« Hidden Palms Premiere: What'd You Think? | Main | Smallville: Season 6 DVD News »

One Tree Hill: Who's the Crazy One?

Lucas grapples with the truthOkay, OTH fans, we're wondering something after last night's episode. Why is it that Lucas looks so crazy while Dan, the murderer, appears totally cool and confident? Clearly, Dan has more experience plotting and scheming. But does Lucas really think he can convince people that Dan killed Keith by telling them that Abby came to him in a dream? The guy has got to get it together or he’s going to lose his mother to Dan…forever!

Last week, most of you said Lucas had to tell someone what he knew about Dan. But did he go about it in the right way? And is it too late for him to change his approach?

Plus, what'd you think of the rest of the episode? Are you pro-Brooke and Chase? What about Peyton's LA internship offer -- should she take it? Discuss! And get a full recap if you missed anything!

VOTE: What should Lucas do to convince everyone?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/18696

Comments

I LOVE BRUCAS,, WE WILL SEE THEM IN SEASON 5 PLEASE MARK PLEASE(VI LOVE YOU )BRUCAS FOREVER <333
LOVE THEM

i just want that lucas and payton stays forever they are cute :)

lucas and brooke both agreed that he was the guy for her..and remember the scenes that peyton cried for jake and once lucas called jake to turn back for peyton..but the same lucas get jealous when he thought that brooke is getting away from him and becoming felix's girlfriend.and the first time lucas cried for a girl was for brooke..when she said that they were just friends.and lucas is the guy hat brooke cried for.the real love is between lucas and brooke, i think... there should be a wway to get them back together in this 5th season...

BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS FOREVER.
seriously i think peyton is an idiot shes just so depressing and its unrealistic all the bad stuff thats happend to her, and i think people are right when they say that i could never go back to been best friends with the person who like sole the love of my life away from me TWICE!
i just dont think shes a best friend at all.
like the end of series 3 she should have just kept it to herself. i would never do that to my best friend.
so i think brooke is an amazing person to even talk to her.
and hers and lucas's relationship is just plain crap.
its just fake.
brucas had realy love.

i would that brooke be in real loveeeee with lucas!!! or chaseeeee

i thank for season 5 that peyton and lucas should grow apart from eachother. And he spends his time hanging with Brooke and they become closer friends so they grow closer together and lucas realizes that what he had with her was real and wants her back to be with. And that Brooke and Chase well Brooke can leave and Chase will have to move away. And Jake returns with Jenny who is like almost 10 or something like that or 7 and we can see what she looks like and Peyton can see him again and he can go peyton i've missed you forever I don't want to let you go. And peyton can be like I love I miss you I thought i was happy with lucas and all but I was really happy with you it just took me time to test or relationship and it was true. And then well Dan can still be in jail and Karen can move on with her life. And meet someone knew or not too. Her Deb can become better friends.

i thank for season 5 that peyton and lucas should grow apart from eachother. And he spends his time hanging with Brooke and they become closer friends so they grow closer together and lucas realizes that what he had with her was real and wants her back to be with. And that Brooke and Chase well Brooke can leave and Chase will have to move away. And Jake returns with Jenny who is like almost 10 or something like that or 7 and we can see what she looks like and Peyton can see him again and he can go peyton i've missed you forever I don't want to let you go. And peyton can be like I love I miss you I thought i was happy with lucas and all but I was really happy with you it just took me time to test or relationship and it was true. And then well Dan can still be in jail and Karen can move on with her life. And meet someone knew or not too. Her Deb can become better friends.

i love lucas i would love to be in hialary burtons place

BRUCAS, BRUCAS,BRUCAS,BRUCAS,BRUCAS!!!!!!!

okay maybe lucas did something out of the norm but he was sexier than ever when he did it!!
i love lucas scott!!!! aaf

the only crazy one is dan and that girl who said brucas fans are crazy. and just to annoy that girl more, BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS BRUCAS!
so last nights episode was yet amazing...yet again!!! i've never seen a crapy one tree hill, you wanna know why? because it doesnt excist.

hello people? you're the ones who are crazy!!! if you're in HS and you've experienced that much drama, betrayal, accusations, near-death situations, lies, backstabbing and blackmailing as Lucas have, you would also get really confused and frustrated. while it's true that pointing a gun at someone, no matter how evil they may be as is dan, is wrong, you can't blame lucas. Wouldn't you feel the same anger and desperation if you see your mom kissing your beloved uncle's murderer? wouldn't you be as mad if your mom believes the murderer of her child's son over you? come'on people! if you put yourselves in lucas' shoes, you would probably resort to something similar as what he did. if there's anyone who's crazy, that's Dan! no doubt about it! so use your head people (if you have one)! LOL!

i still think that dan is the crazy one. and how about brooke telling every1 about the stolen test

So, after watching last week's episode i thought about things. Lucas wont go to jail because that would kind of end the show, then what would they do next season? I also dont think that Lucas shot dan, obviously he tried to but dan was bending over so i dont think he got hit with the bullet. I also think that Karen might die and the baby will survive, but if that does happen, who gets the baby? Then again, i dont know if they would kill keith and karen both in the same season.so if you think about it anything could happen. I just hope Lucas doesnt go to jail and stops acting crazyyy.
I think Brooke and Chase should be together, they're cute together. I'm thinking that Peyton will take the internship. I think it's a little strange that Lucas told Peyton, no matter what happens she will always be in his heart or something along those lines, then he went and got that gun, i was beginning to think he was suicidal, but then he tried to shoot Dan, and i began to think maybe he knew he'd be going to jail or something. i dont know this show is getting crazier each week and there's only like what, 2 episodes left.

