By Adam Abramson
I had about 25 comments from the weekend and I wanted to pull out some points and address them. It's not real in depth, but I'm going to talk a lot about BCS picture/what a playoff would look like and the Heisman tomorrow, so I'm going to be cracking on that all night.
It's a beautiful thing when the Rangers, Islanders and Knicks are off. And A-Rod doesn't create any news.
Adam,
I'm sitting here watching the 3rd OT of the LSU - Arkansas game. I'm in a disagreement with a buddy about the wisdom of Nutt deciding to start the OT on defense. My buddy says you always pick "D" so you know whether you need 3 or 7. I'm thinking when your the underdog and run a better offense than a defense - it often makes sense to go on offense first. Make the other guy play catch-up.
What do you think?
I'll address this at length at a later date, but soon. I think this is a great topic for discussion. My first instinct is to always take D first, but let me stew on it some.
Considering Houston Nutt's Faux Pas last year in leaving WVU off his season ending ballet, I has a tough time rooting for Arkansas today... It was a great Win for WVU, but a better win for Ohio State. That "Terrell Pryor Bowl" is looking better with each game. http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/2005-12-06-notes_x.htm
I had the chance to see Pryor play while eating a Primanti Bros. sandwich on Friday afternoon and actually passed through his hometown on the way to the wedding this weekend. I have no idea how good Beaver Falls is, but Pryor made them look like the Little Giants at their first practice in the Pennsylvania state championship games. He was a man among boys and any school should instantly benefit from his presence on the roster.
And I finally made it up to Mt. Washington…great, GREAT view.
The way things are going, is it possible that USC & Ohio State could end up playing for the championship? Heck, maybe even Hawaii & Kansas or Missouri or LSU or Oklahoma. You guys get the point. Of course, just think how great all of these arguments would be if there was a playoff. What do I know, clearly, nothing, I am still smarting from the beating last night. The only thing at this point is will Hawaii-Boise State be higher scoring than Colorado-Nebraska?
At this point, I am going to refrain from assuming just based on this while season. It really could be anyone, and when computers are running the show, who knows what will happen on December 2. Logic gives us a clear idea, but we'll have to wait and see.
As for USC, I watched the Trojans play Arizona State and what stood out to me most was the youth at the skill positions. Joe McKnight really looks like he can be a version of Reggie Bush next season or the year after and those receivers are going to torch secondaries for a bit, but the whole group just needs some polish.
I'll throw up a post about this more within 12 hours.
Oh, by the way, with all of the upsets again, and the weekend is just starting (A&M/Arkansas), if Hawaii wins out, they have to go to a BCS game, don't they?
Yes. The win over Boise earned them that right. But we'll talk more about this tomorrow. There's just a lot to digest.
Adam, if you haven't seen it yet. This is the best penalty ever called in college football. Worth embedding if you're bored.
I'm bored.


Comments (1)
RE: Offense or Defense to start OT
Always take D. I know, I know, Ken Venturi always said he liked to hit the ball off the tee first to intimidate his competitor, and while that may work on the links, I'd rather know what my offense has to do with 4 downs and 25 yards. There's my two Abe Lincolns.
Now, on to the real question that should also be addressed when you give your take on O/D preference: which OT rules are better -- NFL or NCAA? I've had lengthy discussions about that very topic, and while I see some valid points in the NFL style, I much prefer the NCAA method that allows both teams to have the ball.
My argument is, in no other overtime rules is one team ruled out by scoring first except for NFL. Soccer teams both get all their PKs. Basketball runs the full length of the OT period. Even the US Open gets played on the next day, all 18 holes over again (see: Retief Goosen, 2001, Southern Hills). Give us your thoughts on NCAA versus NFL, then tell us whether we should trust Foster or Stinespring to win the game in OT on Saturday...