"Enhanced interrogation" vs. torture

It's an old cliche that language is the most potent weapon of all.
If you can control what things are called, you can define and guide public discourse. This is something the Republicans learned well, exemplified by their skillful substitution of "Death Tax" for "Inheritance Tax." Makes it all seem so unfair. On the other side, "pro-choice" sounds much more benign than "abortion advocate."
The term "War on Terror" --which is really absurd when you deconstruct it-- was carefully crafted to act as a template for using military involvement to address a problem, when the rest of the world saw it as a law-enforcement issue.
The "what constitutes torture" debate that is going on right now is more than some abstruse argument over semantics. Its outcome will not only define what we intend to stand for as a nation now and in the future, but it could also have a real impact on whether or not certain people are going to be treated as criminals and sent to prison.
"Enhanced interrogation" sounds like a questioner who just shouts at you a little louder under the bright lights, not someone who is busy trying to fill your lungs with water. I heard somewhere that it was the Nazis who first invented the term.
And they sneer at Obama for emulating Lincoln.


Previous entry:
Next entry:
CHAN LOWE



Comments
I got a chill- a good one!- and a lump in my throat when I heard President Obama say, "This is the United States of America - we do not torture." It's just as simple and as profound as that.
Posted by: Beth Masino | April 24, 2009 9:55 PM
Andy Sullivan had a post on the Nazi use of torture where enhanced interrogation is discussed. Worth your read:
http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/the_daily_dish/2007/05/verschfte_verne.html
Posted by: Our Paul | April 25, 2009 9:23 AM
I got a chill- a good one!- and a lump in my throat when I heard President Obama say, "This is the United States of America - we do not torture."
I get chills too, but they are not good. Obama is the consummate politician, and he is lying. It is not simple. It is not profound. It is frightening to be living in the shell of what used to be a great country.
Bush made me miss Clinton. Now Obama makes me miss Bush. Heck, I'm starting to have fond memories of Nixon.
Germany was the most civilized country in Europe (possibly the world) at the turn of the 19th century. It always seemed strange that in two generations the people of Germany could have degenerated so far as to support the "Final Solution." Now I understand.
We seem to be split between people who seem to salivate at the thought of torture and people who are in denial, but completely support the government no matter what.
Posted by: Lolly | April 25, 2009 3:48 PM
We must be in the spin cycle, now.
Posted by: rev. marvin e. purser jr. | April 27, 2009 6:55 AM
Posting this to Facebook.
Posted by: Lois Lane | April 27, 2009 8:43 PM