The CW Source

lindsey isn't meant to be there...she is just trying to fit in with the gang and she shouldn't.
lukas should be with peyton or brooke NOT lindsey!
it just aint right..sory

Doesn't anyone notice that Brooke mentions how much she loved Lucas in most episodes. She is obviously just hiding her feelings because of Peyton. I hope Peyton stands aside and lets them finally be together.

Wow. The majority of you here are immature and have so much to learn. What are you 12? Peyton was int he wrong. She was cruel, nasty, etc. Lindsay did nothing to deserve Peyton's wrath. The fact that you don't like that she is in the way of PUCAS? Well too bad, that doesn't automatically make her a worthless person. You guys are pathetic and sickening! GROW EFFIN UP!

As for Peyton apologizing. She only did that because Brooke and Haley jumped all over here.

peyton, selfless? that is a laugh! she's a selfish hag! she kisses lucas when he's with brooke, then when he's with lindsay? she doesn't care about anyone's happiness but her own. the only reason she said those nicer things to lindsay was because brooke and haley made her feel guilty.

as for pucas having chemistry? they don't. they look awful together and their acting together is just....fake. mark has even commented in the last blog that sophia and chad have the best on-screen chemistry. THAT is a fact. peyton needs to go to georgia or something. lucas n4eeds to suffer alone, and brooke needs to be with chase or owen or someone who is actually a good man.

I hope Lindsey leaves Lucas at the alter! They are not soulmates and Lindsay needs to step out of the way so LEYTON can get back together!! Leyton = TLA

okay, wow, some of you guys get REALLY angry, especially you whack-job leyton fans. its pretty pathetic that you guys have to bash our ship, BRUCAS, because your so concerned about leyton. its fine if you like them together, thats your choice, but dont say that brucas was never meant to be together or that they never really loved eacvh other because thats crap! lucas spent two and a half seasons being in love with brooke! and if you didnt notice, the only reason he got with peyton in the 4th season was because SHE had to tell him she loved him first, and he knew he couldnt have brooke anymore so he SETTLED for peyton. now, have they had a relationship thats worth something since then, yeah. but dont say that brucas never meant anything because it did. i mean, we all have strong opinions about our own ships, but that doesnt give us the right to bash any one else's ship ESPECIALLY when we ALL know, lucas will ALWAYS love BOTH peyton AND brooke no matter what, he just hasnt ever really decided between them.

as for lindsey, theres nothing wrong with her. i know the leyton fans hate her because shes "in the way" of the two, but shes really a good character. what peyton said was out of line whether she knew about lindseys dad or not, lindsey had tried multiple times to be nice to peyton and stop the fighting but peyton was too hurt and too blinded by her rage that should be directed at lucas.

and also to the other brucas fans, this might sound like im pro-leyton, im NOT, at all! im totally BRUCAS, all the way, but i just dont like it when everyone is bashing each others ships, its pointless.

ok...well i think we will get want we want in the end....LUCAS AND PEYTON FOREVER please!!!!!!!

Hopefully Lindsey will question Lucas about the comment made by Peyton, regarding the ring. Then hopefully Lucas comes clean about the ring being the same one he proposed to Peyton with, and both Lucas and Lindsey avoid making a big mistake. Lucas needs to stop acting like an idiot and follow his heart back to Peyton. Mark, make it happen. Their chemistry is undeniable.

Ok, i totally dont feal bad for lindsey!!!! i love leyton and lucas has no brain or heart, we all kno he loves peyton, ugh....

i love this show and have watched it from the beginning and i love all the characters and think nate and luke are hot. peyton and brook are a laugh and think they have fight in them.

it is always fub to watch a fight. i feel sorry for peyton as her and luke made a good couple and now he has someone else.

love the show and cant wait to see the rest.

wtf. MISCHKA I WANNA PUNCH YOU YOU BUTT DONT YOU DARE SAY THAT ABOUT PEYTON. i love her, she is so selfless, it takes an amazing person to do all the things she does like give up lucas cuz he says hes "happy" and then tell lindsey all that bullshit to make her happy and keep LUCAS "happy". ugh i am NOT liking this dumb storyline i used to think leyton were perfect for eachother but look at the bull lucas makes her put up with after he knows shes been through so much already, cant STAND him :(

I think this was deffinitely one of the best episodes of this season. So many of the library scenes were so funny especially with Mia. anddd TIMMMMMMMMMMM!!! when I saw Brett Claywell's name in the opening credits I got soo excited. It was cool to see him again and i hope there will be a ilttle more of him in the future.

I love Peyton and realize that its hard as hell for her to be around Lindsey, but some of the things she said were out of line. When peyton told Lindsey not to laugh at Tim, which is what started the whole big fight, I think she was not fair in saying that. I liked at the end how Peyton and Lindsey made up. I don't think they're gonna be friends now or anything but I think they're done with hating each other. And I have to admit that I do like Lindsey more now then before. Shes nice and clearly loves Lucas but shes just in the way of Lucas and Peyton.

And when Nathan tells Haley about the kiss he should NOT say "i kissed carrie" because Carrie kissed him and tricked him into it. Lucas is more to blame because after Peyton kissed him first he kissed her.

The jamie scenes were great especially when he was walking out with the team with that hardcore music playing.

and i do not think carrie will be gone for longgg

love oth an the gang peyton did great in last show at lest she got to say something to lindizy or whatever her name i thing hes is one who is lame come on peyton is oth first charter liz is a bitch trying to fit into with the gang . as for carrie she a slut and she got something up her sleves i hope she dies or just diapper

i do not feel sorry for Lindsey actually she said all that junk about being engaged to lucas and peyton not when she knew that was going to hurt her! i do not like lindsey and i was hoping that she was going to get knocked on her a** last night! i wish
that peyton and lucas would get together again and soon!!

i enjoyed this episode. however, about the scott brothers being guilty for kissing other girls, im not sure about.... the girls kissed THEM. yes, they didnt tell lindsay or haley, but i wouldnt say there at fault for it happening. they are at fault for not telling them when it happened... not saying anything right away just makes it worse. =X nathan just digs deeper holes when he keeps things from haley.

i feel bad for peyton. it sucks about what she said about lindsay, but shes hurting. plus, she didnt know about her dad. i think both of their tragedies will bring them somewhat closer. it was noble of her, however, to stand up and make amends with lindsay. and for her to tell her something special about lucas giving her karens ring was sweet.... even if it was a lie! lol. i guess we'll never know for sure. unless they tell us in a future episode. :)

Lindsey landed as many low blows as Peyton, but, Peyton apologized 3 times!!!...Lindsey didn't!!! I can't stand Lindsey, she's not called out for the comment about Peyton being shot and "bleeding all over the library" but I'm supposed to feel bad for her because Peyton made a comment when she didn't even know about Lindsey's fathers death?!
I love Mia and Peyton! They are great together! More MPB scenes, too.
And AGAIN the BP moments were the best in the show!!
Hilarie's performances have been wonderful this season!! and she and Sophia work so well together!

I don't think Peyton was out of line. She didn't know about Lindsay's dad, so that wasn't her fault. And Lindsay was kinda mean to her anyways...
But I really loved that episode. Actually, so far in season 5 there was no episode I didn't love.
And all the actresses are doing an awesome job, especially Hilarie.

Peyton rocks and i think she was being completely fair about lyndsay. because she was trying to take all of peyton's friends and kept showin goff her rwing. maybe she was a little mean to mention lindsays dad but peyton had to go through two dead mothers. I love peyton and i think that lucas is an ass for lettign peyton go even when u can tell that she is hurting. that was the ring that lucas proposed to peyton with. how could a guy ask a girl to marry him then ask another girl with the same ring to me that is disrespectful and i think peyton knew that lyndsey would freak if she found out about the ring. i also think that the ring was the one keith gave to karen adn it has sentimental value to lucas.

That's a good point about the ring, Heather. That explains it if it's really Karen's. At least to me it does.

I think Peyton did overstep some boundaries but come on! The girl is hurting and to find out that the ring Lindsay is wearing was originally supposed to be hers?! That would tear anyone down. I don't think Peyton made up the thing about it being Karen's ring..I mean come on why make that up especially b/c Lindsay can just go and ask Lucas if it's true or not. AND to answer the question someone asked about if it really was Karen's why wouldn't Lucas have told Lindsay?....well I like to think that he held back on that detail b/c in the deepest part of his heart he knows his love for Lindsay isn't anything compared to what his Love for Peyton was/is and therefore couldn't compare the new LL love to what Keith & Karen had... b/c lets face it, living up to the kind of relationship Keith & Karen had isn't achievable in just the few years that Lindsay & Lucas have shared...

I love Peyton, but I have to say even I thought she was out of line.....HOWEVER, she made up for it. And she was hurting just as much, and she was wrong to jump off like that, but in the end they made it better. As for the ring...I say that it is Karen's that Keith gave her, but I also think that she just said that it wasn't the one that Lucas proposed to her with to make Lindsey feel better. I say that it is the one he proposed to Peyt with, because Brooke would know.

Aahh, anyway, it was a ffaaabuuulous episode in my own personal, extraordinarily biased opinion!

I actually think that it was the same ring and Peyton was just trying to make her feel better. Brooke would never have said that to Peyton if it wasnt true and we know that Brooke had the most time examining that ring. I think that Peyton is completely justified in her actions. She is fighting for the man she loves. I was once in that situation (minus an engagement) and i fought for the man i loved and i won. I think its only fair that Peyton gets a chance to do the same.

I loved the episode!

I wanted to punch Peyton. She was being so awful the whole time!

yea...Peyton made up the thing about the ring being Karen's

OMG peyton is such a horrible person!!! she's awful.
I love lindsay, she did anything wrong, she loves lucas that's all!!!
Brooke is amazing as usual, the best thing of this show is brooke davis/sophia bush, you are lucky to have an amazing actress in your f***ing show mark.
We miss brucas so much, i'm so sad.

I'm confused about the ring. It makes no sense for it to be Karen's. Did Peyton make that up? You would think that if it was Karen's Lucas would have told Lindsey that important detail. I really hope this isn't the last we hear about the ring.

This episode was basically terrible. I loved BP though! They're are my favorite thing about season 5. At this point I'd settle for a BP ending.