The assistant managing editor for photography of The New York Times made a curious comment in a Q&A published online recently that has set off a kerfuffle among some photographers.
In response to a query posed by a student photographer on handling overzealous security guards, she advised that it's best to shoot from public places, and then added: "You are prohibited from shooting
bridges and tunnels, less so the subway."
Now, in offering these tips, she was probably erring on the side of caution, since it's much easier to get out of a scrape with an officious security guard who misunderstands your motives if you carry a Times press card. And indeed, reports still emerge from time to time of photographers being hassled when legally taking pictures on the subway. But her advice has raised eyebrows.
Firstly, regarding the legality of subway photography, no less an authority than The New York Times itself wrote on May 23, 2005: "A proposed ban on taking photographs in the subway, meant to thwart potential terrorists, has been rejected as too broad to be enforceable, the police said yesterday."
Now, it's true that around the city's tunnels, there are a barrage of signs prohibiting photography. And a little Nexis research supports the idea that laws do prohibit photography of MTA bridges, too, but who is really going to stop that student photographer (or those countless tourists) from snapping away? (Well, this did happen shortly after 9/11 and may remain an issue today.)
To be sure, it seems the key questions are vantage point of the photo, and whether "sensitive" areas were being photographed. Still, the editor's comments, however well intentioned, seem to cry for amplification.
Here's reaction over at the Chezlark blog, who says the advice was "entirely incorrect or badly misleading". And there's more commentary at The Online Photographer.
-- Rolando Pujol
Have you been hassled taking pictures in the subways or around bridges? Let us know in the comments section. And the Chezlark blog pointed us to this interesting subway photography blog, Express Train.
Photo: Woman boards A train, by Newsday's Julia Gaines