Affordable House of the Day: Mysterious Shirley ranch

The bad rap on Long Island is that there’s no affordable housing. Not true.
Michael Maida’s Shirley ranch home has a mystery: Who was Candido Vasquez?
Apparently, Vasquez was somebody in the 1950s, because he was the first owner of the house that sits on a street named after him, Candido Avenue, in an area that’s called Candido Heights on some Brookhaven Town survey maps, Maida said. In fact, the house address is 1 Candido Ave.
That’s all the homeowner ranch has been able to find out or needed to know.
He first learned about Vasquez when he bought the house in 1996 and needed to get town permits to renovate it. But he had no certificate of occupancy -- somehow the sale went through without it -- and the town didn’t have the document either because a fire in the ‘70s destroyed many town records.
He needed two witnesses to verify that the house had been existed for some time so he could get a new certificate of occupancy.
So his real estate agent Patricia Lorenzo of Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life in Shirley suggested he see if anybody at the local fire department.
As it turned out the day Maida went to the firehouse, an older volunteer firefighter who knew Vasquez was there. “My boy and his boy used to play ball on the street there,” Maida recalled the firefighter saying.
The firefighter also said that Vasquez owned some land in the community and gave some property up so that Sunrise Highway could be built, the homeowner said.
So Maida got the firefighter and his wife as the two witnesses for the certificate of occupancy, and they verified that the house had been around in the 1950s.
But while Maida was taking out some kitchen cabinets during the renovation, he found a slip of a calendar paper behind the counter. The month was May and the year 1940. That’s why the house has a 1940 birth date on the sale listing.
Besides the mystery, the home has a $279,900 asking price, three bedrooms and vaulted ceilings in the sunken dining room.













