The CW Source

personally, i think OTH is a GIRLY show. Supernatural may be considered a GIRLY show but really its not. Its and action show. Oth what is it again a bunch of girls crying and a bunch of manwhores? i dunno you tell me. ♥ SPN ♥

Monster Movie was clever, funny, and original - great episode! Dean and Sam Winchester are what make it special!

The OTH episode was absolute crap. The storyline was incredibly stupid, the acting by CMM and HB was horrendous and it was just all around pointless.

Monster Movie was great. I mean come on, 'Brother, I've been rehymanated' Need I say more?!?

Plus the vampire was hot!

I thought OTH, SPN & GG were all good episodes but I'm voting for OTH. ONly because of Nathan/Haley, Julian & Dan. They were the standouts IMO, the rest was average. I hold a very large grudge against the episode because of the "pretty girl" line. As a BLer, it felt like they were stomping all over us.

I hold a grudge against the GG episode because it ruined the typical, amazing PROM episodes that we get on the shows. As a pilot, I thought it was amazing but I really wish it didn't take away from out beloved stereotypical prom episode.

Love OTH but that is the worst episode ever. I couldn't even watch it all.

Well said Matt.

Everyone has different tastes in things.

♥SPN♥

-- Joelle Davis

Because you don't like shows with a more unique fantasy/sci fi angle, doesn't mean that they aren't good shows. Smallville and Supernatural are what keep the CW alive.

And are you kidding me? One Tree Hill's episode was AWFUL and you are still voting for them? Need everyone be reminded this is a competition for the actual best scene rather than 'oh my favorite show! I'll go vote for them for no reason!'

Hey, guess what? I've never actually seen an episode of One Tree Hill that seemed original or a plotline that actually was interesting. Teen dramas... They've either been done before or boring as hell.

Yeah I agree that the OTH episode is the worst episode of One Tree Hill.

But, I will support One Tree Hill in every way that I can.

One Tree Hill is the best show ever made. It is realistic and you could learn so much from this show.

I really dont get what people find so fascinating about Supernatural. I have never seen a good episode of that show.

So why should Monster Movie be so special. That show sucks.

Not to mention Smallville.

If OTH wins this one, I'll just vomit everywhere. That episode was atrocious in every way possible. The Supernatural one is by far superior. Admittedly, the entire SHOW is superior to OTH, but that's beside the point.

Frankly, I'm amazed that anyone liked that OTH episode at all. 40 minutes I'll never get back...

I gotta stay true and vote oth on this one, although I do agree the dream sequence was unnecessary. and I was sad Peyton died, the whole Peyton storyline is that Lucas is always saving her. plus she's already been shot once, cmm could have come up with a wayyyy better way to kill her haha. I loved the naley scenes in here though! I enjoyed the scenes referring to past ones in oth history, especially the dock and quickie proposal with naley. and Dan and Peyton, really? but all in all a very good special episode. the supernatural episode would be my second choice, then gossip girl. truthfully I could care less about smallville. whatever go oth! btw one tree hill fans-- does anyone agree nanny Carrie should have been nominated for the bitch is back? sorry this is way off topic, I just noticed someones comment concerning victoria, and I totally agree ruby was a wayyyy bigger bitch.

Supernatural.

this was THE episode that mentioned the restoration of Dean's virginity ...NUF SAID!

Agreed with Charisna that Hilarie's acting was bad, her wig was bad, and Joy was pretty great singing. It was nice to see Dan back to being a normal "bad guy" and Mouth's entertaining death, but Gossip Girl wins my vote.

Supernatural or OTH but in this case i prefer OTH, this old Casablanca style is really good.

Usually, I would vote for One Tree Hill, but this episode was the worst episode ever. The only good part was when Peyton got shot, sorry. I hope Supernatural or Gossip Girl wins. I voted for Supernatural.

Supernatural was the only one who had an actual special episode that fit in with the storyline--OTH's was just really randomly placed and seemed to be mimicking smallville's old time episode; SML's toxic was just a long flashback (i'm a SML + SPN fan, too, and i liked that ep) and so was GG's.
My vote goes to SPN (also, Monster Movie was one of the funniest episodes of season 4)

How can you chose "Toxic" when it was one of the worst episodes of the season?

My vote goes to Supernatural, it was a suprising episode, very funny and I also loved the guest stars. Most funny bit was Sam confronting Dean with his secret wish of a Porkies II movie :)

Okay, first things first: EVERY episode of Supernatural is special, so it should win, hands down.

Secondly; as much as I like CMM, this episode was dreadful in every way possible. I hated every second of it.

And I don't care about the other shows.

SUPERNATURAL!!!

This one was between Supernatural and Smallville. I just did not like the "special" part of the gossip girl episode, and the fact that they wasted a whole OTH episode on a dream sequence was a total turn-off for me, no matter how many in-jokes CMM put it.

Sooo, although i LOVE Supernatural, i decided to throw Smallville a vote cuz Supernatural's gonna win anyway.

No, let's not take a moment for One Tree Hill's win for biggest bitch. That was a rigged poll. I was amazed at the sudden surge of votes whenever supernatural got close. I looked at the comments and it looks like some other people noticed it too.

Ruby is the biggest bitch ever. Victoria wasn't even a bitch toward the end of the season.

As for this sourcie... Anything but One tree Hill. Chad Michael Murray just made a waste of an episode.

Love OTH, but the acting of Chad Michael Murray was ridiculously bad in this episode. Hilarie Burton's accent was also really off-putting. The only good thing about this episode was seeing Joy sing again.

Therefore, my vote goes to Gossip Girl, as it's the only other show I watch.

i wannna know who you guys (the ladies of the cw source) want to have win

supernatural?