The CW Source

I love oth i like brooke and lucas but i cant belave what lucas did to peyton that was not right she loves him a lot you can tell. i dont trust her or that nanny at all. but the show is the best i love it so much i watch it all the time mark has done a great job so far hope he keeps it up. it was hard for peyton to let lucas go and to go talk to him in the gym

I Hate Hate Hate Lucas & I Hate Chad Michael Murray Sooooooo Much More!
Brook & Nathan Are Still My Fav's In The Show.. Love Them!
I Don't Like Lindsey That Much, It's Too Bad She Has My Name...

i hate lindsey.i hate lucas proposing to lindsey.what about lucas and peyton i thought that this season will show how these two souls will find thier way back and stuff.i'll hate one tree hill if lucas and peyton will not end up together.hmp!

one tree hill is myn favorite show but i want to say WHAT THE HELL LUCAS ASK LINDSEY TO BE HIS WIFE!!! he kiss peyton back and then when she says " YOU SILL LOVE ME DONT YOU." i know that lucas loves peyton. he is still in love with her we all know that

I was so upset that Lucas asked Lindsay to marry him, I want him to be with Peyton. I do wish that Haley would just fire the nanny before something bad happens, because her and Nathan and a great couple.

hey guys , nathen will cheat he dan son . haley story is boring come on de who show is werid i want seson 1 back were guys keep fighting i want haley to punch carries and i hope nathan get his butt kick by lucus wen he cheet , and i still thin k it going to be karen weding not lucus cause story line is quite old

Im so excited for this weeks episode...
man i hate that lucas wants to be married right away like doesnt lindsay think something is up. i bet she does and she realy likes lucas and she is going to get married earlier so she can claim lucas as hers and then peyton cant be in the picture anymore. but i soooo hate lindsay.. like get her and carrie off the show i hate them both but they do add nice drama. lol. and k-fed ahaha that was hilarious when he was trying to sing as a rocker so didnt work. but hes a good addition for dramma even though i hate him as well...
i hope we get a full season because of this writers stike.. please we need one tree hill

i think that peyton and lucas are meant for each other and deserve to belong togethere. lucas needs to face reality and see that peyton is the one that he is meant to be with and that lindsey is a girl for the moment and will never have what peyton has.

Well I read through most of the reactions to the recent episode and the season so far and I just wanted to share my point of view.

Firstly I love the jump of the show so far, it's unique and gives us a chance to see as fans where their lives have gone... but with that said.

The headliners up first, Peyton and Lucas, Brooke was right in saying Peyton had her Lucas stealing face on when she was at the airport, but at the same time. If she meant what she said she'd truly stay out of it and not encourage her best friend to go after another girl's guy again.

Peyton and Lucas I can honestly say should be together because if they're not they're just cheating on whoever so they can be together or leading others on... I.E. Brooke, Jake, Anna, Pete (FOB). My point being if they keep coming back to each other they need to just stop playing games and make it work... or better yet grow up.

Brooke and this whole Clothes over Bros fashion thing, it’s great and I like how this season she’s taking on more of the buddy role, seems that all of the girls fall into that role at some point? But Brooke it suits her with Lucas yet I can’t help feeling like she’s just kind of idle right now. Like being in Tree Hill has her acting out on old habits. Where was the Brooke that didn’t need to get drunk and met this great guy through Clean Teens… speaking of. I’m really hoping they get into what happened with Chase, because I was a big Brooke and Lucas fan till he came along. I’d like to see him pop up and remind her how independent she can be.

One more thing her Mother situation seriously Brooke clearly has issues with maintaining a healthy relationship, maybe that’s what happened to Chase… on either hand, she’s got to stop letting her mom get to her. At some point she has to see the pattern, Nice comment, compliment, put down, put down, harsh, harsh, mega beast mode and finally cold distant reaction to an emotional out cry and one of them walks away. I mean if I can have that mapped out why isn’t Brooke seeing it? She needs to turn her all seeing eye on herself and maybe flip it towards Nathan and Haley for five seconds since the nanny situation is under the radar at the moment.

This nanny situation I'm breaking into two parts, firstly, why isn't Skills the nanny, I mean he's seeming more and more like the suitable choice. He doesn't lie to Jamie, he's not using him for anything that could potentially damage him later in life and he's actually got great chemistry with the kid. Where was the consideration for him when they were looking for someone to watch Jimmy Jam?

Secondly this Carrie thing, Haley is too busy (once again) with her music to notice what is clearly in front of her. Nathan is too dense to stop anything from happening and Carrie is just plan talking herself up and using any little crack that she can get to make a doorway for her to get to Nathan. I honestly don't know if he's going to cheat or not, but I do know Haley as a woman should put her in check and while I'm on it, Lindsey as a so called friend to Haley should have told her the second that Carrie made that comment that night at dinner. My mom always said "never bring another woman into your house"

My honest reaction when I heard that was oh… yeah it wasn’t good. Let’s just say I’d have laid Carrie out like Q did Jason at Tric lol.

Speaking of Q is kind of annoying but has a lot of old Nathan qualities. I like how he’s the only one making comments about the nanny situation and stepping up and knocking out Jason. I can however understand why Haley flipped out on Nathan. She was clearly upset that it was a reminder of Nathan’s accident and she somehow must feel at fault for him not walking away. She’s got to deal with all those unresolved feelings or it’s going to eat up at her. I think they need a good knock down drag out fight and then some hot married action. I’m sorry I just don’t want to see mild flirting any more. I want the cute couple that’s made me believe in love and fairy tales.

What else do I have to say, Brooke's mom's crazy and clearly using her daughter, because generally if someone tries to point out what others are doing to someone it's because they don't want that person to figure out who's really using who.

I miss Karen and I want to see the new little Scott girl and I miss Deb surprisingly enough. I bet if Deb was around Carrie would be long gone! Dan I like the little bits so far and I'm curious where the writers will go with that. I actually miss Tim and I'm so sad he wasn't even in the fourth season, at least the episodes I saw.

Back to Skills for a few minutes, first let me say out of all of the characters I love him the best for his growth because he's not trying to be more grown up than he has to be like Brooke or Lucas or Haley but he's not forgetting he's still young see his moments with Jamie or the guys. I just wonder what happened to Bevin and why they fell apart.

I guess the one thing I hope is that whatever happened to Bevin and Chase and even Rachel isn’t explained in a flashback, I’d like to see them act as adults. So many unanswered questions, like was Brooke talking to Rachel or Bevin when she fired that model?

See if someone knows that’d be great to fill me in lol

Overall I wouldn't say this season is bad but it's not great either, I mean thus far only one Nathan and Haley kiss... come on if they're supposed to be getting back on track where is the focus and why is it every time music comes into play on this show Haley is off to the studio? I mean seriously didn't she learn from the Chris Keller situation, divide your time well or your marriage suffers.

anyways, I'm excited about the rest of the season... darn it one more thing (just keeps going on and on lol)

To the writers of the show and well just writers in general, I'm excited the strike is over and I was even more excited to hear that there's more to come with the show and as a writer myself. I understand that you want to entertain and touch people but at the same time you don't want to be disrespected.

So let me just say this, One Tree Hill as an entire show has been a great source of entertainment and escape from a rough day. It's been my music source and writing inspiration. I'm glad the strike is over and I'm glad to know that the show is going to go on.

This episode was interesting, but I would really like to smack Nathan!I mean the first few episodes it seemed as if Nathan was just blind to what Carrie was doing, she was so subtle about hitting on him that Nathan really was not sure if he was seeing and hearing what he was. Personally the scenes with Carrie and Nathan remind me of Rachel and Nathan right after the bridge accident. When he found out the truth from Rachel he just walked away, but why does he not do something about Carrie, he now knows whats going on!
As for Lucas/Lindsey/Peyton triangle, why does Mark keep putting Lucas into these situations, we all know how it will turn out. As for proposing, personally I don't think he did, Okay wishful thinking on my part, but I keep seeing the last weeks episode of him taking the ring out of the drawer and the flashbacks of his proposal to Peyton, and him dreaming that Lindsey came into the room and saw the ring and thought it was for her, he woke up. But what if it was the same this time, he was thinking of the kiss with Peyton, her words about still loving her, took the ring out while he was thinking, and Lindsey walked into the room, and being Luccas, he just did not tell he the ring was originally Peytons, just let Lindsey think it was for her? Just a thought.

I don't care anything I just freaky love and care brucas.. so the other issues nema problema...

Awesome episode yet again but Urgh! I hate Carrie so much i could break my tv! What on earth is wrong with her? Doesn't she get it; Nathan is married with a kid! And why is Nathan doing absoloutley nothing about it? Its as if he's playing along! Haley should fire her a.s.a.p! I soo want the old naley back with their cute moments. I think the whole someone trying to get it on with Nathan is soo old! They need to bring something new! And what is wrong with Lucas?!?! He's in love with Peyton whether he likes it or not! How can he be so stupid to kiss her and then propose to Lindsey. He's totally in denial!! And Peyton is being such a cow! She can't just kiss him and say you still love me don't you! Although i don't exactly like Lindsey, Peyton isn't great at the moment! I want her and Jake back!!!! :-$. That leads me to Lindsey - she can never take Peyton's place, ever! What's with the whole hair thing anyway?! Oh and i soo love Brooke and Owen they are soo cute and Owen is awesome!

lucas does not want peyton.

Ummm NO WAY FOR BRUCAS i LOVE Leyton!!! they are the cutest ever, well besides my favorites haley and Nathan.. i HOPE that nanny gets fired.. and SOON!! and i hope haley tells Lindsey about lucas.

Okay so,
it just broke my heart that Lucas proposed to Lindsay. He knows he's abosolutely making a very horrible descion and he wants Peyton more than he ever knew he did. So there :) And I think Brooke and Owen make a hot couple! On the Real! And Alice and Carrie can just go back to wherever they came from..

I would first like to say "Welcome back to the writers!" I as a fan appreciate what you do for me each week, by taking me away to a sleepy North Carolina town every Tuesday to share in the lives of the residents of Tree Hill. As a military spouse who's husband is not home much it means the world.
Second, this season is getting more and more interesting by the moment. I think that the storyline between Lindsay, Lucas, and Peyton is getting spicy. I think that Nathan, Skills, Mouth, and the rest of the guys need to throw Lucas a bachelor party with non-nude dancers. Maybe at the last minute the dancers cancel so Brooke fills in as a favor to Nathan and Mouth. One thing leads to another and Lucas and Brooke end up together for the night. They conceive a child together for real this time....and they get married instead of to Lindsay or Peyton. Lucas is boring with these two, especially Lindsay. It is like Lucas feels obligated to be with her since she made his dream come true by publishing his book. Peyton and Lucas are cute together, but Lucas has never expressed passion with Peyton like he did with Brooke. Brooke was there for him when Keith died, when he won the State Basketball Championship, when he went after Dan, and every other time he needed a shoulder to lean on. The relationship between BRUCAS was real, and they went through so much together. Lucas once said, "I told myself if I ever got another chance to be with you, I would never let you go." I want to know what happened to that Lucas. For a guy that seemed to care for Brooke so much, he gave up on her so quickly. He hardly talks to her at all now. Does he even know how Victoria is treating her? Why hasn't he tried to protect his "friend" like he always did for Peyton when she had family issues. Brooke deserves happiness too and deep down we all know she came back to Tree Hill for Lucas too. She even said that,"Lucas Scott is the guy I could have lost it all for." After all Brooke was there when his dreams have come true, in Tree Hill and New York. Please bring back BRUCAS...they are truly meant for each other.

I can't believe what happened on Tuesday.

Lucas is a jerk and he doesn't deserve Peyton at all. He kissed her and then proposes to Lindsey. Give me a break Lucas we all know you still want it P.Sawyer style.

Lindsey's hair? Please she can dye it until hell freezes over and she still won't be enough.

I loved the Brooke/Owen dynamic so cute and I can't wait to see something romantic happen between them.

Loved you guys comments.

I didn't like last nights episode at all, it was just awful. What Brooke said about Peyton going to get her man was just OOC she made it out to be as if Peyton's cheating was ok, and that's just wrong. She should have told her to handle things more maturly and tell P that Lucas's decision was what mattered in the end even if that meant picking lindsey. I hate the fact that the Brucas relationship is presented as if it never existed or meant nothing and that's not fair to us Brucas fans...we really don't feel like sticking around anymore. Brooke knows what its like to be in Lindsey's postion and making her out as if she's condoning cheating just seems so wrong on so many levels, especially since in season 3 she said that she knows what its like to have her heart broken and she wouldn't wish that on anyone even her worst enemy, so why do i feel like she's wishing it on Lindsey, though not intentionally though. Lucas and Peyton really need to grow up and with the way their treating Lindsey is just awful. If Lucas doesn't want to be with Lindsey who should be honest with her, not propose to her when he went behind her back and kissed Peyton. I really hope Haley gives them a piece of her mind.

I am just sad about the whole Lucas— Peyton situation. I really want them to end up together and I do not believe Lucas will marry Lindsey either way I am sad, it's Thursday and I am still sad about it. I am realistic enough to know that high school sweethearts come far and few between but gosh darnit this is TV, let's make is fairy tale!

We need Brucas back

I soo dont like CARRIE AND LINDSAY they shoudl not be in the show.
carrie shoudl back off of nathan and nathan should fire her or tell hailey whats happening. Also i dont like lindsay she shoudl leave or figure out that he only proposed because he still likes peyton. also i was wondeirng if the ring he proposed to her with was the same one he asked peyton to marry him with because that would be funny if peyton tells lindsay that that was the same ring and lindsay would freak. also i dont want thme to get married. leyton all the way.

i was SO relieved when nathan turned off the lights in the backyard. lol.. i kept whispering "turn off the light, turn off the light, turn off the light" and when he did, i was like YES YES YES YES YES YES!! lol
i was thinking last night, and this kind of happened before.. on nathan's bachelor party? the stripper wanted him too and he chose haley!
but that was just in the beginning of their marriage, maybe things have changed.. :s
lucas totally asked lindsay just so he could show peyton he's moved on. but he hasn't :p
mouth + mellicent = CUTE!
mouth + alice = no no combo! :p

and dude, what's up with those ugly shirts lucas has been wearing? lumber jack.. :p

although i'm rooting for leyton, instead of lincas (lol..).. .. .. BRUCAS!!!!!

OK! i almost wanted to throw the tv OUT the window.. i am like REALLY mad that Lucas cant just deal with the fact that he is still in love with Peyton.. when he was inlove with Peyton last time he still said Brooke was who he wanted to be with. Hes never been great with the girls.. even look back to season 1, when he went off with brooke because he thought she was more fun and less angsty.. or whatever. Peyton said she wanted to wait a year to get married. What is with Lucas and thinking they wouldnt last until then?? yet he still wanted to get married!?!? and isnt THAT meant to be FOREVER! but he cant wait ONE year.. and now hes saying she said no.. and has even got her saying that she said no (in this episode) SHE DIDNT!! The nanny needs the crap beaten outta her.. and she'll be kicked to the curb soon anyway.. Lindsay will realise that Lucas just propsed because he's too scared to let peyton in.. he even says in the promo that Lindsay will be his 2ND!! its like that movie 13 going on 30 with jen garner, the dude at the end chose the other girl because he couldnt hurt her and cared alot for her!! BUT yeah, lindsay will realise and leave him at the altar!! there wont be a wedding my friends.. Mark just WOULD NOT be THAT mean to us!!

There.. i said what i needed to, instead of breaking my TV.. i mean, its not the tv's fault.

I liked this episode, but I´m not sure what´s on lucas´ mind anymore.. I mean he has this look, when he looks at peyton, like the look he gave her right after their kiss.. and then his eyes just become cold, like he´s trying to control himself around her.. I still think he loves her, but he doesn´t wanna face it.. I loved that we got a some scenes from season 1, like haley seeing lucas and peyton kissing, just like the scene at the library in 1x13 I think, and then the last scene, peyton shows up at lucas´s door and she finds out that he chosed somebody else, just like the BLP scene at 1x09..
I really want Lucas and Peyton to end up together, they actually made me believe in true love and they belong together, lucas needs to realize that..
ok about Brooke, I loved her in this episode, besides the fact that she´s pro Leyton this season, I love the way she´s there for her friends even when she´s having her own problems too, and the storyline with her mom is really great too.. and I´m kinda looking forward to see Owen again :P
I hate Carrie, she needs to go, she´s trouble.. I hope Nathan just keeps on trying to be the best man for Haley..
and I really loved what Mouth did, how he finally understood that what he was doing needed to stop, I hope he gets together with Millicent, they´re cute together :)
anyway, I can´t wait till next episode, Leyton is breaking my heart :(

OMG! Where's Brucas, I want them bad so much! Who is this new Owen person I really dislike him, and the whole Brooke being a total Leyton fan sucks! What are you doing to Brucas fans Mark? Hopefully you have something good for us to make up for that horrible line that came out of Brooke's mouth.

As much as I love One Tree Hill ... The Scott boys are just idiots! (Am I allowed to write that?) Nathan is clueless! The guy either doesn't know he's flirting ... which he really should especially since it's been 4 years since high school and if you had a problem with it then, it should really be corrected ... or he's being stupid and playing with fire. I know that Nathan is never going to cheat on Haley but darn it! Why the heck is he leading the crazy nanny on!
And Lucas ... he is just ugh!!! Why do all these girls want to be with him?!!! Lindsey is the season 4 Brooke between Lucas and Peyton. Haley even caught the two of them together AGAIN! Girls should just stay away from Lucas. He is trouble!
I've got some respect for Mouth again ... Q was cool ... Kate/Mia sounded great ... Honorary Title was cool ... as for K-Fed .. I could care less if he came back or not. I wasn't excited or horrified him coming to the show and I still feel that way.
I love One Tree Hill basically because it actually gets a reaction out of me .. just like this episode!

What I want to know is why does it seem that Lucas acted more grown up when he was in high school than he does now that he is supposed to be older and wiser!?!?!?! What is he thinking? Peyton is his true love!!!