time. Sucks that they could have split the difference and found a talented black woman. Have your rainbow AND sound good, now there's a concept.

I cannot believe that Asia won of all people. I loooooved both Chelsea and Melissa R. and one of them deserved to win. I am soo dissapointed and I will never listen to the Pussycat Dolls again if I can distinguish her voice in any of their new songs. Asia should not have won.

Melissa R., Melissa R., Melissa R..... okay STOP! She didn't win and I know you think she deserved to win the most, but she wasn't sure if she wanted to be in this competition in the first place. She wasn't sure if she wanted to be a Pussycat Doll. The other girls in the competition wanted it more than she did. What is it going to take for you to see that? She's talented, I'm not going to lie, so don't worry about it. She's going to do something with music I'm guessing. And I know a lot of people are disappointed with Asia being chosen to be the next Pussycat Doll, but please cut her some slack. Give her some respect. You don't have to like her, but by saying negative things about her isn't going to change anything. The top three were amazing and they all have wonderful careers coming towards them.

damm guys Chelsea's she the #1 my hart is broken !
she the godess
anyawys this suck

asia just makes the group look bad and out of place....

asia should not have one she does not deserve it MELISSA R ALL THE WAY

I think they didn't pick Melissa R. because while she was the more talented performer, she looks and sounds just like Nicole. Why have a group of clones? As for Asia's singing does it really matter. I never knew the other dolls even sang.

WHY U GUYS PICK ASIA I WANT MELISSA R TO WIN

Whattt!!! That was the MOST ILLOGICAL decision I've seen on reality TV. The girl with the best combination should win, and that's Melissa R. Robin, I'm really disappointed in your taste. What made you pick Asia?? It was such an easy decision. Even Mr. Fair said that Melissa R was (and still is) the full package. There was no reason whatsoever that she should be a PCD. She can't sing and she tries too hard. Then again, maybe you're just looking for a backup dancer. But if you were, you would've picked Mariela (no offense, Mariela, I really love your dancing). Either way, I don't get it!
Well, for Melissa R, maybe this happens for the better. I hope she'll lead a solo career or be a leader of her own group.

I would like to know what are Chelsea's plans now.
She had the most beautiful personality, charachter and drive of them all. and can she sing I sure hope a door opens for her, she has overcome so much and I would love to see her blossom even more I am proud of you Chelsea!

i totally agree with the ppl that thinks melissa r should've won..and as for robin choosing asia cuz melissa r would affect nicole's attention...i agree with that too. it makes sense doesn't it? ahaha

melissa r. keep believing!! u'll become successful someday =)

why didnt Melissa R win?I like her better than asia.asia has a daughter and she might have no time to be in PCD.Melissa R better win!!!!!! -her #1 fan

You guys suck for not picking Melissa R. You just lost at least 100 fans by doing that...all my friends are refusing to support PCD just because you picked the worst singer because Lil'Kim liked her...what a joke...what does Lil'Kim do anyway....HUH:(:( You guys definitely screwed the pooch on this one...ASIA SUCKS

Robin, The 3 girls are great. It's sad that you had a difficult decision to make. We're sad when you didn't choose Chelsea & my other son when you didn't pick Melissa R. Is just that we grown to see Chelsea compete. She may not be a strong dancer but she dance & move gracefully and her apearance is unique to see up there. I'm pretty sure that if you practice with Chelsea, she would be perfect w/the rest of the PCD. And also by Chelsea not winning, we thought that you would pick Melissa R. No offense, Is just that now Asia won't be able to spend time as much as she should w/her daughter. Robin, at the end, we're happy that you made one of the girls dreams come true.

i think melissa R. should have won, she deserves it more... she has it all the bod, the voice and the moves... she would easily fit in with the PCD damn!!!! how could you not pick her...then maybe you could have had another vocalist? lead singer for the PCD!!! it's your loss!!! I definitely think that melissa R. and chelsea would really succeed even though they did not become the next PCD, hey what the hell maybe they could even outshine the PCD!!!

Asia more than anyone deserved to win. THe others had "potential." And potential was not enough to become a member of the Pussycat Dolls. Asia's talents will soon be discovered, and in fact because of her the group will become even better. She is bilingual, and recording in Spanish would be a plus for the Pussycat Dolls. BTW, her mother is Puerto Rican, and her father, is half Black and half Filipino. All you haters, you will see, Asia is the best choice.

i dont rele care who one they were all good but i liked chelsea an dasia the best. but that doesnt matter cuz i only watched it to c mikey he is sooooo hott if only he wasnt gay...

what dogged me about Robin was that she said Melissa R. is a "deer w/ headlights". This really explained how "Asia" was chosen to be the next pussy cat doll and that Robin portrays herself as a slutty, sleep around executive manager which explains the pussy cat dolls. I guess things in the end turn out what they are to be. I do not even know how Asia would take care of her daughter at the same time travellng on tour as a pussy cat doll. Melissa R., you deserve better!! With such great talent, Melissa R., you'll achieve your success!!

robin dont listen to these people u made a wonderful choice. u know what u whant and u got it

Robyn sucks!

Let me tell you the honest to god truth. Robin wanted
Melissa R. to win. All 3
judges knew that Melissa R should have won. But she would DEFENITELY take alot of attention away from Nicole and Robin doesn't want to do that. But she dam well wanted Melissa R to win. The girl was absolutely beautiful in her finale performance. Please let Robin see this message, because she knows!!!