by Mark Silva
On this Sunday when a candidate's church again has become the focus of his campaign - something which Sen. Barack Obama has attempted to resolve by removing himself from that congregation - many voices will be raised.
The Rev. C. Welton Gaddy, a Baptist minister and president of the Interfaith Alliance, calls it "a sad day in American politics and even sadder in American religion.''
Earlier in this campaign, another candidate attempted to reconcile the perception that many have of his church with his own views on religion and politics.
But for Mitt Romney, former governor of Massachusetts and a Mormon, it was a question about not one church, but rather about his faith and his allegiance to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He attempted to assert his independence while confronting public prejudices, particularly among the most conservative, fundamental Christians who comprise a significant base of the Republican Party.
For Obama, the Democratic senator from Illinois who is close to clinching his party's presidential nomination, it's not a question of his religion or even his church so much as what has been preached from the pulpit of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago.
The longtime pastor there, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, retires today - but not before laying a groundwork of doubt about his words on racial power and prejudice and what those sentiments might say about those, like Obama, who long sat in his pews.
And then came the Rev. Michael Pfleger, a visiting Catholic who injected yet more racial animosity into a campaign that Obama has attempted to raise above race. The Wright saga had prompted Obama to deliver his own sermon on race in America. But there are only so many times one can return to Philadelphia to take that pulpit.
Ultimately, Obama concluded that it was not enough to disavow the incendiary words of the Rev. Wright, or to distance himself from a pastor who had married him and his wife and baptized his children. If the pulpit of his church would continue to serve as a forum for divisive political rhetoric, he would have to extricate himself from the church.
Yet, just as Romney should never have to resign from the Mormon Church to revive his own political fortunes for another campaign, some say Obama should not have to resign from Trinity United Church of Christ to maintain his political credentials.
The problem, some say, is bigger than any candidate. It is the inevitable intermingling of religion and politics in a nation which attempts to uphold a devout separation of church and state.
"No candidate for the presidency should ever have to resign from or join a particular house of worship in order to be a viable candidate for that high office,'' Gaddy says. "To make such a decision for political reasons dishonors religion and disrespects the Constitution. This is a sad day in American politics and even sadder in American religion. Sen. Obama is at the center of the storm, but all who wed religion to partisan politics share responsibility for this tragic development."