The CW Source

I LOVE OTH. I HAVE NEVER WATCHED A SHOW UNTIL THIS CAME ALONG.....OK SO NALEY ...LOVE THEM AND I DO HOPE THEY STAY TOGETHER AND AS SAID BEFORE ...EVERY MARRIAGE HAS IT'S TINY OR BIG THING BUT THEY BELONG TOGETHER. AND FOR LUC & PEYTON GIRL YOU ARE THE BOMB. OF COURSE THEY GOT TO BE TOGETHER....BROOK AND OWEN TOTALY. RACHEL AND DAN SHOULD HAVE STAYED IN THE PAST. AND THAT LINDSAY ...NONO.. SHE NEEDS TO BE BOOTED OUT HELLLLLOOOOOOO. I LOVE THIS SHOW SOOOOOO MUCH.

Ok, I'm so confused!!! I LOVE OTH...and after the episode where Jamie was floating in the pool when Nathan rescued him...WHY didn't they call 911???? And why wasn't ANYMORE said about that in last night's episode? It's like it never happened! Did I miss something?!? I know, I know...it's just a show, but if Haley had a son in real life and he was found floating in a pool, don't you think SHE would call 911 to have him checked out even though he started coughing up the water??!! That scene was really uncalled for...I'm for Naley working it out and Lucas and Peyton are destined to be together. Lindsey looks too OLD for Lucas...looks closer to his mom's age than his. I've thought that since they first brought her on the show.

I didn't like either of the vote choices.

I believe that yes Rachel should stay in NY in rehab, then go back to tree hill. "Nothing but trouble", is harsh, but everyone has trouble in their lives.

About asking for a divorce.

naley is such a cute couple i dont think they will get a divorse and rachel disorves a second chance but for dan he should rot in hell

I like Naley, because even though it is a television show it gives hope to love. Not just "Love" but to "True Love." What girls hasn't wished for a guy like Nathan? What guy hasn't asked for a girl like Haley? They make sense together, because they are different. This couple still has hope and I really hope that the writers give that too them.

True love is hard to find, and so when you have two characters that find it, you can't help but connect with them.

This episode was sooooooo sad for Naley, but I can understand where Haley is coming from........I dont think she really means it when she says "I want a divorce" it was just a weak moment for her with all the emotions of the recent months catching up to her, after seeing Jamie in the pool.........However, It may be a long long time before they actually reconcile and get back together, altough she should let Nathan Explain.

okey so naley fan i now u love dem cause i do but if de writer didnt cause some drama soon i would have puke . come on no marriage is bed of rose. so it good 2 see there marriage has it twist . cause all marriage do i think there will be find an if day split i do hope thay do cause come on wne last nathen kiss his wife ?? lol kidding no split but bring de drama writer u guy r great . i hate de part ware jamie said i wish nanny carise was my mommy i mean i though he was smarter then that . owen an brook noway i think he new rachel( from before they had a pass) there more suited .love one tree hill haley lucus nathan peyton brook , jamie, mouth, skill, karen, deb, whitey, even dan and and new cast fav is mai and millce

This episode had so much drama! My heart was already broken with Leyton and now it´s even more broken with the Naley situation. That nanny is evil and I hope she doesn´t come back ever! Nathan and Haley need to get passed this, I´m not sure if Haley overreacted.. she did have the right to be upset about this, but I also think that Nathan never meant for this to turn out like this..
I´m starting to like Owen a lot, he seems like a great guy and I think that´s exactly what Brooke needs right now.. and I loved how he helped Brooke with Rachel. I didn´t enjoy seeing Rachel like that, she looked so broken and hopeless.. and I think Brooke is doing the right thing by bringing her back to Tree Hill, she´s such a good friend :)
I agree with some of you about Lindsey, I´m glad she wasn´t on this episode, but I must say that I don´t hate her as much as I did when the season started lol
ok I still think Lucas and Peyton are destined to be together and I know there wasn´t any LP scenes in the episode but I just feel like I need to say that :P
and I hope they find their way back soon!

