The CW Source

The heart-eating dog wins hands down!!!

At first I went WTF and then when it sunk in I couldn't stop laughing!!!!!!! It was so funny! Looks like Karma is a bigger witch than Dan!

Okay having seen the OTH one now, it wasn't AS weird as I orignally thought (I was imagining a god literally eating Dan's heart from his chest...) but its still pretty WTF

i lol when the dog ate the heart!! omg it was wtf and hilarious...very good tv writing

My WTF movement is none of the above.It was when the STUPID smallville writers had Davis all of a sudden a bad guy and trying to hurt Chloe and killing Jimmy. SO DISAPPOINTED!

I havn't seen any of these ones:( but I'm going with OTH because it sounds really WTF to me.

Well considering I actually said WTF (several times actually) when watching SPN, this is a no brainer.

Supernatural! I was really WTF when I saw that.

"Drinking demonblood" isn't WTF Moment for me. WTF Moments are that Sam did sex with demon and he killed nurse.

In all actuality, the Smallville WTF moment is HUGE because not only for 2 years did we have a completely different chararacter that they claimed was a comic-character but then he dies and then we're all WTF JIMMY OLSEN CAN'T DIE YOU RETARDS and they're like psych! haha jimmy's not the real jimmy yo! and we're like WHAT THE F***

I don't even know which one to pick. Minus the GG one, I think I had WTF moments with all of them. One Tree Hill was the most ridiculous, like, lol WTF?, Smallville had the confusing WTF and Supernatural was just WTF SAM? WTF indeed, to all of them. These are good choices. But I don't know which to pick.

Gotta go with the Dog.

I totally wasn't expecting the demon blood. And the fact that his junkie-withdrawal in 'The Rapture' effed things up? For the win.

Superb storytelling should always come out and Supernatural is the only show on this network and in these categories that has an amazing storyline.

Even though I haven't watched the episode yet, I'd have to go with Dan's heart getting eaten by a dog. Because when I read that it had happened it literally made me go "WTF?!"

Videos....???

Three of them would have my vote if I could do it that way but since I can't I went with SPN and Sam drinking demon blood.

I'd say the dog eating Dan's heart because not only was it a WTF moment in itself, it was a WTF is Mark Schwahn on crack moment as well. The Sam drinking demon blood wasn't TOO "WTF" for me because I totally saw it coming.

Oh, I ABSOLUTELY voted Supernatural! When I first saw that, I was so ridiculously pissed off. Well, first I was ridiculously CONFUSED and BAFFLED, but then I was like "GODDAMNIT, Sam! What the hell do you think you're doing?!?! Demon blood? Really? WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS TO ME?!?!"

It took me weeks to get over that. Literally. Weeks.

I understand it now. I don't approve, but I understand. But that was a tough journey, let me tell you!

Sam and the demon blood was the biggest "Holy Sh*t! WTF?" moment.