I thought it was the season finale! When I realized it wasn't I was soooooooooooooo glad! Lucas couldn't have shot Dan because it would end his own life, but hey, he has been a demon of a dad,so who knows,but those writers who have us all just dramatized right about now!

For all the Brooke/Lucas fans - has anyone ever thought about WHY their chemistry was so hot? It's because they were married in real life at that time. When they did love scenes, you could tell by looking into their eyes that they weren't "acting" they truly loved each other, and that's what we all miss. With Peyton, Lucas is just "acting" and so we don't see that chemistry. It's the same when they got their real-life divorce. When they had break up scenes, you could see the real life pain in Brooke's eyes when she was kissing him off. You just knew when she was telling him to get away, she meant it for real! I would love to see Brooke and Lucas back together but we doubt that will ever happen since they are divorced. I don't like Peyton and Lucas either. Their love does not seem genuine to me and they find so many reasons to be apart from each other. They don't get a lot of togetherness on the screen either. Bring Jake back. . .

Ok.. the reason all of you seem to think that the love between Lucas and Brooke was so REAL was because for a time in real life it WAS real so of course they had lots of chemistry together.. but do you really think that with their current situation now with Chad seeing another woman that they are going to hook them back up on the show.. kinda aukward dont you think? Lucas should stay with Peyton and Brooke with Chase.. either that or Brooke with Chase and Peyton with Jake and Lucas can go it solo or find a new love interest! Why does it always come back to this love triangle with those three? Sadly Brucas is over.. in real life and on OTH.. I loved em too but its time to let it go folks!

i agree with RJ i want it to go back to lucas and brooke i love those two together!!!!!the seasons two and three were the best season five is going to be great if it is a combination of those two it would be the best ever!!!!!!!

dan should go to jail, end of story, he killed his brother, dan scott is crazy! HE SHOT KEITH! anyways, i want brucas back too! they should go to the police!

I didn't like Lucas's reaction right from the point when he found out the truth from Abby. she says it was Dan, and he says you have to tell someone. no way! He should have gotten pissed like he would have in the first two seasons. Nathan and Lucas do not seem to have the personalities that they did in the first two seasons which sucks. Bring them back in season 5. we want original One Tree Hill

I think that Lucas went about this alllll wrong. First of all, right after he found out, instead of acting on what he knew, he went to Nathan's press conference and seemed to be concerned with other things. Then all of a sudden he gets a gun and tries to shoot Dan? Blurting it out like he did was all wrong. I think that he should have (and still should!) tell one of his friends, like Haley or someone. Hopefully they'll believe him. And the REAL Lucas Scott (the one from seasons 1 and 2) would have rushed right to his mom's side when she collapsed. Lucas needs to have more of his original personality! As do most of the characters

i think that the crazy one in ONE TREE HILL is........................................................................ Really its KINDA hard because of what happened on the most resent episode with Lucas and Dan with the making out and the gun and the gun. I would be freaked out tooooooo if I saw my mother making out with the man I hate most but besides that i want to see what happens on the next episode with Dan and Lucas and the mom oooooo and that BABY.

You have got to be kidding me. I didn't think this was a discussion about Lucas + Peyton + Brooke, I thought it was about Lucas being crazy?? Ha, could have fooled me. It's done, let it go. Brucas fan are freaking crazy!

Anyway, I do think that Lucas was not in his right mind. He just found out that the man kissing his mom murdered her unborn child, I'm not sure I would have acted any differently. Good for him for standing up for what he knows, maybe now someone will listen to him if he is this passionate about it. We all know that Dan will not die, duh, he is the villain, the villain can't die. I just hope they don't kill Mora off.

i just want brucas back, and lucas cant kill dan, he cant go to jail, and he has to be with brooke!! i love them together, and i like jake and peyton! and where did jake go? he disappeared off the earth?

Oh NO Sabs!!
That's not the way it went. Lucas had a crush on Peyton but when he tried to do something about it she told him to go to h***. Brooke hasked Peyton about what she was going to do about Lucas and Peyton said and i quote "He's already fair game", giving Brooke the go with him instead. So Brooke started the whole dating thing with Lucas first therefore when he hooked p with Peyton he cheated, ergo Peyton stole Lucas from Brooke.

Ok Now that that's been clarified.