I tottally LOVE naley!!! i just HATE carrie, she ruined everything they had worked so hard to get through! Nathan is finally better and carrie ruins it! I love your podcasts because living overseas the only way i can watch promos is on your site thnx !!
NALEY FOREVER!
she did overreact!

omg One Tree Hill is my favorite show ever and i loved last weeks episode and at the same time i hated it. Naley and Leyton are the two most important reasons I watch the show. TLA like Peyton said "TRUE LOVE ALWAYS"... Haley's reaction to the whole Carrie & Nathan is reasonable, yes Nathan should have been told Haley about it or said something to Carrie himself. Nathans not cheating and thats the point he loves Haley and thats all there is to it and let's not forget that in season2 Haley kissed Chris Keller oh yea that was like b4 renewing there vowls and everything but still Nathan didn't kiss Carrie, Carrie kissed him and Haley kissed Chris so thats all I have to say about that. Now for Leyton, Lucas is in denial and knows that he wants to b with Peyton but because he always wants not to hurt anyone's feelings he puts them aside and he was wrong for leaving Peyton because she wasn't ready. Didn't he say in the end of season4 that he would wait for her nomatter how long it takes.... LIndsey is nice and everything but it's Peyton shes the one for him and Brooke and Owen r perfect, I think hes right for her, hes definitely what she needs.I hope for next weeks episode that Carrie doesn't go psycho and kidnapp Jamie.
tbc.....

I really think Rachel and Dan need to stay in the past. I never liked Carrie in the first place. When Carrie arrived, Mouth was dead on. You never hire a hot nanny. Expecially when she hits on your husband. Lucas really needs to get back with Peyton. Lindsey needs to go. she is to high sturng for Lucas. But I feel so bad for Hayley, I mean her kid isn't her biggest fan right now and also she thinks he manshe loves is cheating on her with her "Hot Nanny". I wonder what will happen with Mouth and Brooke's assistant

i don't think haley is over-reacting, she is only mad at his huband.I really hope that in the next episode they will be back together!!
I don't know if Rachel will be good for Brooke but she is being a good friend!I hope that lucas will NOT marry Lindsey because he's made for Payton!I think Dan is a bad man, he doesn't deserve to get out of jail!!
Ps: i loooove the character of Mia

I think Haley reacted normally. I can understand her, in that moment, being mad and saying divorce. I mean the way she walked in on Nathan and Nanny Hoe did look bad and then with Jamie. I think she was just upset at Nathan and said what came to mind. I think divorce is a bit to strong, but its because I get to see both sides. If I was in Haley's position though I could understand where she is coming from. But I hope she doesnt mean it. I hope it was just one of those in the moment Im mad kinda things. They so belong together and are the power and back bone couple of the show.

And let me just say im loving Owen. He plays that strong type of guy Brooke loves so much very well. I kinda like to see him with Rachel to though.

And what about Rachel and Dan. I love seeing old faces again. But Im wondering where is Karen and Lily. I mean her own son is getting married and she is out of the country? This episode was such a good bad one.

come on u guys . naley is cute an i love dem but luc said i something abt been a good uncle to jamie which make it me think it de end for dem in this seson maybe they will renew there vow lol. but luc not gething married somebody else karen or maybe brook . i am sorry for q . and owen an brook hell now they have no chem. love oth and naley but keep the stroy rollen

one tree hill is really good this season, but haley should have not asked foe a divorce.

i totally agree with B Hop!Haley was absolutely in the rite about the whole shower thing and calling for a divorce, cuz naley has been having trouble for awhile...i do luv them together and i think that after haley's reaction, nathan's gonna make some changes.at least i hope so.
leyton all the way, for gods sakes lucas y are you getting married to the wrong gal??

saying Haley was irrational was an over statement but saying they should call it quits is worse so I had to vote she was irrational though I think she should be angry and she probably needs time to sort through her feelings do I think asking for a divorce while holding a soaking barley breathing jaime was jumping the gun though??? Heck yeah she should be mad and she should kick nathan out for a while she should have held off on asking for a divorce until she cooled off once she had her head on straight and had a chance to think and to talk to nathan without yelling at each other and with out having jaime out of the room without supervision then she could come to a decision and if it were divorce then I'd be angry and still hope Naley would work it out but her reaction the other night was about 75% justified and 25% jumping the gun

I think that this episode was fantastic!! Bravo to the writers. I am so excited to have Dan and Rachel back! However, where are Karen, Lily, Chase, and Deb? Lucas is getting married and his mother is not involved at all? First, of all I hope that the wedding does not occur because I would much rather see him with Brooke. I think that Owen is sweet, but he would be great with Rachel. It is about time that Rachel had a good man in her life. I think that they would understand each other. As far as Nathan and haley are concerned, I understand why Haley blurted out divorce, but we all know that she doesn't mean it. Naley belongs together! Last but not least there's Peyton, and although she loves Lucas, I think that the next artist she signs should be her new love interest because of her love for music. They could make sweet music together. :)

dude im so happy that rachael is back. i think she was the best part of this episode. to bad she was not in it more. does anyone know how long she will be on the show? is she on it for good?

I really can not believe how many people think Haley is overreacted! You have to understand that the first thing that would come to mind when seeing the nanny and your husband exciting the shower together is CHEATER! Did Nathan cheat? No. Was he honest with Haley about his realationship with Carrie? NO! I absolutely aggree with the comment under me along with everyone else saying she ISN'T overreacting. I love Naley too, but I am not letting that cloud my judgement. What Nathan did was WRONG and I am not going to say that Haley is the one to blame. I think she asked for the divorce because she finally realized that she has to think about Jamie too. She will probably change her mind, but right now she needs time and Nathan should give it too her. She doesn't trust Nathan and he needs to give her space. Nathan should know about needing time and space considering he was once the one telling Haley this. I hope I have changed some of your minds on this situation.

I think that this episode was fantastic!! Bravo to the writers. I am so excited to have Dan and Rachel back! However, where are Karen, Lily, Chase, and Deb? Lucas is getting married and his mother is not involved at all? First, of all I hope that the wedding does not occur because I would much rather see him with Brooke. I think that Owen is sweet, but he would be great with Rachel. It is about time that Rachel had a good man in her life. I think that they would understand each other. As far as Nathan and haley are concerned, I understand why Haley blurted out divorce, but we all know that she doesn't mean it. Naley belongs together! Last but not least there's Peyton, and although she loves Lucas, I think that the next artist she signs should be her new love interest because of her love for music. They could make sweet music together. :)

I know everyone thinks Haley is over reacting, but you have to look at it from her perspective. She Walked in on her husband & another woman exiting the shower together, then nathan said it was just 'flirting'... come on now. Any woman knows that if you walked in on your guy & another girl, you would be FURIOUS & would not listen to a word he said. Then when she DID actually try to listen to him, He told her there was no more & didn't tell her about the Kiss. So She felt more betrayed when the kiss came up. I don't blame her for being angry ONLY because I know she doesn't know both sides of the story and why should she believe Nathan when the evidence says differently?

i loved this episode

though i don't want haley and nathan to get a divorce, i think that nathan needs the scare, the scare that he might lose the poeple that he loves.

but i really hope that they don't end up getting divorced!

and i can't wait for more about rachel

Haley is just acting crazy. Her and nathan belong together.

This episode was amazing, I must admit that i was severly pissed off and screaming my head off at the tv but that is what i love about this show it gets me crazy with excitement, however i am mad at haley. She makes me mad. Nathan has done nothing wrong if they dont fix this Naley thing im going to be mad!! I really wanted to morph into the tv and kill that nanny!!!! She makes me soo mad!!! Another thing that makes me mad is the lucas and lindsay thing, but they didn't really focus on it in this episode. I hate them together!! I hate Lindsay! and Carrie!!! but anyways I LOVE THE SHOW!! But I guess thats all!

omg i hate the nanny.
Haley should not have asked for a divorce.
i am an avid one tree hill watcher....but if nathan and haley break up i cannot watch it anymore, it will be ruined.
i LOVE NALEY..always and forever!

Totally loved the episode!!! Glad to see Rachel back. She always had some real issues but deep down I think there is a really great friend in there. But what the heck is Haley thinking!?! Nathan should have told her what was going on from the get go but I think a divorce is a little extreme. They just need time to work it out. It wasn't Nathan's fault that their nanny went all "hand that rocks the cradle." And Dan just needs to stay in jail. He is bad news for everyone! They have enough problems without his meddling. BTW hope we get to see Karen and Sophie soon.

I dont really think Haley overreacted considering she only had chris keller and told nathan about the kiss without him confronting her but nathan had rachel who he got a little too close to and carrie who he never told haley about
either way theyre perfect for eachother (thats why I didnt vote for the no choice) and should work through this

so glad rachel is back. the show isnt the same without her. :) good storyline pickup for her too. shes an interesting girl.

OMG! ONE TREE HILL KEEPS ON GETTING BETTER EACH EPISODE WTF haley is gonna realize its a mistake their forever and i know what happens in episode 12 AND its probaly gonna bring them back together oh and i also herd 2 ppl help them work things out AND THAT NANNY IS A BITCH OMG I FEEL LIKE KILLING HER FUCK IM NEVER GONNA HIRE A NANNY THATS YOUNGE ! hehe.

I kinda think that Haley isn't over reacting because Nathan should have told her about the kiss and everything that have had happen, but in a way i think she is because i know deep down she knows Nathan wouldn't cheat on her. Carrie is a whore and she needs to get off the show, she cased Jamie to hate Haley. Carrie is a skank and she needs to find somebody else and leave Nathan alone. I think Haley needs to kick Carrie's ass and make her sorry for what she did to her and her family.

I think that Haley threw out "divorce" too quick but I can understand. It's not just the whole Nanny thing but I think that the past months (after Nathan's accident) have finally caught up with her. They haven't worked through those issues yet and here is another problem. I also feel that the whole Chris situation should be left out of this discussion. Yes there also was a kiss (or kisses) but that situation has been dealt with and it is should not give Nathan a free pass. I kow that Nathan did not do anything and that is where the problem lies. He should've done something sooner. The only thing he did was tell Carrie not to flirt anymore. He should've been honest, didn't he learn this lesson the hard way with Dante? That is the only big problem I had with this episode. When he says to Haley that he's trying to be honest but to expects too much. I did't like that at all because he's being honest too late and it almost seemed like he was shifting the blame to Haley.
So yes, Haley shouldn't have said divorce but her reaction is understandable and Nathan should've been more sorry.

HALEY IS GANGSTA! She grabbed Nanny Carrie by her hair and threw her out of the bathroom! I didn't know she had it in her! What a gal! However, I did think she was over-reacting when she asked for the divorce. And to be honest, I think Lucas could have helped Nathan out and told Haley that Nathan told him in the Gym that Nanny Carrie kissed him and that Nathan even said that he was going to tell her.

Lucas needs to not marry Lindsey! What is she even doing on the show. I don't like her character at all.

i agree haley really overreacted with nathan. now as for carrie i woulda done much more to her. She crazy to think that nathan loves her she a freakin psycho and she needed to be away from jamie anyway. But haley and nathan bet not get a divorce to me the show wouldnt be right. enough stuff has already changed too much.

oh my..

yesterday's episode is so.drama thriling..

i didn't like the fact that haley caught nathan an carrie..but its pretty awesome that nathan maintans his hot body..haha..it was so heartbreaking wen jamie sed..he wish nany carrie was his mom..awww..how i wish..i can enter the tv and kill carrie myself..grr..

for the scene of peyton and mia..i love mia..so much..but i think she is going for a tour in real life...i think that was her last episode..i love there strategy..it mark my day..i will miss her..

for dan..im excited for his revenge comeback..but i wish there was new bad guy that will rumble the lives of Oth Characters..

I love Owen and brooke..now i'm starting to be convince..they should be a couple or something..they have a nice chemistry..and i love owen..he is so hot...but i got a question?does he know rachel??it looks theyre frends or watever..

>lablab..Oth..

HOLY CRAP!! that was an episode filled with HUGE drama..ugh carrie is such a homewrecker!! i hope naley doesnt get a divorce..its 'always and forever'..poor jamie.

i really hope nathan and haley don't get a divorce and i hope that Carrie just goes away for good... she's so dumb and i hate her!

I dont think Haley should have asked for a divorce but Nathan definitely should have said something about the nanny to Haley along time ago, so they could've prevented all this from happening. As for Dan i definitely think he should be released, yes he is a bad person but he definitely makes the show more interesting. And i am so happy that Rachel is back!

Okay, last night's episode was insane!! I believe Haley was overreacting with the whole divorce situation she randomly blurted out in the end, I think she just felt that way in the heat of the moment.

I was so excited to see Danneel Harris' name during the opening credits! I screameddd! I love her!! I'm glad they brought her back!

I think Dan should get out ofjail b/c I believe he changed & I'm still disappointed that he & Karen never ended up getting together last season.

Sucks for Q that he messed up his hand.

The Peyton & Mia scenes bored me compared to everything else happening in the episode.

Owen seemed cute & all but I still say Brooke & Lucas belong together in the end. I hope no one forgot or lost hope on that!

Peace.

Ok first off, loving Owen! He seems really cool and him and brooke are great together! ... plus he's none too shabby when he takes his top off! haha

Second, from what I can see, all Nathan did wrong was to not tell Haley right away about the kiss that Carrie initiated. But if i remember correctly, Haley initiated two kisses with Chris Keller and left on tour with him! and she couldn't believe it when Nathan wanted to separate! Why is she doing the same now? Nathan didn't even WANT to kiss Carrie! I understand that Haley was upset about what Jamie said, and rightly so, it was heartbreaking! But she's got to get over this initial shock and let the poor man explain!! They can't get divorced!!!

shannon- if you go to youtube and type in NH 5x10, a bunch of scenes will come up from last night's episode, and the one that says clip 1 is the shower scene

OK OMG WTF is she thinking asking for a divorce. I could have come unglued when I heard her say that. After all the things that they have been thru shes gonna go and do this to him. Dont get me wrong, I love Haley, but this is gone too far. What are the writers doing to me? I cant take this. I mean Lucas wont take Peyton back. And I do not like this girl he is with. She doesnt belong. I am truly hurting inside for all my fave characters. Please dont let NALEY GO! I cant take it if they get a divorce. Please for the love of God get Lucas and Peyton back together. I cant watch him marry that woman. Im still broken hearted about the whole thing. I cried last night when I heard Haley say she wanted a divorce. I could have pushed her into the water. AND if that bitch Carrie doesnt leave OMG Im gonna push her in front of a moving truck!

This was the best episode of the season! So much drama! I loved it when Haley threw Carrie out of the bathroom and when Owen saved Rachel. It was so dramatic and when Owen was getting all wet... well yeah he was majorily hot!! Also, Dan needs to stay in jain. He doesn't belong on the streets. He's just plain evil.
I must say... it was pretty nice having an episode with NO Lindsey!!! lol. She needs to leave so LP can get married. :)

I hated the fact that Haley asked for a divorce. Nathan was wrong not to tell her about Carrie, but she should have been home more. As an ardent One Tree Hill watcher, he is not the Nathan at the beginning of the show. And they have been through so much; Taylor(Haley's sister), Chris Keller, Dan, Rachael. She should accept her responsibility in this. She should also remember when she was the one that needed forgiveness. It was good to see Dan again. He is one of those characters that I love to hate. I think that he is totally reformed, and wants to make it right with his sons, especially for his grandson. I really want him to get out of jail; not saying that he should not pay for killing Keith. I am not a big Rachael fan, so I have no comment on that.

Yikes! Haley finally reaches the breaking point, about time! Too bad it wasn't even Nathan's fault this time... and that they'll get back together after some time.

Don't be worried about LP, I have a feeling Lindsay will realize just how wrong that marriage is right before it happens and he will marry Peyton instead since evrybody will be there.

And Rachel rocks! I missed her so much during those 9 loooong episodes! I'm glad Brooke is taking her to Tree Hill, since that means we'll see her more but I think it might not have been the best idea. she'll have to watch over her 24/7. If Deb is any indication drug problems aren't that easy to kick in Tree Hill.

Last night was soo intense. I'm glad that Haley kicked Carrie out of the house, I would've kicked her azz the first sign of anything sneaky. Nathan finally did the right thing by telling her, but Haley's just overreacting to everything that's been happening.

Lucas is really pissing me off! Lindsay needs to GO AWAY! I loved LP. I'm totally rooting for them to make it together.

Brooke and Owen are TOO CUTE! Owen is hot, apparently intelligent, and has common sense (UNLIKE SOME PAST LOVES, like stupid Lucas). I'm interested in seeing how their relationship/friendship will develop.

And HOW did I know that Jamie was going to drown?? I think I watch too much tv..

Can't wait for next week!

I think that Owen and Brooke have some awesome chemistry! I hope that they end up together! I am so disappointed with the direction that Leyton is taking, I have been watching this show since it started and I hope that Mark quits playing games with these 2 already and they get together.

is there any way you guys could post the scene at the beginning with Nathan on the phone with Haley til when Carrie jumped in the shower with him and Haley saw? The tv channel was sketching out last night during that part and I was freakin out. Please cuz that would be amazing

Haley overreacted big time. Nathan and Haley have been through worse than this freaking physcopthic nanny. I can get why Haley would be a little upset but she has to know that Nathan didn't cheat on her, he just didnt tell her the whole truth. And when Jamie told Haley he wished that Carrie was his mama, it killed her. Nathan and Haley will no way ever get a divorce. no freakin way. always and foreverrrrrrrr.

and I wanna know how Owen knows Rachel?

Somebody needs to nudge Nathan and tell him that there is a 'we' in a marriage, meaning communication otherwise you will face the consequences of your actions.

Naley and the whole divorce talk, I think is a good idea.

A couple is always going to have problems and may even become separated.

I don't think Naley will get a divorce, but it would make good television if they didn't get back together right away.

I was yelling sooo loud at the tv last night it wasn't even funny! The stupid idiotic Nanny!! I mean seriously!! She has a really big problem and she needs to go away fast. Nathan and Haley better work it out as well. If they don't I will not be a happy viewer and unhappy viewers don't stay very long. I don't think Haley's feelings were wrong, she was right to feel everything she felt, but her hasty, yelled decision to want a divorce. Jamie is not gonna be very happy with her.
No mention of Q up there so I'll mention it here ... it totally sucks for him!!
I'm scared for next week.

Alright, so it was NOT Nathan's fault that Jamie almost drowned. Haley was the one arguing with him. And how dare she ask for divorce? Naley reminds me that there is true love in the world! They can not get a divorce!!!

There's no way Naley divorce ! Seriously, I think Haley is overreacting ! Okay, Nathan did something wrong by not telling everything but asking divorce ? No way !
Well, I'm so glad Rachel's back, even if she's in troubles. I love Danneel !
And about Dan, I think his place is in jail, that's all.

This episode was so intense, but can't they seriously leave Naley alone??? We all love them so much and watch for them. Gosh, they have to get through this and FAST!!!!

This was probably the best episode of the season. Why? Because of the raw emotion alot of the characters carried throughout the entire episode.

Nathan and Haley..that scene at the end just brought tears to my eyes. And I haven't cried during this series since the Season 3 finale. With everything that was happening with Haley, seeing that her marriage and family is crumbling, she was just so caught up with everything going on, the first thing that came out of her was divorce. Divorce..no, that should not be an option. Trial separation..possible. Getting back together after that...definately.

I'm really starting to like Owen. Getting to see more of who he is, not just the bartender at Tric. I think that him and Brooke seem to be building a very strong friendship. If something more were to happen, well..whatever. And Rachel. Poor Rachel. Feeling abandoned by her only friend. (Stupid Victoria). Well, I'm glad that Brooke will be there for her. Rachel was there when she truly needed a friend and I'm glad that Brooke is returning that favor.

And Dan...bring Dan back. I've missed that ol' you know what. Realistically, can he get out after five years? I wouldn't think so. But in terms of Tree Hill, I think he'll be back next episode.

Nathan and Haley belong together. He has been trying his best to change. Carrie needs to leave Tree Hill and never come back. Please keep Nathan and Haley together. It would be devastating to see them split. They are the only good couple in Tree Hill. Someone needs to set an example for the others. Please keep them together!!!!

oh man!! a divorce!!!!??? they have been thru sooo much and a stupid bitch is gonna break them apart. She is totally over reacting, she could be upset but a divorce thats insane. he didnt do anything wrong!! that crazy carrie is just plain nuts! i just hope nathan and haley stay together cuz thats how they belong!!

I think Haley is freaking out he didnt cheat on her and shouldnt she trust her husband not the nanny.

i loved seeing rachel again!! Dan well i like seeing him but he's better off in jail!!
as for naley...well so sad!! really hope that haley gets over it cuz nathan didn't do anything wrong (well not much, he didn't cheat on her at least...)