Just two weeks ago, the Islanders had lost seven straight games to fall to 13th in the Eastern Conference, and the buzzard scouts were hovering over the carcass in anticipation of picking the bones of a team that clearly was destined to be a seller at Tuesday’s NHL trade deadline. Six straight wins later, the Isles are hovering on the playoff bubble, still in ninth place but only one point out of a sixth-place tie.
So, what will Islanders general manager Garth Snow do come 3 p.m. Tuesday? Is he a buyer or a seller?
“Neither,” Snow said after returning from the recent league GM meetings. “I’m a builder.”
With a laugh, Snow said he got that line from a more seasoned GM who told him to say that if he didn’t know what the heck he was going to do at the deadline. But there’s truth in jest, and the line perfectly captures Snow’s position.
A year ago at this time, the Islanders were in the middle of a tremendous February playoff push that had carried them solidly into sixth place and had them thinking about gaining home-ice advantage in the playoffs. When the opportunity arose to pluck Ryan Smyth from Edmonton in the final hours before the deadline, Snow sacrificed his first-round pick and two former first-round prospects to make the biggest blockbuster deal of the day. It turned out to be a 24-game rental including the Isles’ first-round playoff loss.
That type of move won’t happen this year. Snow is committed to keeping the Islanders’ first-round pick in a very deep draft this June, and generally speaking, the top prospects who remain in the organization are ones he declined to part with last year.
But that doesn’t mean Snow won’t make some noise at the deadline this year. With forwards Miroslav Satan, Mike Comrie, Ruslan Fedotenko, Trent Hunter, Josef Vasicek and Chris Simon all in the final year of their contracts, he’s certain to receive some attractive offers, and if there’s a chance to add a first-round pick and a useful player in exchange, he could sell.
At the same time, Snow has managed his salary cap so that the Islanders have plenty of room to take a big-ticket player. If he finds a trading partner who needs that salary flexibility and will take one of his pending free agents in return rather than picks and prospects, Snow could end up as a buyer.
Although the Islanders’ winning streak has placed them solidly back in the playoff picture, it hasn’t altered the principles on which Snow’s approach to the trade deadline is based. He’s a builder.
“It’s weird,” Snow said. “A six-game winning streak changes a lot for us in some ways. But what I’m focused on is how we’re going to build a team that can win the Stanley Cup someday on Long Island. When you focus on that, the extraneous variables fall by the wayside. They get eliminated from your thought process. My only focus is on what’s best for the organization for the long haul.”
In the third season under the NHL’s new collective bargaining agreement, many top contenders find themselves bumping up against the salary cap and forced to act accordingly. That’s why Anaheim couldn’t match Edmonton’s offer sheet to Dustin Penner last summer and had to trade Andy McDonald to St. Louis this season. To Snow, his cap space should be valued as a trade asset in the same fashion as draft picks and top prospects, but many old-line GMs might have trouble accepting an approach that has become standard procedure in the NBA.
“I firmly believe that, if you want my cap space, you better give me a good asset for it,” Snow said. “We’ve managed our cap in a pretty good manner, and if somebody wants some of it, there’s a price to pay for it. It does have a value…It is a new system. Who says I’m right? Maybe I’m wrong, but it’s what I believe.”
Snow can’t comment on players who belong to other teams, but if you apply his logic to some of the trade rumors out there, it hints at how his strategy might unfold. The Isles need a top-line center, and Tampa Bay’s Brad Richards, who carries a price tag just under $8 million per season is rumored to be available. Richards is widely regarded as overpriced at that salary, but he would be attractive if the cost doesn’t include top draft picks and key prospects. Another overpriced player linked in rumors to the Islanders is Toronto defenseman Bryan McCabe, who has a no-trade clause. The Leafs have been desperate to unload him for more than a year. Are they willing to pay a price to do it? That remains to be seen, but it might take the Leafs' first-round pick to get the job done.
What can’t be overlooked is that the Islanders’ cap space remains a valuable asset to them, too, when it comes to making moves in the free agent market this summer. There might not be as many big-time free agents available because so many have signed long-term extensions already, but Snow is in position to compete for those who are unsigned and he won’t sacrifice his own flexibility lightly.
In that regard, the Islanders’ pending free agents would do well to study how Snow handled last season’s free agents. He made what he believed were fair offers to Ryan Smyth, Jason Blake, Tom Poti and Viktor Kozlov and didn’t negotiate up. Smyth took less money to return to the Western Conference, and while Blake received twice as much as the Islanders offered, his contract now is regarded in Toronto as an albatross. Poti and Kozlov got slightly more money, but their performances haven’t justified anything beyond the numbers Snow offered.
Asked about the progress of negotiations with his pending free agents this season, Snow said, “We’ve made offers. That’s as far as I’ll go.”
Obviously, Snow has a price and a role designated for his pending free agents. It’s up to them to decide whether they fit in the Islanders’ scheme. If they’re not signed by Tuesday, they certainly could be vulnerable to a trade. The exception is Satan, who has a no-trade clause, but he’s hot now and is bound to attract the most interest as a proven 30-goal scorer. One rumored destination is Dallas, but Satan, who has built a home on Long Island, would have to agree to any deal. Snow declined comment on the offers he has received.
Hunter, Fedotenko and Vasicek all have value to the Islanders, but all went through prolonged scoring droughts until they were put together on the same line. Now, they are performing exceptionally well, but where do they fit in the big picture for the future? That might be determined in the next few days.
If Snow has decided he’s a builder right now, then, he could go any number of directions in managing his assets. What will he do? “Whatever is in the best interest of the organization to build a Stanley Cup champion,” Snow said. “We’re not going to mortgage our future to try to get a quick fix. That’s why it’s going to be exciting. You never know what’s going to happen.”
ISLANDERS INSIDER LINK: Starting today, the lead item for the online-only Islanders Insider will be posted on the Islanders Beat blog. To make it easier for readers of the blog to access Insider, which is posted elsewhere on Newsday’s main sports web site, I will add a link to the full Insider once it is posted every Friday morning. For the rest of today’s Insider, including comments from Ted Nolan and Miro Satan on the trade deadline, please click here.