What is up with Lucas????
He's supposedly very smart, he should know that making accusations without proof, evidence, witnesses, anything, is not going to convince the police or his mother.
He should grow up and be a man, because right now it doesn't look like Dan is going to pay anytime soon. What he should be concentrating on is finding Abby and keeping in touch because maybe in a few years she might have the guts to come out and say that she witnessed Keith's murder. Although, it still might not bring anything because of the time that has gone by since the murder and the witness coming forward.

Now that that's said. Can we please focus on Naley for a minute!!!
I feel so sorry for Nathan and Duke. And he probably could be spending time begging whoever he has to beg for a chance, he's talking to Turner about Haley's valedictorian speech. Now that's a man!! And we all love him for it. They are soooo in love; trying to help each other behind each other's back is so cute.

Now what is up with the whole Brooke/Chase senario??? Mark we love you but the show's next season better feature some heavy Brucas to make up for THIS whathever that is, because there's no chemistry at all.
And let Peyton go because her relationship with Lucas seems wrong, like a Dawson-loves-Joey situation.

sorry, i have to say this to RJ, that peyton did not steal lucas from brooke first..

if you watched season 1, Lucas and Peyton had something going on... and Peyton told Brooke, but Peyton at the time was still rocky with Nathan. When Peyton wanted to tell Lucas how she felt, she found out that Brooke went at Lucas. So if anything, Brooke stole Lucas from Peyton, not the other way around.

it's so hard to decide. when lucas and brooke were together they were okay, but a lot of things kept going wrong. i like leyton, but i also like the idea of peyton and jake getting back together. oh,and, yes, lucas went about exposing dan all wrong. he needs to tell his friends so that they'll be there for him and back him up with what he has to say.

Lucas need to get better proof. You know, find Abby and make her talk to the police. And he really needs to tell his friends about this, they could shourly help him out.

LEYTON!!! LEYTON!!! LEYTON!!!
Hottest couple, EVER!!!

I really want to se brucas back to! what they had was real. and brooke is cute with chase too but she belongs with lucas in the end. they are the cutest couple ever!
peyton should be with jake andno one else.they are ment to be. in season two it was all good, naley jeyton and brucas. thats what we want!

I love brooke and lucas together, i think they should go and find abby..while peyton goes to LA, and she will find jake there, and brooke and lucas should get back together, and jake and peyton. brooke shouldnt go to LA with peyton. and dan will go to jail

LEYTOOONN!! I love leyton!
Brooke should be with Chase. I like them together. I wanna see more of him. :]

YEsssss, Lucas does seem REAAAAALLLYY crazy. I mean if I were in the detective's and karen's position, I would have thought so too. Oh please,, couldn't he think of soemthing better then "abby came into my dream" He sounds like a lunatic. Anyways, i hope dan dies! And karen lives!!

yes i definitely agree the love that was between brook and lucas is just not the same as the love b/w peyton and lucas, i strongly believe peyton belongs with jake and brook and lucas belong wit each other. the love b/w lucas and brook was soo intense and real. BRUCAS FOREVER!!! and i think lucas is doin the right thing by confronting dan someone has to do it and plus he's goin through alot right now and he needs to let it all out, especially if its the truth. he's just acting upon wat he thinks is right i would do the same thing.

p.s. i STRONLGY agree wit RJ, BRUCAS all the way! and i hope all the good memories comes bak in season 5.

yess im liking what im seein here. you guys are so right, lucas needs brooke back. its so true what you said "its a different thing loving someone and caring for someone" and plus i dont think he loves peyton at all i think he feels risponsible for her.

I agree with Anjela. Yup Lucas was acting crazy but cmon man I was like "It's season 4 after all".
Looking back, I don't think Lucas acts crazy though. He's lost, and he needed answers to his questions, now he doesn't understand what, why... He's lost. Hopefully, in season 5, he'll grow up and get over it. He'll also remember he's the guy for Brooke Davis, and that loving someone and caring for someone are two different things. Duhhhhhh he needs Brooke back. And I need my Brucas back!!!

BRUCAS is dead! LET IT GOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Haha, anyway, i dont get why the writers made Lucas come off so crazy. I do think Karen believed him, its def nagging at her. But perhaps its just easier for her to believe otherwise. Think about wat it means for her, she pushed away Keith for yrs only to realize that he was her soulmate too late. He was killed and u let the man who walked out on u help take care of his baby only to find out it was him that murdered Keith. I'd be pretty comfy in my denial too....

This episode kind of creeped me out not only leyton haha pucas i mean but because lucas was acting all crazy.
I dont like brase they just dont click for me that could also be because im pro brucas all the way and I always will be pro brucas.
So im striving for brucas season 5
!!!!
<3 i miss them :(
But yeah this episode kind of creeped me out.
and lucas at the end like pointing the gun and then his mom colapses and doesnt move to go see if shes okay.
like helloooo?
and brooke and peyton talking about pucas together is just too weird for me i could say right now that if my bestfriend ever did to me what peyton did to brooke TWICE i wouldnt be all buddy buddy no matter if peyton LURRED a stalker into her life like hello its called turn off your webcam.
season 4 all of it was just really weird for me im praying season 5 can return to our season 2 and 3 OTH that I miss so much.

BRUCAS<2

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "n" in the field below: